A Gentile's View of Today's Germany by William E. Grim
>
>- William E. Grim is a writer who lives in
>Germany and is a native of Columbus, Ohio. -
>
>I'm not Jewish. No one in my family died in the Holocaust. For me,
>anti-Semitism has always been one of those phenomena that doesn't really
>register on my radar, like tribal genocide in Rwanda, a horrible thing that
>happens to someone else. But I live in a small town outside of Munich on a
>street that until May of 1945 was named Adolf Hitler Strasse. I work in
>Munich, a pleasant metropolitan city of a little over a million inhabitants
>whose Bavarian charm tends to obscure the fact that this city was the
>birthplace and capital of the Nazi movement.
>
>Every day when I go to work I pass by the sites of apartments Hitler lived
>in, extant buildings in which decisions were made to murder millions of
>innocent people, and plazas in which book burnings took place, SS troops
>paraded and people were executed. The proximity to evil has a way of
>concentrating one's attention, of putting a physical reality to the
>textbook narratives of the horrors perpetrated by the Germans.
>
>Then the little things start to happen that over a period of time add up to
>something very sinister. I'm on a bus and a high school boy passes around
>Grandpa's red leather-bound copy of Mein Kampf to his friends who respond
>by saying "coooool!" He then takes out a VCR tape (produced in Switzerland)
>of "The Great Speeches of Joseph Goebbels." A few weeks later I'm at a
>business meeting with four young highly educated Germans who are polite,
>charming and soft-spoken to say the least. When the subject matter changes
>to a business deal with a man in New York named Rubinstein, their nostrils
>flair, their demeanor attain a threatening mien and one of them actually
>says, and I'm quoting verbatim here: "The problem with America < BR> is
>that the Jews have all the money." They start laughing and another one
>says, "Yeah, all the Jews care about is money."
>
>I found that this type of anti-Semitic reference in my professional
>dealings with Germans soon became a leitmotif (to borrow a term made famous
>by Richard Wagner, another notorious German anti-Semite). In my private
>meetings with Germans it often happens that they will loosen up after a
>while and reveal personal opinions and political leanings that were thought
>to have ceased to exist in a Berlin bunker on April 30, 1945. Maybe it's
>because I have blond hair and my last name is of German origin that the
>Germans feel that I am, or could potentially be, "one of them." It shows
>how much they understand what it means to be an American.
>
>Whatever the reason, the conversations generally have one or more of these
>components:
>
> (1) It was unfortunate that America and Germany fought each other in
>World War I I because the real enemy was Russia.
> (2) Yes, the Nazis were excessive, but terrible things happen during
>wars, and anyway, the scope of the Holocaust has been greatly exaggerated
>by the American media, which is dominated by Jews.
> (3) CNN is controlled by American Jews and is anti-Palestinian. (Yes,
>I know it sounds incredible, but even among the most highly intelligent
>Germans, even those with a near-native fluency in English, there is the
>widespread belief that the news network founded by Fidel Castro's friend
>Ted Turner, who was married to Hanoi Jane Fonda, is a hotbed of pro-Israeli
>propaganda.)
> (4) Almost all Germans were opposed to the Third Reich and nobody in
>Germany knew anything about the murder of the Jews, but the Jews themselves
>were really responsible for the Holocaust.
> (5) Ariel Sharon was worse than Hitler and the Israelis are Nazis.
>America supports Israel only because Jews control the American government
>and media
>
>For the first time in my life, then, I became conscious of anti-Semitism.
>Sure, anti-Semitism exists elsewhere in the world, but nowhere have the
>consequences been as devastating as in Germany. Looking at it as
>objectively as possible, 2002 was a banner year for anti-Semitism in
>Germany. Synagogues were firebombed, Jewish cemeteries desecrated, the No.
>1 best-selling novel, Martin Walser's Death of a Critic, was a
>thinly-veiled roman a clef containing a vicious anti-Semitic attack on
>Germany's best-known literary critic, Marcel Reich-Ranicki (who was a
>survivor of both the Warsaw ghetto and Auschwitz); the Free Democrat Party
>unofficially adopted anti-Semitism as a campaign tactic to attract
>Germany's sizeable Muslim minority; and German revisionist historians began
>to define German perpetration of World War II and the Holocaust not as
>crimes against humanity, but as early battles (with regrettable but
>understandable excesses) in the Cold War against communism.
>
>The situation is so bad that German Jews are advised not to wear anything
>in public that would identify them as Jewish because their safety cannot be
>guaranteed. How can this be? Isn't this the "New Germany" that's gone 60
>years without a Holocaust or even a pogrom, where truth, justice and the
>German way prevail amidst economic wealth, a high standard of living that
>is the envy of their European neighbors, and a constitution guaranteeing
>freedom for everyone regardless of race, creed or national origin?
>
>What's changed? The answer is: absolutely nothing. My thesis is quite
>simple. While Germany no longer has the military power to enforce the
>racist ideology of the Nazis and while all extreme manifestations of Nazism
>are officially outlawed, the internal conditions -- that is, the
>attitudes,world view and cultural assumptions - that led to the rise of
>Nazism in Germany are still present because they constitute the basic
>components of German identity. Nazism was not an aberration; it was the
>distillation of the German psyche into its essential elements. External
>Nazism may have been utterly defeated in May of 1945; internal Nazism,
>however, remains, and will always remain, a potential threat as long as
>there exists a political and/or cultural entity known as Germany.
>
>Now hold on a second, I hear many people saying. You can't possibly claim
>that Germans are as anti-Semitic today as they were during the years
>1933-1945. It is true that Germany today is much different than during the
>Third Reich. What is different is that due to its total defeat by the
>allies, Germany today is a client state of America and must do its bidding.
>That means repression of overt anti-Semitism. It's bad for business. The
>other thing that has changed is that, even though Hitler lost World War II,
>he was phenomenally successful in carrying out his ideological agenda.
>Germany, indeed virtually all of Europe, is essentially Judenfrei (free of
>Jews) today due to the efficiency and zeal of the Germans as they
>perpetrated the Holocaust during the Third Reich. In fact, a very
>convincing case can be made that Nazism is one of the most successful
>political programs of all time. It accomplished more of its goals in a
>shorter amount of time than any other comparable political movement and
>permanently changed the face and political structure of several continents.
>
>Germany is wealthy, stable, relentlessly bourgeois, and for all intents and
>purposes, free of Jews. Yes, there is a tiny minority of Jews, mostly
>centered in Berlin, and yes, there have been a number of Jews from the
>former Soviet Union who have emigrated to Germany, but most of the
>immigrants from Russia are not practicing Jews and do little if anything to
>promote a unique Jewish-German identity. The result of all this is that
>Germans today are able to reap the benefits of Hitler's anti-Semitic
>policies while paying lip service to the "need to remember." Young Fritz
>doesn't have to be overtly anti-Semitic today because his grandfather's
>generation did such a bang-up job of the Holocaust. There just aren't that
>many Jews left to hate any more, and besides, the Germans have their old
>buddies, the Arabs, to do their hating for them. You might call the
>overwhelming German support for the Palestinians to be a form of
>anti-Semitism-by-proxy. The German government has made cash payments to the
>State of Israel, as well as to individual Jews, to settle claims of murder,
>torture, false imprisonment, slave labor and genocide. Talk to most Germans
>and you'll soon discover that they think that the score has been settled
>between Germany and the Jews, that somehow the return of just a portion of
>what the Germans stole from the Jews is fair recompense for the deliberate
>murder of millions of people. If you think the Germans are truly sorry for
>what they did to the Jews, think again. There's never been an official "tut
>mir leid" offered by the Germans to the victims of the Holocaust and their
>descendants because that would admit culpability. Germany has paid off all
>claims against it without acknowledging responsibility in the same way that
>the Ford Motor Company engages in recalls of automobiles. It's all done to
>avoid liability.
>
>I have previously mentioned that Germans overwhelmingly support the
>Palestinians as opposed to the Israelis, and that this overwhelming support
>represents a form of anti-Semitism-by-proxy. Germans may claim to be
>supporting the Palestinians because they think they are an "oppressed
>people," but let's be honest - they are supporting the Palestinians and
>their Arab handlers because the Palestinians and Arabs share the same
>ideals as the Nazis. There's a long-standing history of German co-operation
>with the Arabs. In 1942 Hitler personally assured the Grand Mufti of
>Jerusalem that as soon as German forces conquered Great Britain, the Jews
>in Palestine (which was then under control of the British Mandate) would be
>exterminated.
>
>We should also keep in mind that the Arab terrorists who perpetrated the
>9/11 atrocities did their planning in Germany. There are several reasons
>for this. The first is the well-known bungling and de-centralized chaos of
>the German federal bureaucracy where literally the "linke" hand doesn't
>know what the "rechte" hand is doing. The second is that Arab terrorists
>can count on a substantial number of Germans who share their anti-American
>and anti-Semitic views. The former members of the SS and Hitler's
>praetorian guards, along with their neo-Nazi supporters, who gather weekly
>in Munich beer halls, made Osama bin Laden an "honorary Aryan" after the
>9/11 attack. Mein Kampf is also a best seller in the Arab world, especially
>in Saudi Arabia, America's putative "friend." Indeed, there is very little
>difference between the anti-Semitic rantings of Hitler and those of the
>so-called "spiritual leaders" of al-Qaeda, Hamas, and Fatah. The Arabs also
>owe Hitler and the Germans big time. Hitler killed off the Jews, and Konrad
>Adenauer and his "democratic" descendants replaced them with the Turks.
>Yes, the Turks aren't Arabs, but they are Muslim, and although Turkey is a
>member of NATO and has relations with Israel, many Turks identify and
>support their radical Arab co-religionists. Turkey remains as fragile a
>democracy as Weimar Germany during the 1920s. It wouldn't take much for
>Turkey to fall into the dark side of Muslim extremism. The end result of
>Muslim immigration into Germany has been twofold:
> (1) It allows the Germans to feign liberalism and being open
>to freedom and diversity; and
> (2) By replacing the Jews they murdered with Muslims, who for
>the most part are as viciously anti-Semitic as were the Nazis, the Germans
>have cynically assured that those few Jews who remain in Germany will be
>unable to reassert political power even in a minority role.
>
>A final point I would like to make concerning the reasons for the a
>resurgence of anti-Semitism in Germany is one that many will find at odds
>with the prima-facie evidence, or even appear to stretch the boundaries of
>common sense. Yet, I ask you to consider carefully my line of reasoning. In
>many respects Germany got away with the Holocaust without paying much of a
>price. Yes, many Germans died as a result of German perpetration of World
>War II and the Holocaust, and yes, there was much physical destruction in
>the country, but the situation is like the little boy who steals a cookie
>from the tray when it is cooling on the kitchen table. For his efforts he
>may have gotten his hand slapped by his mother, but the stolen cookie
>remains eaten nonetheless.
>
>After having committed the worst crimes in the history of humankind, the
>Germans were allowed to regain their sovereignty after only ten years;
>their infrastructure was completely rebuilt thanks to the generosity of the
>American people; and relatively few Germans were brought to trial for their
>monstrous crimes. Even those who were tried and convicted received
>relatively short sentences or had those reduced or commuted in general
>amnesties. For example, some members of the Einsatzkommandos, those Germans
>who, before the construction of the death camps, hunted and murdered Jews
>by the hundreds of thousands, received sentences of as little as five years
>imprisonment. If there were true justice in the world, Germany would no
>longer exist as a separate country, but would have long ago had its
>territory divided up and dispersed among the Allies.
>
>It was an unfortunate historical coincidence that the Cold War began just
>as Germany was at last being brought to task for its many crimes and
>atrocities extending back to the First World War. The new threat of the
>Soviet Union took precedence over a just settling of accounts with Germany.
>The tragic result is that many of the countries raped and despoiled by
>Germany, such as the Czech Republic and Poland, are just now coming out of
>decades of economic decline, while Germany - fat, sassy, arrogant,
>self-satisfied, and essentially Judenfrei- has enjoyed four decades of
>undeserved economic prosperity. We can't turn back the clock to redress all
>of the historical wrongs that have been committed by the Germans, but there
>are a number of things that can be done to assure that Germany can never
>again be in a position to threaten the rest of the civilized world.
>
>First and foremost is the realizat ion that, while not all Germans are
>anti-Semitic, there is an anti-Semitic tendency within German culture that
>extends back to the time of Martin Luther. Germans are instinctively
>anti-Semitic in the same way that Americans are instinctively freedom
>loving. Anti-Semitism has been and unfortunately remains the default
>ideology of the German people. All things being equal, Germans will
>instinctively support the enemies of the State of Israel. Therefore,
>America will need to monitor closely and be ready and politically willing
>to intervene at a moment's notice in German affairs when it appears that
>Germany is back-sliding into anti-Semitism. Additionally, it should be a
>goal of American foreign policy to oppose and to accelerate the
>dismemberment of the European Union. We must not allow German domination of
>the EU to accomplish through parliamentary maneuvering and brokered deals
>what Hitler and the Germans were unable to accomplish during the Third
>Reich.
>
>Given Germany's resurgent anti-Semitism (and that of France as well), a
>strong, German-dominated EU that tolerates and even benignly encourages
>anti-Semitism, and is diplomatically allied with the Arab world, is
>potentially the greatest threat to Judaism since Nazi Germany and a major
>threat to the United States as well. The enemies of Israel are the enemies
>of the United States. Let all Jews and Americans stand united as we
>proclaim never again to both the Holocaust and 9/11.
>
>_________________
>
>* This is the very first post-Holocaust picture of Germany that i have ever
>seen published that depicted the post-Holocaust country of the nazis
>with absolute accuracy in every detail. Over the years I have often written
>about the reunification of the two Germanys and described it as one of the
>greatest mistakes ever made in history, and wrote that instead naziland
>should have been divided into the four historical parts that is its nature,
>never to rise to brutalize its neighbors or the world again! A crucial and
>horrible error!
>
>It took only a few minutes during my first visit back to the land of my
>birth for me to realize that the place was clearly no different than when
>my
>parents and I had the good fortune to be among the very last Jews to
>escape, literally "minutes before midnight", when the gates of that
>man-made hell slammed shut with a resounding clang for the final time,
>dooming those of my people left behind, including over 50 of my immediate
>family.
>
>I recall the words of my beloved grandfather as we came to Breslau to say
>our final farewell, knowing that there was no likelihood of ever seeing
>each other again. He ran alongside the slowly rolling departing train we
>were on, knowing he was bidding a final farewell to his only son and his
>family. Even then he optimistically maintained that "no harm will come to
>us. After all, I served my country and my Kaiser as an officer, and have
>always been a good citizen."
>
>I do not know Mr. Grim, but I salute him for his clear view and thank him
>for writing this piece, which, had it been written by a Jew, would never be
>believed nor given its proper credence.
>
>Please do forward this article to your lists and see that it gets the
>widest possible circulation.
>- harry
>
― s1ocki (slutsky), Monday, 25 September 2006 23:00 (seventeen years ago) link