POLL With It - OASIS (ILM artist poll #78) --- The results thread

i was one of those first place votes for Whatever.

https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/5NKpkL2gUe0zI1iIlNEgWR9Clrxbt6ptJkbwMmTx_Uztpg-lAl7Gm_V7Ao4PJx27C6CKWukh1kLPKmXK3T0Asun3B9enLNPIA20z5RxUAIqbV-cRJkENwl7rLPLAF1p24zAnIvo7Dk1e6f2tWA07760JFVOTKffXl2nInd13T7ydu8hajzdKT__1fV-V1OyiB4m5J1cGLNZ0Yd6qk5MgMnd-uEOmrBRf_nTm-JP-sU0pzXyxFVnGONhpDfLECpfXidJGlFCkMLHV4nNsjikKeHnnlsq1JgqrII8XF-XblxEnIkXPZ4rIFJezJ-hcdu8V04YttOr6SIE8dCP4hnxBvtde6piy9VTOMwC0iK19_lnFLDjPGQ8mW_2qp7hz7pRbJHbQjjPxuKvV_JDJMj-RAXy-S37-Y6HIybkXSO4DL5BdYxUCRrZFwRq3A28O5VfPWPxRigX2TsK7Z_wOmSzs3u8T5p25YRUyHWChMDJsxa8ctqe98EM1ZDowSSTuLxUERjS8EhA9oN79_SqBXQgT3CWK7r7ul7XE_1tipGBqtSdhK4Y4FLMw6LJ_92FLEiPa5-sEEgBUVei0AY6PpiBQPgLYQdC0hLKrzQvepNqFkuyi7sE6=s500-no

7. Heathen Chemistry
Released: 1 July 2002
78 Points, 2 Votes

ha, i was one of these two votes. i threw this a bone instead of SOTSOG and have never heard DOYS.

https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/z7BCo3JFsJwoD2ZCJeDwNU-FHwEBU5YFurosAah4YBsdTE5Jpdu-NmYn-LOui2-ZsdBUaGusv93vOUzgDDtKM8sQkoxn-wwqwHVt3SVcyJrQuhhYmJBV1ho-JxInYEP4WarHTJp89V4qwigZixINEsG_EVAgbAYjV1zNZlrl5vzNYFQwp9I4_NyRflMVGNWtafaDCRoecCQ2o6y7yDwVWWIEpLLdqeJ-zZFlSsk2zQ7SOWopuAgeV0R2XPN-fnQBL0imnFo5eRGB6-9QIkY0FqFj4P9BPrvgrQSaQG-CJwstwRdvGXy5xC7NZWDyJdhEKJHmhAgMWGCMvh4VI_BKARUlS6cEuf1-nUvANiTJx5C6FGlUlkfrMh9_y2zNdKo-Uk1IunoWUlWM13iJfr3_8mpZ5oGj0x3aEa57CJvFHAeEF5hGcB2NZasGOXEU9pTELj7ViqlibLcv-Y4d-1ixnT75cM0zvS5Pmon2Ee7bnR8u3Q2HlzHSY_JqyFXP7MVjYbXtxiUGlt_HBNSt16JMRL4kCrinEcMi0UheFX3nq3dN8Is9fw-bp0QXVD43b0hy7CJsUrCX_UTo_MlyDqvs8vTPONao-3ABga6i2RdVpMC6KqLX=w500-h499-no

6. Dig Out Your Soul
Released: 6 October 2008
199 Points, 5 Votes

and now i'm having more image problems.

can anyone tell me the best image hosting site?

https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/gGxdMBNUFGlcwOcjBqMKT73AEhLnUrgP5kiZESKLIM3jNCg_Dw26jhV56j5zK7Omp5xpK0VNYbUsVm88CDceItCVyO5KzUDqR33MUjRPwRV-kkd3rX7AggDkmSVfuVPyof52Y16KmSm7mgSG6jVYY_E8gs3Vw5yLG_NrYhZ7ztirjwbpyxwTijn4RjRd1LcO2dgGp25owvPDVqrEui2YAIair2zFOB-ZGErDltBf7IQq4VvqcCBZRDRISbVBEiS-r0ojL29RpZC_66_fxwr0GBWphswj5WE1tw1X9qDKIcyt1GJqNIepZKa8fbTnzol8NLEN52B-2ekAQZGuMd83qm4Aj_wABpQVzdHicKtDz5nh8iAMken63DB7PTysyZSNtB7gacJdx0YOXxdNVsEa-Vs0KTNMuq-FAwKEnYZWpwlI1ln3xQ0zGZqx6q10w2HjNHs8INPzwe9Q5in4H5D9lMzm3SDBuyB1V_vbe2Z3-FZHClYl2YFL5ZTUIz0XvFh8RhoZwdM_RbL4dFKxE8S3j463dPZki83ZqpZlRezpOPaHXgrS_3LJd0iMOijrqzlrZjJqwtv8DLVyWm8mMZne7bYG15bqbp3oIBUPvilS1bniGvE6=s500-no

Don't Believe the Truth
Released: 30 May 2005
213 Points, 5 Votes

that is 5.

test, sorry:
https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/68L-D3BFuZR9g2ww4IeMQtg5R5rSb8WTbf0eY1O4OlIlYIx5TVUE8i__GlwQAsK7qz2a07oo9msB2yfw2MMJa-2vVuivbp5x4JYVpjMtzGhGDEV-uW9WE6wEHfsdWw_u2nnxoF-kU09eqKHn3IrGWSxTiTWl3-meEZMg9XSssJf2FtXASouugFrTY-4KteojzYdgh3bI8G7VW_ayxVyWkKKEBJ9SlKXO1fKd0uwPDr2I022VX2-NLNAxcEzPrlVK930EbZoxWKALOH8OA0OviuCvuHdjUAV7ZoxnDgXbIgnzKEZ8OnS7dpqSsfFDKJEB_dG7PcB5bsgvXnbv-etXyTzW-unfO3GFEgwj5s-xrE5lq5TTqeymUgAPi8EnfVeGwGlncbA3Ua5U8QlY4Gzqjrna9j6MzldLaEXoUKQZdACzlndZ450V-EYQDonBc2qThdNcHH_j6dRFz144ouQ8FTWUwuejblpu9eRZPJ6dXQcJl0i_HqdMcariBacFl0wwV4kZj1J7qdQbjszTkT3sR4HlC0VvDwBzBdMB9jJUKywl7QLRekALAzQSUlGaiPO2PAT3LeE1qMmVjk8vfierGa15vFlF53x0UFEg5hnE26sMuVfO=s500-no

it worked, might have figured out what i will need to do. what a pain.

that is it for tonight as it's late. will pick it up the the morning tomorrow.

forgot to post this...

Singles Full Results (or Top 18):

1. Whatever 226 Points 5 Votes 2 Number Ones
2. Wonderwall 171 4 1 Number One
3. Live Forever 161 4
4. Some Might Say 146 3 2 Number Ones
5. Cigarettes & Alcohol 120 3
6. I'm Outta Time 84 2
7. Stand by Me 83 2 1 Number One
8. Roll With It 81 2
9. The Hindu Times 74 2
10. Supersonic 73 2
11. The Shock of the Lightning 72 2
12. Songbird 43 1
13. The Boy With The Blues 43 1
14. D'You Know What I Mean 40 1
15. Morning Glory 38 1
16. Sharkermaker 38 1
17. The Importance of Being Idle 36 1
18. Falling Down 32 1

The boy with the blues?

Sort of amazed Don't Look Back In Anger isn't there. Do people not like it?

I'm not surprised, tbqh. Imagine Liam singing it. Sounds good, doesn't it?

do I understand the poll correctly and most people here prefer these songs to Supersonic ??

6. I'm Outta Time 84 2
7. Stand by Me 83 2 1 Number One
8. Roll With It 81 2
9. The Hindu Times 74 2

I'm very surprised, because it's one of Oasis' best singles packages of that period, with 'Underneath The Sky', 'Step Out' and their best cover version ('Cum On Feel The Noize') on the B-sides. I think 'Don't Look Back In Anger' is a miles better song than 'Wonderwall', too. Always did.

Having said that, though, the 'Wonderwall' single is also one of their better singles packages: 'Round Are Way', 'The Masterplan' and the full version of 'The Swamp Song' on the B-sides.

Those that voted for the 'Live Forever' single were probably voting for the song and not the single. Aside from the lead track, it doesn't have much else to offer.

(xxxpost)

In fact, seems to me that people generally got confused about this section of the poll.

Yeah, true, although "Cloudbusting" is there. (It's on my version of the DefMay CD)

https://www.discogs.com/Oasis-Live-Forever/master/52290

(p.s. like the review at the bottom..)

Yeah, 'Cloudburst' has its fans but I've never really liked it, for me it didn't really have much about it that stuck in the cranium long after listening like Noel's best songs of the period.

ayo bee ok, I voted for the "don't look back in anger" single

whoa i was like OASIS COVERED KATE BUSH? for a sec

I didn't vote in the singles poll but it's ridiculous that Don't Look Back in Anger didn't even place, being as that's their best song

Well, there is a stewards enquiry on tthat one thanks to:

ayo bee ok, I voted for the "don't look back in anger" single

I don't think it would be better with Liam singing, Noel's voice was a nice change at the time and I still prefer his voice.

hum. I don't know, I don't really like Noel's voice. It's too mild and lacks personality.
whenever an oasis song happens to play on my spotify, if it's Noel, I skip it.
"don't look back" is ok, though.

the only real flaw with the masterplan beyond the "i am the walrus" cover is how many songs are sung by noel. i guess he has a better voice traditionally but he mostly sounds mundanely bored, as opposed to liam's way more compelling idgaf bored

Liam has the sneer and the gravelly Lennon-esque grain. Noel's a much less distinctive singer. nonetheless he sings the two best songs on Morning Glory.

er wait no I guess Liam sings Cast No Shadow?

Noel's got better as a singer over the years, Liam's got worse.

Dunno, that Noel Remix set that came out, I like all the tracks that do not have Noel singing

just about ready to go again.

can't believe i messed up.

I thought Some Might Say was nailed on for #1 single/EP - great lead track, two amazing b-sides (and one decent one).

i even voted for "Don't Look Back in Anger" single:

7. Stand by Me 83 2 1 Number One
8. Don't Look Back In Anger 82 Points, 2 Votes
9. Roll With It 81 2

i somehow eliminated it when i was editing the spreadsheet.

also sorry, i should have been a bit clearer in the Singles/EPs part of this poll. there seems to be some confusion.

https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/BSnp0V9EvakaAscf1s78YARQWfKQa-k_B1xteXP7GIgqIuUzk8SXj_bKB-3oUmJfgIujy0AinoTzWd3NOYQo-a24Hd-Hcd8uOPXXjXtrHHCWfHbJDRa6wUsX-nQUuJ-5YsLwAR6AjWk637YfywZTcrpc_NZwzIx-FnJ5hNC6qkoSYS1Vj-8iSR84EEgy8pjWNHCxlWfBc-_NKPdj_xj9qUAjlkpgWvkzUpqRQlbUWtVYCpYZEMwO_Kp6FDiI4PuIJU_oDV7eK5GJJ4IyywGGaLI_2Sra6TrG4w0ddbu-W7HpwHL-MM1lequZ4dx-kYWPTdKQLuq1mXIMLKs5t47jV1Nmwl7wWe3jUYTitKsw7VLYPU5a7bj2HTTCOJmTGRTv3PgEcWe_W9gRB7CI68bGmn_6tVfihPmH-CdtGw1HD1NJJOKzImVu8zkK5ZhG6Y1Yq-CP9Bwl_7aWyADzLLCyLU51yQJt0iCENeAgc0L-sQhaje9chAUSKiPPrDO3SMrqSbzoJXmjLskVL-4BIr_esFtIf7OYz--XttuKJu-6jgypzEqX-VggPQ5NKD4Adi1Jdees_5ybLIapEwG_ZuS3lyJvtmSv_-XOWMdX8offLAiJUL4o=w500-h488-no

4. Be Here Now
Released: 21 August 1997
319 Points, 8 Votes

this order is about as logical as you would think.

https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/S1xz07h0F76Bpsgx67QauVfawvHfyojafIxcljBQCCYYU03125G7TUPFFTTP9f91U6kAGhrFxe0L_YkQHD6lYHr2mqcilCLtU0WQJlBXcTeY3kaP4HVo2iPYe-SmeENwT8knx4syCPIoH6wJTLhpxOt5TyWgVt73QLVH-o_qjiIGw1SZzjN3tYJ04IIk0bqu7jOTEHAz4u9maU71cmdkSiJDhvogJNmUHWVxtabjoKUxKsinGoe0MkCg9zh51GdJUYMyhtnXn0pLwnAY7LjAisENRY34rcT8m2bqNTDt8giVcRS0ZJFnj83E2Q0_R9Mcug27gZkDvkuOocTZJtweNidcuemljs3ga3V76fnRvwye221r7NeYLk5ULMuvB5XW-jYM2DHfkaRDH3PSI1DbRqBxmcBvxTB3YhPLLnAQy-g_dYyBmz9nVHBSIYCdDhPWlPW281VWaXeLAr7J12qwLbE06LYf6ld6F4ihDr5DrSYuZYBIszs79Tejz4OAerBi07K6IVLxjAUy1niUfCyUpfrrV8FTLILO2Y3GR2J3fGBYaZ6tP6aIynRBMXZksXImtSdiXRcyXMZHtPf0kXHSkrwDjXhOkyUOEBkYapAuyb3ih0mw=w500-h499-no

3. The Masterplan
Compilation album
Released: 3 November 1998
490 Points, 11 Votes, 2 Number Ones

i has mixed feeling about voting for The Masterplan in this part of the poll. i never owed it as i had all the single but when i looked at what made my ballot and what songs were on this comp. i decided to go ahead and vote for it.

yeah it was my no. 1 album

https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/jvv-zrHcnU0gMx-ugsIKIR1ui14C-XEGafDhF-Gdlvqf8GsiAyoHNKshjl77ntf3bE0Z_rWO__AUZ_HGqeXrn--rWWV1OviMPwrNfqAlKGy3QbXToTTjSsbaUMmBhhGijcfsvKw0n1zAfsP1x7TQ_NBxye0FJZWGo9vPghg_ERzIsPwOgd3XhJX6ak4KpODQa4MPytCV7OZibhjsaEoWTMc1h_kbO8TES0kwijlgCYAmFPN75GcpPXhD2wBOsYGh0N9rVaWkaT1zCkW-Zw8E7omLFPtcgXxAED8bSMupc9p-8iU7mflywLcAwQetAnQy75p3cDfaJoxyvzpduLGU2n_qbeImwh71tdJ8iSAlmsv4_Udgkqwrww7fuOYN60LKsyfbzrnrsj89JysjiciWr2tanMgz2H_oj8HIoI-yMB4vFuf8fIPeRZAZPIHH80Hl0NopR8mKAQQt-_MK8Qy9wjplfvvzsa5U_IKcBFNEZRJKDvZTLofc6Wh6_3LVN5ZO_0Jqa5Iti9I3ZWIvboZsFVMaMARohRlciymTyS9ql8PnOf1goPYYq4GoqlpXYWshh6cyTdiWxqP6n7EhRPXMKHtPNisigKGTpVE8oOOtuvYlmTJx=w500-h494-no

2. (What's the Story) Morning Glory?
Released: 2 October 1995
686 Points, 15 Votes, 2 Number Ones

and the only album to make all 16 ballots.

https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/qsCDDw7uS1oNxKbLRIiPA_sclRd_bJMiJcFDuh5xif4npcQ4mUJvo6H8CbzSyWavNHszADB1WQCusMa0hjlC4jyyq9zDKJA47UrqibBvDL-dHlQb-X-pd1lffQVOnxMb46N8OblpB28Dn5XdfuZz3HEjSoMeU0__-ZtYFGol8OMXJvHPxQcK8MQwW7vFzUOzmlXdBdimnJ-Ea2fJ-8EuTKj4TceVoiTb7g5aDDoH63CPNx6PwHCxs6xj_SIS74wZbqwHbwuWJPCCPDOo5wcrfv15IZFbS_ZWuJFTOgWnxFdAIWngyO-PcZwj8OTRQO2F5t_DuCkLN2hSYSvWyB-zfRpvT4OAJOoK7_yvXRUsBzoBmgC87t6KHjvCVvajXOp-NwCBkTAww7ydfZE3rMyzYRYBf6Jy65Ul6kVbqofLlGxY7byI-fwgSuXqJuGHN46iruB3OXjAnaEp5ZauZ7mGPXB4va5J0EY4FG5RmxFAtp10_q7mqBoHbOCx9KeQSj8v3N8Ps2kE1_9q2j6VPMIZnBUtl7h4XFgIbkaUAauW3TL27qeGdCIA7vy8q0WBhoIl1II3uze_i_PSVbI_hd3U5ANSlqM5-9-DY61VAx0v259uX-Dz=w500-h495-no

1. Definitely Maybe
Studio album by Oasis
Released: 29 August 1994
781 Points, 16 Votes, 12 Number Ones

it really wasn't even close.

Albums Full Results (or Top 11):

1. Definitely Maybe 781 Points 16 Votes 12 Number Ones
2. (What's the Story) Morning Glory? 686 15 2 Number Ones
3. The Masterplan 490 11 2 Number Ones
4. Be Here Now 319 8
5. Don't Believe in the Truth 213 5
6. Dig Out Your Soul 199 5
7. Heathen Chemistry 78 2
8. Stop The Clocks 43 1
9. Familiar to Millions 40 1
10. Standing on the Shoulder of Giants 38 1
11. Time Flies…1994 - 2009 38 1

no-one offered to help with images, so i was just going to go with plain text. decided that was too boring and didn't have time to learn photo shop. decided to go with original artwork since Oasis has enough verity.

Top 50