a hot dog is

is a gordita or an arepa or a pupusa a sandwich?

is ravioli a sandwich

you're a sandwich

not the 1st time I've been subposted

stuffed pastries will maybe be sandwiches one day, but today is not that day. sorry empanadas, calzones, pasties, gorditas, arepas, and pupusas (i am assuming these are all stuffed breads/pastries -- not easy to find all of these in my city). ravioli is one step further removed.

pastry can be the bread of a sandwich though, ham and cheese on a croissant is A) delicious B) pastry-based C) sandwich.

as the self-appointed ILX Dean of Sandwiches I thank you all for your sandwich questions. I shall eat one sandwich deemed a "hot dog" in each of your honours.

war criminal

you can't self-appoint yourself to a position of power without breaking a few eggs

and before you ask, an omelet is not a sandwich

Gonna have some taco sandwiches for dinner tonight, can't wait.

Chicken pot pie - sandwich? It is stuff surrounded by a breadlike product.

For that matter, so is an apple pie.

pies are cousins of sandwiches. and tacos where is that even coming from

your logic traps do not make hot dogs any less a-sandwich

you're a cousin of a sandwich

i do have a cousin named reuben so joke's on you

https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/236x/6f/2e/69/6f2e6903af68ea2cec74507b851fced3.jpg

it's a clever pun you dumb idiots!

http://www.tmfile.com/mark/?q=783764574

because of the sandwiches which are there

i would like to draw everyone's attention to this sandwich called a "mother-in-law"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mother-in-law_(tamale)

i found this while researching sandwiches. after all a leader should be knowledgeable of that in his purview

your mother-in-law's a sandwich

once I ordered a pork chop taco in SA and it was a : pork chop, cooked normally with bone in, in a tortilla. I think that taco at least was a sandwich.

transgressive food delivery mechanism vs. tightly-curated finite list of predetermined, vetted creations

self-appointed ILX Dean of Sandwiches

after all a leader should be knowledgeable of that in his purview

oh i see, it's the old story, radical/revolutionary —> tyrant
sandwich robespierre

i'll have you decapitated and your headmeat served on a kaiser, motherfucker, test me

a hot dog is

what i'm going to have for dinner

we talking grilled and neat? or some swanky body hot dogs at a secret NYC club?

i'm just gonna sweat them in a bit of water in my frying pan, toss some butter in, brown'em, and then put them in a coupla buns with mustard and some cheddar slices, nbd, basic monday, what's with all the questions

i'm just gonna sweat them in a bit of water in my frying pan, toss some butter in, brown'em, and then put them in a coupla buns with mustard and some cheddar slices, nbd, basic monday, what's with all the questions

― jason waterfalls (gbx), Monday, August 3, 2015 7:24 PM (1 minute ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

my man

starting to think i should've found a way to exclude the queen's subjects from this poll, it's too important to have a bunch of people who don't know shit about hot dogs up in it

real talk

britishers are making a good case but I will keep voting for "not a sandwich " until system (a britisher too iirc) gets it

still not a sandwich

a hot dog is a sandwich if you slice it into thin, flat, and round slices, and then you put those on tiny slices of bread to make tiny bologna sandwiches

i'm game, don't slice too fine
http://newyork.seriouseats.com/images/2011/10/20111012-cumbre-headcheese-sandwich.jpg

a sliced hot dog, in slices, sliced on bread of any kind --- is not a hot dog

if the tube is intact between even an infinitely planar surface, it is still a hot dog, hinged bun be damned.

what about a hot dog annulus on a hamburger sandwich's bun?

or a hot dog annulus between smaller and larger radius bread annuli?

would that we had the technology

still a dog, dogg

https://www.rover.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/pug-buried-in-sand.jpg

If the thread didn't want UK input, it shouldn't have strayed so close to 'what is a pie' - pie phones are ringing softly across the country.

1741: His first completed work - a slice of bread, a slice of bread on top of that, and a slice of turkey on top of both - fails miserably. Bitterly disappointed, he returns to his studio and begins again.

"jason waterfalls (gbx)
Posted: August 3, 2015 at 7:06:51 PM
a sliced hot dog, in slices, sliced on bread of any kind --- is not a hot dog

if the tube is intact between even an infinitely planar surface, it is still a hot dog, hinged bun be damned."

God bless you my friend and saint and scholar

Main ingredient: bread.

I am not going to eat a "hot dog annulus." nope

cf andouillette

andouillette is like the supremum of hot dogs (sans bun of course)

Even though it literally smells like shit

Would you ever say the words "Hot dog sandwich"?

― AdamVania (Adam Bruneau), Monday, August 3, 2015 5:31 PM (Yesterday) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

are you arguing for tautology?
Since a hot dog is inevitably a sandwich you would be declaring the same semantic referent twice wouldn't you?

Is bologna a sausage?

Rag bologna is a long stick, or "chub" of high fat bologna traditionally sold wrapped in a cloth rag.

Our Hot Dog Was, Is (Townshend, 3:23)

I'm sorry, I know it's off-topic but can we go back to "patrissy" for a second?

lol that pug

i am making a late pass on this but imo this is a silly question. my thoughts:

1) yes, a hot dog is a sandwich - it is food served between pieces of bread. it does not matter whatsoever that people do not typically call it a sandwich or say "i want a sandwich, maybe a hot dog sandwich!", it is still technically a sandwich
2) a hot dog (or a folded pizza) is not a taco, fuck outta with that bullshit, a taco requires a tortilla, that is what makes it a taco, not goddamn bun. i can't even imagine what you are thinking when you call a hot dog a taco.