Van Morrison's Astral Weeks: Classic or Dud

Great article about Astral Weeks, one of the best pieces of music writing I've read in a while and the best description of this record I've ever seen:

http://www.nwanews.com/adg/Style/242565/

He mentions that Morrison's performing Astral Weeks live in LA tonight and tomorrow with Richard Davis and Jay Berliner. How could they possibly recreate an experience this singular? I sure wish I was going to be there to find out. Anyone going?

"enigmatic Irish wizard"

"Slow Slim Rider"

Anyone who can't even get the fucking song titles right shouldn't be trusted.

Lester Bangs' piece pisses all over this and all other non-factual/documentary writings on the same topic.

enigmatic Irish wizard = permanently grumpy Ulsterman

interview (via email?) with van the man about the performance this weekend ... http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/music_blog/2008/10/van-morrisons-f.html
VAN USES EMOTICONS? wow. :D
anyhoo, one of my top 10 records for sure. Not a bad moment on it. Risky, beautiful and nothing else in the world sounds like it.

The author on the link (xpost) seems amazed somewhat that the musicians had no chord sheets to follow. Aside from Young Lovers, pretty much everything on AW is a 2 or 3 chord jam. The kind of thing most jazzers could follow in their sleep.

As for his take on Madam George, well, I'd always imagined that was about a teenage boy's visit to a prostitute. It makes sense to me like that, anyway.

I can't get excited about Van performing AW live today. His voice is nothing like it used to be, and I really doubt he could do it justice.
I WOULD get excited if they came out with a remastered deluxe version of the original, with all the extra jamming.

I read in Mojo years ago that there was a whole 25 minutes of extreme free improv chopped off the end of "Slim Slow Slider." You can maybe see why it was edited out but it would be interesting to have the full take as a bonus track.

yeah, i can't imagine that the live re-creation of the record will be that amazing. i actually think van is enjoyable in his latter-day period (though i certainly haven't heard all of his recent albums), but he's not anywhere near the adventurous vocalist he was in 68. might be a pleasant concert, but nothing incredible.
but yeah, for real, i would love a deluxe treatment of astral weeks, just to eavesdrop on those sessions.

yeah i read that too -- that the "free" thing that closes out the album briefly just went on and on in the studio. would be verrrrry interesting to hear. it's perfect on the record, but i'd still just like more Astral Weeks music ...

I was tempted to read that piece but there's some bad undergrad poetry going on there:

"It is a festival of anguish, a wild and lonely ritual conducted on a dirt crossroads at midnight under a baleful bone-faced moon."

I hope Laura Barton sues.

I hate this album and I've been exposed to it way too often by people who just presume, because I'm "Into" music that I'll become all dewey-eyed and joyful upon hearing it. T be honest, I'm not a big Van Morrison fan although I like Them and that thing with The Chieftains was decent enough.

I read in Mojo years ago that there was a whole 25 minutes of extreme free improv chopped off the end of "Slim Slow Slider."
Yup, but where is it? Did they keep it or was the tape destroyed? If it really exists, it's hard to believe it's not available somewhere in the blogosphere. Damned if I can find it.

John Payne to thread...

I'm going to the la show tomorrow

I'll post about it

Great review:)
Astral Weeks (1968)
- With the chance to make his own record, Morrison came up with this, basically soft rock recorded with jazz musicians (including the Modern Jazz Quartet's Connie Kay on drums). Which might sound not too different from what Simon & Garfunkel were doing at the time, but where Simon's work is carefully composed, arranged and produced, Morrison relies on sponaneity. The liner notes brag that Morrison cut the album in two days, and you know, it sounds like it: the lyrics are stream of consciousness, and usually the tunes seesaw endlessly between two or three chords. The musicians sound like they don't know what he's getting at, and the fact that most of the songs have no clear melody doesn't help. Morrison's fans often cite this as their favorite album, because there aren't a lot of distractions from his distinctive, half-spoken vocals. But if you're just getting into him, you're probably better off with Moondance -- unless you're a fan of New Age music. (DBW)
http://www.warr.org/vanmorrison.html#AstralWeeks

i love this album so much.

It's my favorite and probably most-listened to album.

Followed by Pet Sounds and Corky's Debt to His Father.

Ha, I was just pondering whether to download "Corky's Debt to His Father" or not, and Dan's just persuaded me to do so!

It's fantastic.

Great review:)
Astral Weeks (1968)
- With the chance to make his own record, Morrison came up with this, basically soft rock recorded with jazz musicians (including the Modern Jazz Quartet's Connie Kay on drums). Which might sound not too different from what Simon & Garfunkel were doing at the time, but where Simon's work is carefully composed, arranged and produced, Morrison relies on sponaneity. The liner notes brag that Morrison cut the album in two days, and you know, it sounds like it: the lyrics are stream of consciousness, and usually the tunes seesaw endlessly between two or three chords. The musicians sound like they don't know what he's getting at, and the fact that most of the songs have no clear melody doesn't help. Morrison's fans often cite this as their favorite album, because there aren't a lot of distractions from his distinctive, half-spoken vocals. But if you're just getting into him, you're probably better off with Moondance -- unless you're a fan of New Age music. (DBW)
http://www.warr.org/vanmorrison.html#AstralWeeks

― Jazzbo, Thursday, November 6, 2008 5:01 PM (1 hour ago) Bookmark Suggest Ban Permalink

So, 40th anniversary reissue coming soon then?

if by "great review" you mean "terrible review (and also Moondance basically sucks)", then yes, quite!
Yes, I was being sarcastic.

Neat, never thought of Corky's and Astral Weeks in the same context but they both have a sort of wistful, late autumn feel.

Moondance doesn't suck, just a totally different animal than Astral Weeks. That review sucks, though, you're right.

an important album for me, too, as for so many - I had caught a little whiff of the legend of it, bought it from Music Plus (SuperSaver! 4.99!) and got my mind properly blown. Just about equal to its status, I think.

Listening to it now actually. Really is quite majestic and one of my faves.

the love that loves the love that loves the love that loves the love that loves the love that loves the love that loves the love that loves the love that loves the love that loves the love that loves the love that loves the love that loves the love that loves the love that loves

Tim Buckley's late 60's stuff (Blue Afternoon, Happy Sad) is also nice if you're into this sort of thing, though it doesn't quite reach the same kind of transcendal intensity.

i love this album so much.

― M@tt He1ges0n, Thursday, November 6, 2008 11:05 AM (3 hours ago) Bookmark Suggest Ban Permalink

yeah, listening to this, homesick as fuck, on a plane, watching the sun rise, was suitably life-changing

I love that Bangs essay, probably my favorite piece of music-writing, period; it shaped my sensibility toward music + a lot of other things in a way that's kinda weird, it being just a piece of pop crit and all

It's my favorite and probably most-listened to album.

Ditto

OK, this is now officially the worst piece about Astral Weeks ever written.

yeah, gosh, one of my favorite record-buying moments involves walking into a store with the specific intention of buying this record, and as i swung through the doors i was half-astonished to hear it blasting over the place's speakers.

'beside you' is so devastating and life-changing, to me, anyhow. i love the way it rambles on with very little in the way of cohesiveness...and the lyrics are like a bildungsroman presented noir style or something

the line 'ecstasy surrounds you...this time it's found you' is presented so wistfully, or at least ambivalently. i think there's a lot, lot, lot going on in that song, and it's somewhat entertaining to muse upon van morrison still not knowing what the fuck he was going on about in it.

you look in you look out you look in you look out you look in you look out aaaaannnnnnnreeeeenennnnuuur HIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIGH

great record.

I bought it based on Dave Marsh' seemingly-over-the-top review in The New Rolling Stone Record Guide when I was in high school. I thought, "No way could it be THAT good... Oh shit. It is."

Van made some good records after this, but its like he's possessed by some higher power here. "laughing music, dancing music, all around the room"
The only other one that comes close is You Don't Pull No Punches, But You Don't Push the River from Veedon Fleece.
There are a lot of later albums where he just mutters some poets names over an uninspiring backing.

such a dope album

'sweet thing' and 'way young lovers do' were def my favorites though - love the incorporation of jazz as urgent rhythm and not just noodling chill vibes or whatever people usually think of as 'jazzy'

like when the rhythm section switches into doing rhythms of two over the 3/4 time signature - so awesome

da-dum, da-dum, da-dum, da-dum

Funny I just saw this revive, I was planning on giving this another attempt during a quick road trip tomorrow. Will report results on my return.

Also

Tim Buckley's late 60's stuff (Blue Afternoon, Happy Sad) is also nice if you're into this sort of thing, though it doesn't quite reach the same kind of transcendal intensity.

― ecuador_with_a_c, Thursday, November 6, 2008 8:47 PM (3 days ago) Bookmark

HappySad trumps this any day of the week imo but ask me again after this thing rides the road with me.

^Marianne Faithfull's cover of Madame George is pretty good.

I guess reading the Greil Marcus book on Van Morrison depends on how much you like or can deal with Marcus's methods

I picked it up last week because it was mucho cheap in Chapters on Parnell St - I would charitably describe it as 'ok' - the best thing about it was it made me go back and listen to some stuff, but yeah some of it went way into Boomer rock crit parody territory.

i like it -- yeah plenty of "where are you going with this" moments, but i sorta enjoy its ramble. and yeah, it gets you going back to the music.

Seems like the breakup of Them -> release of Astral Weeks would be a good period to cover in one book; would also like a book that's just straight-up storytelling and no extraneous flabby critical analysis

(so basically I want 200 pages of that awesome article)

Seems like the breakup of Them -> release of Astral Weeks would be a good period to cover in one book; would also like a book that's just straight-up storytelling and no extraneous flabby critical analysis

― Brio2, Monday, March 30, 2015 5:54 PM (39 minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

I don't know if there was a break up of Them. Van left and several members continued for another 3 lps before morphing into a band called Truth

right - I just meant Van leaving Them. I've always been curious about the post-Van Them stuff.

i haven't heard all of those post van them records, but i remember some of it being surprisingly good.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RVCvi4aNLc8

According to Wikipedia there was a Them, a "The Other Them", and the Belfast Gypsies (with THEM in huge letters on their album cover) all playing at the same time.

and there was more than one Them as early as '65!

confusing.
hadn't seen this before, pretty amazing
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LKuM5oKk0es

Arizona Jones has posted 1970/71 shows, incl one with a 12-minute version of "Astral Weeks." Haven't had tyme to listen yet, but all the AJ posts I have checked are worth hearing. Here's the one with "Astral Weeks":
http://arizjones.blogspot.com/2015/04/van-morrison-fillmore-west-10-09-1970.html

The AJ posts I've heard are by other artists, no idea yet re his Van shows (some of which have songs I've never heard, unlike this set; gotta check 'em all)

Well actually looks like there's just one other Van show still up, but intriguing (and lengthy) set list:
http://arizjones.blogspot.com/2015/04/van-morrison-san-anselmo-ca-8-08-1971.html

@Dow. More than just one more. Here are a bunch. Enjoy!
http://arizjones.blogspot.com/2015/03/van-morrison-marin-ca-9-05-1971-fm.html
http://arizjones.blogspot.com/2014/12/van-morrison-london-3-21-1982-sbd.html
http://arizjones.blogspot.com/2014/11/van-morrison-montreux-11-07-1990-sbd.html
http://arizjones.blogspot.com/2014/10/van-morrison-glastonbury-festival-6-21.html
http://arizjones.blogspot.com/2014/07/van-morrison-montreux-7-10-1980.html

Wow, thanks so much!

When the reissue of Astral Weeks comes out one of the alternate takes will be an apparently legendary long version of Slim Slow Slider. This guy interviewed John Payne, the soprano sax player on the tune: http://throwingpenniesbridges.blogspot.com/2015/08/it-had-just-blown-them-away.html

OK, I'm so ready to hear this.

wowww

I woke up at 5am today, anyway I've been trying to set up all our household bills on to this online bill pay system so I went down in the basement where the computer is. Threw on the Rhino vinyl reissue from a couple years ago. I was having trouble getting my credit card account to connect to the site, and all of a sudden "Madam George" came on and I just started crying it was so pretty, right at the part where she says my love you forgot your gloves.

The bit that always does it for me is "laughing music dancing music all around the room"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H66PEecCo9g
unedited bonus track of 'slim slow slider' (for some reason shown as being from His Band and the Street Choir)... interesting to say the least...

listened to this for the first time in years the other night. my sister & brother-in-law visited last weekend, we had a fire going in the fireplace, had been smoking a little weed and drinking a little bit, this is like my sister's favorite album so she asked to put it on, the line that got all of us was "for instance me baby" from ballerina

xp editing out that last bit may have been the single best production choice made for that record, damn

Going to see if that new edition is in HMV tomorrow.

I see it gets reviewed in the new Uncut, couldn't check the Mojo since it was sealed in a bag around a book about the Dylan bootleg series. Both had just appeared in the local newsagent when i was in town yesterday.

Still wondering how extensive the physical cd releases on the Legacy material are after reading that Record Collector news last month.

xp yeah, that edit is a stroke of genius, like falling off a cliff or something. still kind of happy to hear that last bit w/ van breaking into a hymn, which would've ended the album on a decidedly different note...

I've now heard both cds and they sound pretty great. B&SC sounds less muddy than I've heard it elsewhere.
AW is fantastic, great to have it on a decent sounding cd at last.

AW remaster sounded crisp and overwhelming as I drove across the GG bridge this morning. In parts it almost becomes chaotic with all the instruments so clearly present.