Songs with only two chords

yeah I think Horse is just two.

Molly's Lips?

Jane Says is technically 3 in that the A in the chorus is actually an A7

I wouldn't count adding a 7th as a new chord but I think there is a third chord here: if you mean the chord under "tomorrow", I think the guitar is playing G and C# over D. This could be ambiguous on its own but, with the bass emphasizing D, and with the vocal line emphasizing A and ending on F#, I hear the root as D.

Sly "family affair"

family affair has at least four (mostly in the chorus)

Wilco - Misunderstood

So basically this thread is destined for 500+ posts about what a chord is

Eno, "Third Uncle"

Eno, "Baby's On Fire"

Xpost i like sund4r's theory posts tho.

New Order Temptation

There's more than two chords in this.

"Pushin' Too Hard"

So basically this thread is destined for 500+ posts about what a chord is

― Οὖτις, Saturday, 3 September 2016 17:05 (three hours ago) Permalink

Yes, but the chords in Family Affair are Dm, Gm7, C7 and Bbmaj7

how many chords does prince's "we can funk" have?

Don't Let Me Down - Beatles (E, F#m)

There's a passing Amaj7 in the choruses, and the bridge has a B and B7.

Van Morrison - You Don't Pull No Punches But You Don't Push the River. It all seems to be Em C.

what is the pop song with the most chords? (excluding tracks that are more than, say, five minutes long so as to rule out song suites and the like)

I think 'Tie a Yellow Ribbon' has roughly about 14 chords in it, although I'd have to double check.

Oh, I've found one with more: 'King George Street' by Squeeze has 16 - (A, Bb, B, C#, C#m, Dm, Ebm, Eb, E, Em, F, F#, F#m, G, G#, G#m)

Beach boys This Whole World has 15 or so

Looking at sheet music (I didn't listen to verify myself in this case), I see 16 in Chicago's "You're the Inspiration" as well, even when I count all extensions and inversions as the same chord.

Three different keys, I think, in that one.

Song that uses nine different chords and stays in the same key - "It's Getting Better" by Cynthia Weill/Barry Mann, hit for Mama Cass.

Four keys, actually, in the Chicago song!

Yeah, totally. I didn't think there was a 'no key changes' requirement?

Oh, nm. I think I misread you.

Right, I was just making the distinction.

I think there's ten in "Tie a Yellow Ribbon?" And it stays in the same key. One fewer secondary dominant than the Mama Cass song, but I think "Tie a Yellow Ribbon" has two different augmented chords, if I'm hearing it right, and a borrowed v chord.

It has a borrowed iv, too, so it would actually have eleven chords if there was ever a regular IV chord, but I think it uses ii and borrowed iv every time.

The Trashcan Sinatras 'Earlies' is just E and F#m.

I wrote a thing on this song recently, which has fifteen chords.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0bj-lOyW_0U

It's one of my favorite songs. I think it really manages to sort of float around key centers. Not deliberate in its modulations.

That's pretty cool.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kK42LZqO0wA

what is the pop song with the most chords? (excluding tracks that are more than, say, five minutes long so as to rule out song suites and the like

Until someone else comes along with something better, I'm going to claim this for the Kinks' "Autumn Almanac", which has 25 (at least) - according to the internet that is, though I remember being flummoxed by it when leafing through an old Kinks' songbook years ago. Also, it is definitely a pop song, no. 3 in the UK charts.

... count them for yourselves...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p_u0gn1I8xQ

Sixteen? Not counting extensions as separate chords, I've got:

F#, B, C#, b minor, E, A, D, d# minor, D aug, G#9 (?), A#7, f# minor, a minor, G, F, d minor

I've just had to check out 'Autumn Almanac', I counted 26...

(A, A7, A9, Am7, Amaj7, Bb, B7, C, Cm, C#m, C#m7, D, Dm, D7, Eb, E, E7, Em, F, Fm, F7, F#7, G, Gm, G7, G#7)

You put them in alphabetical order?

Lol

Is that one of those Eno I Ching techniques that Carlos Alomar balked at?

If you count extensions (e.g. 7ths and 9ths) as separate chords, there are definitely over 16 in the Chicago song.

It's a real stretch to count A, A7, and A9 as different chords, though.

They sound different, therefore they are different.

You put them in alphabetical order?

― Under the Zing of Stan (James Redd and the Blecchs), Monday, September 5, 2016 4:43 PM (one hour ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

Fuck me, you're observant.

I'm just as God made me.

It's a real stretch to count A, A7, and A9 as different chords, though.

Yeah, tbf, A and A7 could definitely function differently if e.g A7 were a secondary dominant (V7/IV) in the key of A. A9 and A7 pretty much always have the same function, though, as do A and Amaj7.

Someone count up Deacon Blues and Aja.

Or still crazy after all these years.

I was thinking we should get to Steely Dan after Chicago.

xp

Yeah, tbf, A and A7 could definitely function differently if e.g A7 were a secondary dominant (V7/IV) in the key of A. A9 and A7 pretty much always have the same function, though, as do A and Amaj7.

(xxp) I was literally just going to post something about how Steely Dan must show up eventually!

Or someone especially sophisticated musically, like Stevie Wonder.

These kinds of arguments go way back

Or, if not that far back, at least to that other instance of this semi-regular ILX tradition for long weekends, the Great Music Theory Discussion of the Saturday Before Easter 2014.

I've just had to check out 'Autumn Almanac', I counted 26...

(A, A7, A9, Am7, Amaj7, Bb, B7, C, Cm, C#m, C#m7, D, Dm, D7, Eb, E, E7, Em, F, Fm, F7, F#7, G, Gm, G7, G#7)

Not counting the different extensions (and two discrepancies, one on the Eb - I think there's only an eb minor chord, and I think there's an augmented chord on the beat for "toasted" from "toasted, buttered currant buns"), the ones I'm missing are:

C and c minor chords?
e minor?
f minor?
g minor?

I don't hear these.

I figured out how to play this song as a teenager, by the way, but never really got through the whole thing!

Nice to look at it again - it sure is a great, great song!

I don't hear these.

― timellison, Tuesday, 6 September 2016 01:56 (fifty-one minutes ago) Permalink

Then yer doing it wrong.

Oh? Maybe you could point out where they are.

C, I got, by the way. Not c minor, though.

John Cale, "Ship of Fools"

'Crazy for You' by Slowdive is just C major and A minor.

'Age of Consent' by New Order is just D and G.

Ministry - "New World Order"

Gravity Rides Everything by Modest Mouse is just Cadd9 and G

Milligan claimed that he wrote this song as a bet, with his brother, that he could not get a song into the hit parade that had only two chords (in this case G and D7).[3]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nebe1zuEtbc

Tom Verlaine/Television, "Breakin' In My Heart"!

yes but which of these songs have the truth

― mookieproof, Friday, September 2, 2016 8:46 PM (six years ago)

"Practice Makes Perfect" is an unusual example of this, in that the two chords (Cm and G♭) don't share any conventional key or mode. Colin Newman did this again in the verse of "Don't Bring Reminders" (using B♭ and E), but tossed in three more chords for the chorus.