Classic or Dud: Weird Al Yankovic

yeah a lot of his style parodies are straight up brilliant. they walk a fine line between tribute and parody while also being generally good songs on their own. I remember a buddy of mine who hated CAKE thinking "Close But No Cigar" was really great because "that's what all their songs sound like to me". but those of us who liked them thought it was a good tune too. I imagine that's not easy to do.

With the style parodies he usually gets to heart of the band's subject matter and tone. Casual listeners who maybe only know a handful of Devo songs would be unaware that so much of their post-Whip It output was dominated by these kind of advice songs where the lyrics use mangled aphorisms to say you gotta do this and you gotta do that or else this thing will happen. Ditto with his They Might Be Giants one - you can tell he's more than a casual fan. "Frank's 2000 inch TV" really kind of gets Michael Stipe in his yearning stream of consciousness style, like the opening lines and the bit where Al sings he's "going to get one of my own real soon" which (other than being ridiculous) is both upliftingly hopeful and quite sad, because you know he won't.

On the other hand, "Ringtone" isn't really a particularly good Queen parody but it's still a great, funny song.

“Virus Alert” nails glam era Sparks so perfectly.

I'm still waiting for a Primus one

Self-parody: the bane of parodists throughout history.

what makes the TMBG one so weird is I think he actually does get to the heart of what makes Linnell's songwriting so unique - but the lyrics are just a stream of goofy shit. so he gets the difficult part right, but whiffs on the easy part.

Feels like with the accordion solo Al is having fun challenging them a bit on the virtuosity.

otm re his style parodies being sublime, sometimes to a point that must frighten the artists. mothersbaugh called dare to be stupid "the most beautiful thing i had ever heard". (my fave song about reaganism, too, tho i'm sure it isn't meant to be.) similarly-- this is v dorky of me-- i think i prefer "germs" to both "closer" and "terrible lie".

Maybe this is over-thinking it but hear me out. The lyrics and the vocals are more typical of Gerald Casale songs - esp. on New Traditionalists, so maybe that's why Mothersbaugh gave that response.