Don't Say That You Love Me: The TUSK Poll.

The Ledge, of course.

Best song on "Tusk" - Fleetwood Nac

damnit, that's what i get for searching for "tusk poll" instead of just tusk fleetwood.

mods feel free to delete.

fuck it. i forgot what i voted for last time, but i know it was a tough choice

LOL ian. you were on that other thread

This is always some random shit but I like to make sure that "I Know I'm Not Wrong" gets a vote.

it is clearly the sweep that runs from 14 --> 18, other poll results be damned.

eh, 16-20, really IMHO.

(aka side 4)

"What Makes You Think You're The One"

I love it when we end up redoing polls that I don't even remember us doing the first time.

maybe a mod could retitle this thread "Just Tell Me That You Want Me: The TUSK Recount!"

my answer stays the same as in the first poll. i know im not wrong.

hahah

"NEVER FORGET"

"Brown Eyes" this time. The McVie tracks need more love, ie votes.

Yeah. I want to see at least three votes for "Never Make Me Cry". You know McVie is the queen of this band.

But if you just can't help yourself and you have to play "Sara" again, I understand.

Also I love that fucking witchy shit from Ms. Nicks - "Sisters Of The Moon"

Beautiful Child - but ARGHHH, this is so arbitrary, they're almost all candidates

oh fucking hell I have still never heard this. where is my credit card? where is my wife's credit card?

ahhaha Talking Heads "where is my beautiful wife?" hahah

want to vote for all

title track is dope

"The Ledge" for me thanx

"That's All For Everyone"

My adoration for "Over and Over" is unwavering. I've also been spinning "Brown Eyes" and "What Makes You Think You're The One?" a lot these days.

I would like to retract any comments I made on the previous thread about the superiority of certain Camper Van Beethoven versions of the songs over the originals. I was so, so wrong.

"walk a thin line" got fucking robbed in the last poll.

I vote 15-20.

"walk a thin line" got fucking robbed in the last poll.

-- ian, Monday, 5 May 2008 18:33 (54 minutes ago) Bookmark Link

yes.

"walk a thin line" got fucking robbed in the last poll.

-- ian, Monday, May 5, 2008 5:33 PM (53 minutes ago) Bookmark Link

truth xp

Good thing I voted for it in this one.

I've seen so many things that made me wonder
But sometimes its hard to tell
I said
"Take your time"
But no one was listening
I walk a thin line

They told me that I never would recover
Still some say they knew me well
I said
"Stay by my side"
But no one said nothin'
I walk a thin line

I said
"Please toe the line"
But no one was listening
I walk a thin line

I said
"Fate takes time"
But no one was listening
I walk a thin line

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

Somewhat disappointingly, I do not get the love for The Ledge.

Missed my chance to vote for "Think About Me". Rats.

i) 4 people commented that 'walk a thin line' is deserving of a vote
ii) 3 people voted for 'walk a thin line'
iii) the title track ends up with the most votes

conclusion: ilm is lazy fukk this poll

Listening to the roughs and demos on disc two, starting to think that I Know I'm Not Wrong really could have had a much better mix for the album.

11. Angel 0
9. Not That Funny 0
4. Save Me A Place 0
3. Think About Me 0
20. Never Forget 0

oh ilxpaws

could say that about almost any track tbh xp, but then you'd have an entirely different album. Not 'Sisters of the Moon' though, the production there could not have been improved upon.

well, I know I'm Not Wrong strikes me especially because the big hook in that song is totally covered up in the mix (compare with track five of the demos disc). you just get a hint of it and then for some reason Buckingham decides to get all Glenn Gould and cover it up even more with some lackluster scatting

I only started loving "Never Forget" when Cut Copy included it on their mix last summer.

I already loved it to bits but I had a newfound respect for Cut Copy after that particular trick.

Piss -- if I'd seen this, I woulda put "That's All For Everyone" into a tie for first.

You guys I am ashamed that it has taken me until November of 2010 to hear this entire album. Thanking you Half Price Books for the $2 vinyl copy.

Well? Thoughts?

Well I'm only just starting side 3, but this is really amazing. I grew up with parents playing Rumors and later a greatest hits thing, so I'd kinda always thought I'd heard all the Mac I'd ever need. I WAS WRONG. This is great great. Loving "What Makes You Think You're the One" so much right now.

Also "Not That Funny", great song.

I'm just now coming to this album too. I love the use of alternating wide open spaces and claustrophobic sound spatialization in the production. "Walk a Thin Line" is the sound of driving home at 4 AM and trying not to asleep at the wheel.

the everything on "brown eyes"

This album has gone from being the underrated follow-up to Rumours to quite possibly being in danger of being one of the most overrated records ever. On here, at least, and I love the record.

danger!

nah it's the best record ever made

overrated = the exasperated hail mary pass of self-important arbiters of artistic quality

I'm confused here - did I not say I love the record?

And yes, it's a great record - well-performed, mostly well-written and impeccably produced. There's a lot to love and admire about it. On the other hand, it isn't completely devoid of filler, the Lindsay tracks aren't really as "out there" as some would have you believe, and I do think it's a record that, as great as it is, does get some over-the-top praise. Good record, though.

74. "Brown Eyes" and "Never Make Me Cry" are really the same song: the first relating the onset of a desire that can only lead to danger, the second the devastating results.

― Alfred, Lord Sotosyn (Alfred Soto), Friday, March 17, 2006 3:41 PM (10 years ago)

at any rate I'm glad the proto-Balearic bliss of Tango has replaced Tusk as the Mac album du jour.

"filler" is another problematic one.. i know what you mean, stuff like "that's enough for me" is underdeveloped and 'tossed off'-sounding. it's still better than frickin "don't stop". incidentally, christine's songs on tusk are much greater than christine's songs on rumours ("you make loving fun" excepted, of course). all imo, of course. signed, self-important arbiter of artistic quality

Mirage is now the underrated album of the Buckingham era, though it is not as strong as Tusk.

I agree that McVie's songs are Tusk's secret weapon - each one is a classic.

with our powers combined this summer, Tim, we'll change this state of affairs.

i saw this in a record store last week: http://recordstoreday.com/SpecialRelease/8342

Tusk's stature has really risen even in the last three years. Not a forgotten album at all anymore. I feel like it's about as well known as Rumours at this point. No filler on it. The underdeveloped experiments and the band's ability to stretch out are what make it great.

Three years?! More like twelve at least. Check out the number of ILM threads.

You're right. I feel like we've reached peak Tusk though.

'Honey Hi' is shite, though - nowhere near the level of McVie's songs on Rumours, definitely not a classic and the very definition of filler. So there's three theories debunked right off the bat.

*shakes head*

wow that may be your worst opinion turrican

oh look turrican is taking a brave stand again

this is the most mind-bendingly WTF poll I've encountered here. these results makes more sense read from bottom to top than top to bottom for me.

I'm not fond of "Honey Hi" either *raises chin defiantly*

Do you like Haim's rip off tho Alf?

yes!

"Honey Hi" sounds like waking up refreshed and in love with somebody

Love the Haim ripoff too, especially the "I'm not afraid no more" part

xxxxpost:

Well, if you truly believe that it's a better composition/song than 'Don't Stop', 'Songbird' or even 'Oh Daddy' (which is my least favourite song on Rumours by some considerable distance) then, y'know, you're entitled to think that, as utterly batshit as that stance is. Nobody, absolutely nobody sees a copy of Tusk and thinks "fuck me! I just have to listen to 'Honey Hi'"! 'Sara', undoubtedly. 'Walk A Thin Line', 'That's All For Everyone' ... yeah, I could see it. 'Honey Hi'? No fucking way. Inessential, airy fluff at best.

0 votes for 'Think About Me' ... what's that all about, then? It's McVie's second best song on the record after 'Over and Over'

"Airy fluff", yes - done perfectly.

"Honey Hi" sounds like waking up refreshed and in love with somebody

also known in physics textbooks as the McVie Dictum

McVie's tracks on Tango In The Night, though, are mostly awesome. Trying to imagine that record without 'Little Lies' and 'Everywhere' is just impossible.

As for underrated Mac albums, then Bare Trees would be my pick. I've always thought that one deserves more attention than it gets.

Zero votes for Never Forget is a sin

this is the most mind-bendingly WTF poll I've encountered here. these results makes more sense read from bottom to top than top to bottom for me.

― rip van wanko, Monday, May 30, 2016 9:17 PM (43 minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

THIS. How the hell did "Think About Me," "Not That Funny," and "Save Me A Place" for chrissakes get ZERO VOTES??!!

Also, "Sara" is great but "Storms" is superior in every way

ILM u mad

Also this is a front-loaded album if ever there was one. I pretty much tune out after "Sisters," though I usually skip ahead and jam "Walk A Thin Line," which is beautiful

the idea that any McVie track on Tusk is worse than "Oh Daddy" hurts my brain

Fuck, I meant Walk a Thin Line, which did fine! Sorry...

Also, "Sara" is great but "Storms" is superior in every way

thinking about these songs in this way misses the point of both I think. "storms" is a gorgeous, sad ballad. "sara" is a miraculous structure

"Honey Hi" rules. Great circular chord changes. Wonderful rocking chair of a song

protip for life--listen to honey hi first thing in the morning and u will have a mellow-ass day

― sex viagra cialis hard teen firm wet tight sexy rod unit teens hole suck (max), Sunday, September 14, 2008 4:50 PM (7 years ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

speaking of mellow, "Over and Over" is a shot of pure uncut heroin str8 into the mainline. How is this a perennial front runner in "best album opener" discussions, but places in the middle of the pack here?

worst poll

yeah i mean 'Tusk' is easily the worst song on the album

Wait there, Tusk song is a restless volcano. Do not diss it.

'Tusk' is great and you're wrong. Although OTM about 'Honey Hi' being "rocking chair" music, just not in the way that you intended.

'Tusk' is great but it's my least favorite song on the record. Maybe it's just overexposure. And honestly Lindsey bugs me on that one.

uuuuunnggggggghhhhh

The right answer is beautiful child!

just discovered this album last week. so good.

"Save Me a Place" got robbed.

fuck i wish i could hear "That's All for Everyone" for the first time again. i completely burned that one out. i think i listened to it 500 times in a single year

Insane that "Sisters Of The Moon" only got one vote.

Intense silence
as you entered the thread

all the various versions of "I Know I'm Not Wrong" on the deluxe set are a pleasure to listen to