MADLIB - C OR D

it seems so boring and toothless to me, but then again I've always found four tet stuff to be like that. This doesn't really sound like madlib at all to me

for all the crazy finished projects that madlib's sitting on I wonder why they decided to put this out, but I mean I'm prob in the minority here thinking this

probably.
i love it.
i have no idea re the sample sources, and genuinely don't care.
if four tet can extract albums like this out of madlibs chaotic excess then so be it.
i love the flow of the album.
it's as simple as that.

Because Four Tet pushed for it, I think that's pretty obvious

Xp

it seems so boring and toothless to me, but then again I've always found four tet stuff to be like that. This doesn't really sound like madlib at all to me

― Bongo Jongus, Wednesday, February 17,

lol 100% of the music on the album is made by madlib and 0% by kieran. all he did was choose the songs from a file dump and sequence them

i thought he did some arranging

i dont want to weigh in til i listen to this whole project. i heard one song that did make me think bongo jongus might be right. felt like a loop madlib would pick, put into a familiar formal framework (arguably overfamiliar)

i will listen before saying too much more. but i wanted to legitimize the criticism cuz i think madlib's catalog is overwhelmingly huge and kind of discourages close critical reading by nature so ofc the four tet record is the biggest revive this thread had in years

he’s way too prolific, the ynq stuff is just uninspired noodling, but this is the best madlib release in a while

xp- from nyt

For “Sound Ancestors,” Hebden decided that although he could alter and manipulate the material Madlib sent him, he wouldn’t create any new sounds.

sounds nothing like the four tet madvillainy remixes

feel duty-bound to bump this tbh