Gotta Make Polls for the Polls I Make - ILM HUSKER DU POLL RESULTS

love the glassiness of bob's guitar sound on it especially

NickB, you are probs right, was just humming it to myself from memory!

the solo is killer. it sounds like the motors or somebody.

Huh, I also didn't know "Diane" is based-on-a-true-story. It makes the song make more sense to me, but I'm still conflicted about the song overall. Oh well. I'll just have to be conflicted.

Probably used her real name 'cause it sounds like "dyin'" xxp

And tastelessly uses her real name (you can look it up).

Aaaand now I kinda wish I hadn't.

I mean, hell Grant. It's not like when Springsteen wrote "Nebraska," he was all "But I'll just kidnap you and kill your parents instead."

It's Grant's delivery that makes it skeevy. In concept, "Diane" is no less blunt than "Jordan MN" or a lot of other songs from the scene and era. Hart is convincing in the song in a way few of his peers were. There not even the thin film of irony you'd get in the Birthday Party or Black Flag.

All my high school friends moved into two 2BR units in the Ghetto In The Sky/Crack Stacks when they went to their first year of college in 1989. 8 dudes in 4 bedrooms.

several xposts

Also, this is copied and pasted from the noms thread but before I forget:

Even the song titles have the same boring rhythm

All This I've Done for YOU
No Promise Have I Made

I totally remember being irked by this when CAG came out. I think of these as their Yoda songs.

I think of these as their Yoda songs.

Haha.

Anyone up for the rollout now or should I wait until 1300 CST like I said I would.

Seemed to peter out in the late afternoon yesterday.

Go ahead. I'm home sick and getting bored with the rest of the things the internet has to offer!

Crazy office shit going down, so yeah, forgive me if I get started a little early.

http://i612.photobucket.com/albums/tt203/pplains/Husker%20Du%20Poll/TERMS_OF_PSYCHIC_warfare700.jpg

20. “Terms of Psychic Warfare” - 166 points
• Pretty faithful cover, Dirty Grocers

Perfect song to start off Part II with.

'Nother great Norton bassline.

Will always live side by side with Slade's 'Run Runaway' in my head.

Spotify List Reminder

Everytime I hear someone screaming in the background of the SST records, I never know if it's Spot or not.

This song being an example.

This is too low.

http://i612.photobucket.com/albums/tt203/pplains/Husker%20Du%20Poll/whatever700.jpg

19. “Whatever” - 168 points
• Arcwelder's version from Dü Hüskers comp

TOO LOW

drums are crazy here.

i took "Whatever" real personally when i was 17

The use of second person in the verses, separating the narrator from himself, before launching into the first-person barrage at the end is heartbreaking.

http://i612.photobucket.com/albums/tt203/pplains/Husker%20Du%20Poll/sorry_somehow700.jpg

18. “Sorry Somehow” - 187 points
• ''Aussie indie popsters'' Pray TV paint-by-numbers cover

Love it (although it didn't make my ballot), but surprised to see it so high. The cassette I bought in 1986 had a drop-out when Grant yells "Yyyeaaah I'm not sorry!" before the solo. It sounds wrong without the drop-out.

that's weird.

It made my ballot. Lots of solitary nights in the car screaming along with this one.

"whatever" and "terms" are cool but i didn't bother voting for them, guessing some of my warner-era nods didn't make the cut then. xpost and then a warner-era track i didn't vote made the top 20.

I only heard "Diane" relatively recently but i love it. Definitely understand if people find it in poor taste or too harrowing, but it's a really gripping, complicated mess of a song. i've read that grant was allegedly friends with edwards, and the casual flippancy of the verses mixed with the agony of the vocal suggests, at least to me, a real horror. obviously no one needs to clap hart on the back for dealing with this shit in a public sphere, though i doubt he thought "oh it'll be great when some irish group takes it to the UK top 30 ten years from now."

http://i612.photobucket.com/albums/tt203/pplains/Husker%20Du%20Poll/cybt1700.jpg

17. “Could You Be the One?” - 192 points
• Husker Du play "Could You Be The One" and have a short interview with Joan Rivers.

First HD video I saw on MTV. And during the daytime, no less!

I'm so dumb, I had to read that twice to realize they didn't have high-definition videos back in the late 80s.

It was between this and another Mould track when I narrowed down my ballot to 20. This lost. I expected it would place without my help, and I'm glad it made the top 20.

xp hahaha

http://i612.photobucket.com/albums/tt203/pplains/Husker%20Du%20Poll/ill_never_forget_you700.jpg

16. “I'll Never Forget You” - 197 points
• Salbando cover from Dü Hüskers comp.

This is the one that when I was making the list, made me go back to confirm that I was counting the votes correctly.

It's a rocking punk song with a trollin' bass intro, but No. 16?

Especially when [your favorite Husker Du song] didn't even make the cut.

YES! I took this song super personally when I was a teen.

I'm out of class now btw, expect nonstop inane posts from me for the next hour or so.

Because of short Tgiving week work crunch I was unable to get a ballot done. But I understand the votes for I WILL. NEVER. FORGET. YOU.

I WILL
NEVER
FORGIVE
YOU
for not voting

I should have
MADE
PLANS
MADE
PLANS
to get it done the preceding weekend

hahaha

I gotta say, "Could You Be the One" has always kinda bored me. It's fine, but it's what I would otherwise categorize as a boring Bob song, perfectly written but monotonous. I would rather listen to Bob scream monotonously than sing monotonously.

We're finally at the middle of the list, with five more to go today and the final ten tomorrow.

Not that you were counting or anything, but the songwriter tally is currently Hart 7, Mould 7, with "In A Free Land" credited to both of them and Norton.

I don't have a lot of hope for What Do I Want anymore :(

My hope is registering at a level of

NOTHING
NOTHING
NOTHIIIIIIING

Really surprised by the last two. "Could You Be the One?" seems like the sort of Husker song someone who came to the band via Sugar might vote for. No offense, fans of "Could You Be the One?"

"Could You Be the One?" seems like the sort of Husker song someone who came to the band via Sugar might vote for.

Or, like me, maybe for people who came to the band via the Warehouse album and not aware that it's basically boilerplate Mould but still love it anyway because it was an early favorite.

I dig "Could You Be The One," even though it didn't make my ballot (only two Warehouse songs did, both Hart's). But seeing it on MTV I thought, "Yay! Now everyone can see how great this band is!" but also "...this...this isn't what I'd play for someone to show them how great this band is."

That said, it occupies a cherished place on a mixtape I made in 1988. Or 1989. Yeah, 1989.

I have never heard of this cover.

Would've voted in this poll if I had the time to replay all the albums. New Day Rising is my fave LP.

(first show -- 5 total, I think? -- Jan 1985 at the Peppermint Lounge after it had moved from Times Square to Chelsea.)

it's the inflection in Bob's voice on "and I don't even know what i'm crying for" that makes "Could You Be the One" for me but i wdn't've placed it this high and there are much better songs on Warehouse

How do you write out that yawning moan Mould does sometimes when he's not singing words?

"Cuz I don't really know oh wow raiwlle yowl wow hoa huh hoa huh…."