POLICE PROCEDURALS - which are ur faves

french people tell me the acting in spiral is quite poor. i enjoyed it though. there is one scene per episode that seems designed to shock.

I watched a few eps of Spiral before we got sucked into Top of the Lake; gotta go back to Spiral.

Also started THE FALL the other day and it seems alright but I wish focused more on Scully and less on the killer.

i thought i posted abt it on this thread but this year I really enjoyed the novels of Gene Kerrigan. My favorite was probably "The Midnight Choir" about troubled policeman Harry Synott. All four of Kerrigan's novels give you the POV of both police and criminals, but I found Synott to be the most compelling. He has problems with the corruption he sees in the cops around him but he's also no angel himself. Lots of different plot strands that come together in unexpected and powerful ways. Kerrigan was/is a journalist as well and has written extensively abt crime and corruption in Ireland.

but I wish focused more on Scully and less on the killer.

It strikes a fine balance imo

i only watched 1.5 eps, so i will keep going.

the fall is good, kind of wish there was more ni politics stuff and less life-of-the-killer stuff but in the absence of prime suspect ill take it

Also belongs in the cartoon-movie-poster thread.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/c/c3/Les_Ripoux.jpg

i am fully on board w the Fall now BTW.

http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/television/2014/01/true_detective_on_hbo_starring_matthew_mcconaughey_and_woody_harrelson_reviewed.html

http://www.slate.com/content/dam/slate/articles/arts/movies/2014/01/140108_MOV_TrueDetective.jpg.CROP.original-original.jpg

yesssss

I'm so down for this, it looks really good

I'm thinking about watching Prime Suspect, just 23 years after it came out...is it still considered good? I've caught a bit so far and it just seems so dated (not the styles though they do) but the attitudes...should I stick with it?

Thanks to being out of The Fall and Luther on Netflix

yes, watch it

its most distinctive payoff is in the long-term view of her career, self

yeah the first couple seasons are the best if you view each individually, and are top-notch terrific policiers, but the real thing you watch for is mirren creating and moving through the character

i mean the fall is kind of a straight prime suspect rip with a little bit of silence of the lambs thrown in

otm -- prime suspect is SO worth it.

Alright, thanks for the recs. Watched part 1 last night- it was a little slow, but I think that was just adjusting to the style. Your collective enthusiasm makes me look forward to more.

Just caught up with the first episode in series two of the new-to-BBC police drama Hinterland. It was quite impressive. Definitely heavily influenced by the Scandinavian noir stuff of recent years. Aberystwyth looks really beautiful and it's nice to hear Welsh being spoken extensively in a show being marketed outside of the region.

oooh that sounds interesting

Southland has just started another repeat stupidly late on ch4. not sure if it's procedural enough i've always liked it.

(it's season 4 and i've seen most of it before. still not sure i've seen all of them...)

i like southland a lot too

the wacky twist at the end of the 1st episode of spiral was super stupid. keep going y/n?

channel 792(!) on freeview in the uk is showing the orignal Dragnet. it's 50 or 60 years old and is great. 30 minutes, no flab, and as dark as you like.

Suspects, which is apparently the first British drama Channel 5 has produced in eight years, is better than expected. The plots could do with being stronger but the unscripted improv approach works pretty well.

there are few things better than when a character on a police procedural starts talking about sovereign citizenship

up there with russian mafia

AGREE

Enjoying line of duty, just finished on bbc

It was pretty silly at times but Keeley Hawes was awesome.

everybody's talkin about how good line of duty is, i'm down

yeah I need to check this out

As a procedural goes, the bit in episode 5 where Fleming and Arnott interview Dryden is all-time A+. Hawes was pretty awesome in it, and I usually don't rate her at all.

Highly recommended for fans of the genre:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=15IRXKn9LSU

^ ha, yes.

just reading james lee burke right now, it's really really good

my gf is a law and order: SVU addict. help me.

Just watched S2E1 of line of duty - so good

There are at least two genuine HOLY SHIT moments, and already I'm basically trusting no one

line of duty is sick, so down

though at times i find it harder to understand than glaswegian

the police in uk procedurals always seem like such a mess

but their lady cops

http://www.rootfilms.co.uk/uimages/BLOG/VICKY.jpg

and their haircuts…

otm

augh but they RUIN IT in the second series

do they actually say 'answering only yes or no' like that in uk prisons, a quick google makes it look like 'line of duty' is the only place that comes from, but it's so diabolically realistic i could have sworn it was real

http://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/04/arts/television/steven-bochco-and-others-on-creating-hill-street-blues.html?hpw&rref=television&_r=0

i would watch the shit out of a cable network that only showed 'racial tensions between homicide investigators and neighborhood residents' episodes of all the police procedurals

https://tv.yahoo.com/blogs/tv-news/-murder-in-the-first--trailer-premiere--silicon-valley-meets-slayings-in-new-steven-bochco-tnt-series-183208663.html

looks very hollywood but maybe that's just trailervision

Happy Valley was really excellent, if a bit hard to watch occasionally.

http://www.nytimes.com/2014/06/09/arts/television/murder-in-the-first-a-new-drama-on-tnt.html?_r=0

alessandra stanley likes it ok, course every time she winds up to make a judgment i feel a little dumber, so fwiw

anybody seen these latest Wallanders? they're sitting on the DVR but i've had so much other fantastic stuff to watch i haven't gotten around to them yet

ooh there's more wallanders??

new wallanders are... odd. there's a massive elephant in the room and it's hard not to sit there scratching your head over it. like when becky on roseanne was suddenly this whole other person, only worse.

oh, they're just taking over production from the swedish version? that's less… a thing. but i do love cast-switches.