Neil Young: American Stars 'n Bars vs. Hawks & Doves

aight i posted that show (with the acoustic shots) mentioned above http://doomandgloomfromthetomb.tumblr.com/
enjoy!

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

thanks tyler!!

Hawks and Doves = the album after which I routinely stopped buying Neil Young albums the day/or at least the week they came out. Two good tracks ('Captain Kennedy', 'Little Wing') as I recall. So for that reason alone, 'Stars and Bars'.

Oh, and I love 'Will to Love' and 'Trans' rocks. Classic NY.

I like "Lost in Space" on "Hawks and Doves" but the electric tracks are kinda lazy ho-hum stuff

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

Neil Young with The Ducks, 1977 -LITTLE WING - RARE electric version
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bZAVO4VR-ME

closer than i thought it'd be, vote H&D

ah, hadn't heard that version of "little wing"! amazing. thanks for posting.

if you're over thirty and born before 1950 you can't program synths.
--Gus Van Sotosyn (Alfred, Lord Sotosyn)

listening to Hawks and Doves for the first time.

why didn't people like this...?

yeah i don't know, must've just seemed kind of "minor" after the rust never sleeps period? it is a pretty great album, I think.

Neil's singing gets pretty unhinged and goofy at points

Hawks & Doves is the tale of two sides

side 1 is fucking great, side 2 suuuucks

bummer about american stars n bars is it's just a worse version of chrome dreams :/

haha, deep neil young nerd opinions.

it is though! i have what i *think* is a legit version of chrome dreams and it's soooo good, i'd honestly put that top 6-7 neil record had it been released

neil is going to announce the real chrome dreams someday and it'll all be stills-young band outtakes.

"i don't know what chrome dreams you guys are talking about, but my chrome dreams is all conga jams!"

The Young-Lala Band

Hawks & Doves is the tale of two sides

side 1 is fucking great, side 2 suuuucks

― My Little Pono (upper mississippi sh@kedown), Friday, September 13, 2013 4:15 PM (27 minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

otm. first time i listened to hawks and doves i was like holy shit this is fucking awesome, has that dark "will to love" fireside vibe. "little wing" especially is amazing. this feeling past halfway through the album once i got to "staying power"

xps mississippi what's the tracklist you have for your legit chrome dreams? (just want to match it against the one i hastily downloaded a few years ago)

i dunno, i enjoy the second side of H&D, even if it's pretty light.
there's a youtube upthread to the electric, ducks version of "little wing" -- here's a better quality SBD version
http://www.bigozine2.com/TRKSA2/DKS2scruz/DKS2scruz108.mp3
it is great.

http://www.geetarz.org/reviews/neilyoung/chrome-dreams-rust-insert.jpg

^ yea that's what i have

i kind of believe that's real, though on wiki, it says that joel bernstein says it's a forgery.

It's reported as being a fake in Shakey too. Neil says something to the effect of there was never a Chrome Dreams album or concept other than a David Briggs drawing with that title.

side 2 of H&D is definitely goofier than side 1, seems deliberate, doesn't bother me

on to Landing on Water...

Xpost OTOH, in the little liner essay on the RNS CD, it's mentioned that some of the songs were slated for the "unreleased Chrome Dreams album".

yeah who knows. this bit from a late 70s cameron crowe thing makes it even more confusing:

Neil Young, who writes virtually all the time, can look back and find all the movements of his life and career documented in his songs, some more cryptically than others. "My songwriting process has never changed," he explains briefly, as if talking too much about it might betray the muse. "I never try to write. I know when it's there. I hear a bell ringing in my head and I just leave ... but I don't try. Sometimes three months can go by...."

Some artists, I point out, have been known to get writer's blocks that last for years.

"Well, if that happens to me," says Young, "I'll take up gardening."

One afternoon during a tour several years ago, Young sat in his manager's hotel room. The phone kept ringing, tour crew members bustled in an out... and through it all, Young sat on the bed with his son Zeke, peacefully watching the news.

The broadcast was interrupted by an emergency bulletin. Pat Nixon had suffered a stroke, an announcer said over a filmed report of the sad and beaten Richard Nixon tearily moving through the hospital's revolving doors. After a time, Young got up and disappeared into his bus in the parking lot. Onstage several hours later, Young played the song he had written:

Hospitals have made him cry
But there's always a freeway in his eye
Though his beach got too crowded for a stroll.
Roads stretch out like healthy veins
And wild gift horses strain the reins
Where even Richard Nixon has got soul

The song was a first called "Requiem for a President." Young later changed the name to "Campaigner," and placed it on his three-record retrospective album, Decade. "Guess I felt sorry for [Nixon] that night," he said of the song while traveling on his bus the next year, just as 300,000 copies of Decade were being prepared for release within the week. "That album was a chance to use some of the unreleased material. Hopefully it's a greatest-hits album that's more like an album." Young laughed. "Should be timeless."

I wondered when he'd decided his first decade was over. He thought about that.

"Well," he said, "I'm not sure it's over."

He was silent for a long while. I drifted back to a bunk to watch television. Young joined me after a few minutes and stared at the screen intently.

"Listen to me," he said, eyes revitted to the tube. "What if I just save Decade for a year, then put out a new album. The new stuff sounds so good - I've got this song called "Hurricane" that just soars - I think I'd feel better releasing something new. It's not time to look back yet.

I looked over at Young, who had obviously made up his mind and was now fully enjoying The Boy in the Plastic Bubble. A few minutes later, Young went to the front of the bus to make a call on a mobile phone. "Elliot?" I could hear him say. "Here goes another album...."

In two short days, Warner Bros. President Mo Ostin and Executive Vice-President Ed Rosenblatt had flown to the next stop along the tour to discuss delaying Decade with Young. Neil played them most of an album he'd already recorded and titled American Stars n' Bars ("because one side is about American folk heroes and the other is about getting loose in bars"). They honored his wishes to postpone Decade a year in favor of the new album.

By the time American Stars n' Bars was released four months later, Young's prolific songwriting nature had completely altered the album to include a side of new music "written fast and in the spirit of country music," performed with Crazy Horse and the Saddlebags - singers Nicolette Larson and Linda Ronstadt.

we could try to figure out the timeline of that, but i don't think it'll make sense. still, it seems like the original "american stars n bars" might be what we think of as "chrome dreams"?

the chrome dreams that i have is the same one as listed above

it kind of "sounds" like an album IMO....like it fits really well

much better than stars n bars which has a real hodge podge feel

hey babe vs. lost in space imo

you could basically make a completely alternate neil young LP discography that would be completely coherent in itself but not precisely mirror any one of his released LPs.

almost

Saddle Up The Palomino!

https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/61CKRvXsS7L.jpg

bought a slightly scratched copy of American Stars n Bars. really loving this album! the cover always made me want to buy it (cos of the Big Lebowski reference).

i really like side 2. "Star of Bethlehem" plugs along nicely and that final verse was so beautiful it caught me off guard. what does he mean?

"Will to Love" is fucking great. this is what i want on a NY record, give me a long psychedelic acoustic guitar trip, complete with some phasing vocals and chill vibraphones. Neil is imagining he is a fish that is imagining he is a singer. hell yeah.

"Homegrown" is such a great way to end a record. Neil's rip-roaring down home pot anthem, Crazy Horse dicing it up with that chunky metallic guitar rhythm.

Album cover by Dean Stockwell!

Never made the Big Lebowski connection

What is it?

"will to love" is one of the best

I'm not sure why anyone would ever pick hawks and doves over stars n bars since the latter is a great record... always thought of h&d as the start of Neil's low quality output period which ends with Freedom, but maybe I should revisit it

http://i.imgur.com/OtHwDUF.jpg

put em on the glass

always thought of h&d as the start of Neil's low quality output period which ends with Freedom, but maybe I should revisit it

― niels, Tuesday, December 20, 2016 10:59 AM (four hours ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

this is otm. Its only saving grace may be "Captain Kennedy," which itself isn't exactly top ten Neil

ASAB, this album is so incredible. "The Old Country Waltz" crashing in w that heartbreaking violin and lyrics I wish I had written about something I have been through.

Side 2 is still my favorite, though I like the whole record more every time I hear it. They did some magical EQ on "Will to Live" imo, it sounds like it probably was a really rough tape w vocal distortion etc. And he used it cos who cares the performance is amazing and they are throwing in the phasing effects softening some of those hard Ss anyways. The vibraphone is so sweet.

"Star of Bethlehem" a wonderful little motorik country rock tune sort of about disillusionment and finding light in the darkness. The first time I heard him sing "Maybe the star of Bethlehem wasn't a star at all" I thought he was talking about UFOs. "Silver spaceships in the sun", etc.

"Hey Babe" is a nice little tune, sort of reminds of of "Only Love Can Break Your Heart"-style harmonies but w motorik country style. I love how he just sings "Hey Babe" twice, then just later keeps singing it over and over. The lyrics themselves are pretty simple ("I hope that all things pass/Let's try to make this last") so it is very plain language only with this twist. Maybe imitating a drunken stutter, the song is almost making fun of itself. Neil has a funny sense of humor and that's a big reason I keep coming back to his records.

oops - that's "I know that all things pass"

Yeah, this one is great. Lots of good info about the recording of "Will To Love" in Shakey, btw. IIRC it was just Neil and Briggs, up all night getting baked. Definitely one of my favorite Neil tunes

^^Yeah, using a home recorded demo (put down on a boombox iirc) as a basic track!

yup, that's why you hear a fire crackling