Best Rush Album [Poll Closes May 7]

"Limbo" is kinda cool

Ha, that's funny, I finally gave that album a chance today, too, and think I stopped early as well. What's up with "Test for Echo?" It'd be one thing if this was the album after Neil's bad period, but this is the album before all that stuff happened.

presto has for me always stood out slightly from those around it, but i too wish it weren't so very trebly

so they've repudiated their repudiation of their eighties catalog by now, right? That documentary released a few years ago made it clear the band didn't want to talk about that period or at best saw it as a necessary but not aesthetically rewarding period. Clearly the fans who prefer '70s are starting to get outnumbered, so it wouldn't surprise me (nor is it a reflection on the band) that the guys (re)turn to the '80s material live thanks to cold calculation.

i thought it was mainly lifeson who was unhappy at having his axe (relatively) sidelined

"No one told ya not to learn keyboards man"

yet to my ears Lifeson still got excellent moments to shine -- and the terseness helped.

agreed

I prefer Permanent Waves - moving Pictures...when they were still prog but embracing synthetic and creating an unbeatable sound.

Followed by 70s a la Hemispheres.

Then the 80s stuff. Grace Under Pressure the best of the Signals - power Windows threesome.

I mean the synthetic shit was extremely creative so other than the meatheads I don't get people that write it off.

*embracing synths

*synth shit

The guitar stuff in the '80s was great, but yeah, the story goes that the a lot of the stuff was done - drums, synths, arrangements - before Alex got in there, so he had to find a way to fit in. Which is, of course, maybe one reason he's one of the rare guitarists equally good at rhythm and solos; the Andy Summers approach fills a lot of space.

By the way, it's those arrangements that get me, and I think it's one of Rush's most unheralded attributes. For a band often pegged as prog, they really only have a couple of prog albums. The rest mostly comprise weirdly dense pop songs, of a sort. But always impeccably put together. One might call Rush indulgent, but I'm not sure what anyone could point to as truly indulgent - solos are short and to the point - and beyond that, they have such an obvious sense of humor that it's hard to call them pretentious, too. Beyond Neil's lyrics, I guess, which can fall on the Sting side of things between the Dos Passos references.

"No one told ya not to learn keyboards man"

Doesn't he actually play some minor keyboard parts live? I seem to remember that from the 2010 show I saw.

I don't have a problem with the synths on those 80s records, but I can't get past the horribly thin, tinny drum sound. That's the only thing keeping me from really digging into those albums.

I dunno, I like the drums on HYF and PW just fine. If anything, his playing itself was more trebbly - more cymbals, more triggering. Later, more recent albums got back to low end drum rumble a bit, and away from the electronics.

Love this guy, btw: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XbWY7sum1Gs

jesus I really like HOld Your Fire. "Force Ten" is mesmerizing. shame they got so much blander after (though I kinda like Presto)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VNEKkiUwGos

hahaha lol - sounds like a retarded pink floyd song

Actually, this is a pretty fascinating dissection of how much thought Peart puts into his parts:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cyVHimRng9A

I'm suddenly finding Side A of Presto incredibly affecting and consoling today and yesterday. Especially "The Pass" which made me cry a little at my desk yesterday.

ways to know whether you're in your mid-forties...

I had a quote from "The Pass" under my picture in my high school yearbook, good times!

Ways to know you're in your mid-forties or late teens

early forties, thank you very much!

I guess now I've heard all of their albums except the debut and Test for Echo.

― Hammer Smashed Bagels, Thursday, May 28, 2015 2:27 AM (6 days ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

Test For Echo would quite comfortably be one of my least favourite Rush albums. Some god-awful lyrics on that one!

put your message in a modem, and throw it in the cyber sea..

and all too soon a canine will be chasing cars in doggie heaven

that dog one is my actual least favorite rush song

ha ha, was just coming to post the exact same lyric

i heard test for echo once.

once...

I like some test for echo tracks despite lots of dopey lyrics. Driven, Totem, and Time and Motion are pretty solid.

i heard test for echo once.

once...

― demonic mnevice (Jon Lewis), Wednesday, June 3, 2015 6:56 PM (26 minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

It's enough to leave an impression!

glad there ended up being so much Hold Your Fire chat here, because I think that might be my answer (having heard everything between Moving Pictures and it over the last couple of days)

it's just too huge, the arrangements are too epic, everything is delivered from on high as heroes defeat evil universes, Turn The Page is the greatest song ever, etc etc

Grace Under Pressure, Power Windows, Hold Your Fire and Presto are probably Peart's peak as a lyricist.

I love Grace Under Pressure and Power Windows, but fairly meh on the other 2

The more the decades go by, the more I love Power Windows.

Mystic Rhythms especially. Probably their most overlooked single.

to me Signals seems to belong more to the run of albums after it than what came before

True

I would go all-in on super deluxe editions of Signals, Grace Under Pressure, Power Windows, and Hold Your Fire but AFAIK apart from that "Power Windows Demos" bootleg CD (which isn't as interesting as it seems) there's little in the way of extras outside of live shows. I don't think they ever worked in a way that generated lots of outtakes or alternate directions.

Well that run of albums is notable in that even though they were a multiplatinum smash and worldwide megastars, they just kept churning out an album pretty much every year! It's hard to think of another band who refused to rest on their laurels to such an extent. Such output seems to tell me they had a lot of clarity when they went into the studio, hence the lack of outtakes

to me Signals seems to belong more to the run of albums after it than what came before

― imago, Wednesday, August 16, 2023 3:44 PM (yesterday)

glad there ended up being so much Hold Your Fire chat here, because I think that might be my answer (having heard everything between Moving Pictures and it over the last couple of days)

― imago, Wednesday, August 16, 2023 3:12 PM (yesterday)

I appreciate how their first 3 live albums serve as lines of demarcation in their catalogue, like ending credit scenes from a cinematic entry in some grand trilogy. While I don't view "Different Stages" as sharing a similar role, it does serve as a nice in-joke to their whole "trilogies have 4 parts" ethos.

As for HYF, I learned that the key to appreciating it as a whole album (rather than a just a delivery system for the "Force Ten"/"Time Stand Still" opening salvo) is to view it as a prog-leaning New Age-adjacent record, like if Windham Hill let Michael Hedges or Alex DeGrassi create their own sub-label. The choir vocals/synths, calm strings, and empty space of "Mission", "Tai Shan", "Prime Mover", and "High Water" make a fairly enjoyable listen. If you can turn off the whole "Is this supposed to be Rush? Where's the distorted riffage and/or wild drum/bass interplay?" part of your brain - and besides, those *are* there, just in a very subordinate role to those other 3 elements listed above - it is damn near transcendent.

One other HYF point that someone made in a comment section from a surely-dead prog-rock blog that I wish I could find: "Open Secrets" might (ahem) secretly be a great "Invisible Touch"-era Genesis song, especially the chorus.

turns out the person why recommended me HYF was also busy doing a huge in-depth interview about it too :)

https://www.spin.com/2023/08/band-jury-fire-toolz-rush-hold-your-fire/

I remember reading something (no doubt linked to on this thread somewhere) about each Rush album evolution coming in pairs.

to me Signals seems to belong more to the run of albums after it than what came before

It felt like a huge departure from Moving Pictures, which in itself was a little bit removed from the albums immediately prior.

HEMISPHERES

i like their 1st album

y'know before they became libertarians

didja get my skrewdriver joke

ivy. OTM