Drink full: The TWIN PEAKS 2017 spoiler thread, part 2

Did Laura only remove her face in season 3 or was that in the earlier stuff too?

Harring in MD is like the textbook example of Lynch getting a perfectly modulated performance out of a pretty limited actor. She's married to like the prince of Luxembourg or something so since money isn't an issue I bet her agent has had some fun over the years with the let's shoot for the moon strategy.

xxxp ahahahahah oh right, love that guy

she still has her countess title but divorced that dude in 1989, unless there's a different relationship that wikipedia/imdb hasn't tracked. she lives in LA, I think

oh n/m then, I'm all mixed up

That piece looks tldr but sciatica's post gets at my problem with a lot of readings, inc Adam's above which is a strong interpretation in many ways, which is that they seem to wilfully ignore the actual emotional texture of what we're shown

― streeps of range (wins), Thursday, September 7, 2017 2:23 PM (seven hours ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

what? why do you think this about my reading?

season 3 has been more emotionally gripping than ever before imo. Laura's scream is the end of the show, it is the defining last word in the series, it is and has always been terrifying. it the emotional nucleus of the series. this is why even when travelling to realities where Cooper barely remembers who he is anymore Laura's trauma is the defining force of the pan-dimensional universe of Twin Peaks. how can you say i am ignoring emotional texture, whatever that is?

i also fully support the realness of Ed/Norma/Nadine/Jacoby storyline and say that shit made me tear up every time i watch. Otis Redding live, the fucking pauses, holy shit. Ed looked so sad in that empty scene earlier, making this all the more sweeter. Nadine for once gets to make a decision about her life for a change. Jacob helped them dig out of the emotional shit, following through with them all in therapy at the end of season 2.

does it make it any less beautiful if it is an unreal dream? no, of course not. Gordon, Jeffries, and Cooper says "We live inside a dream", this is the ancient phrase. dream in the Hindu Kush sense, the playful creation of reality. we experience dreams as we experience our "real life", through the body, through the mind, through abstract concepts and labels we have given things physical and abstract. this is what they are talking about when they say life is a dream.

i like the time jumping and use of cutting around time periods, i think all three seasons now are sort of shuffled like a deck of cards. it flattens events, makes nothing less important than anything else. it heightens the ability to create/imagine where the mystery could go from there.

as for Cooper/Richard in that last episode i have no idea, he is sort of acting like a broken robot, i need at least a month to unpack all of this before saying i have a definite theory about any one scene in this entire series

sheryl lee has one of the all-time great screen screams

Laura's scream is the series mantra.

what is this emotional texture i am missing? what year is this?

since this thread has served its major function i'd like to say thanks also - it's been a lovely and stimulating thread and it's been a good time! an excellent reminder of what ilx is at its best!

i'd like to say thanks to ilx lurker, Priory, who sent me a helpful email off the back of this thread. I was unable to reply to your message since I couldn't find your details (ilx mail doesn't allow one to simply respond to a message!) - anyway, thanks and please de-lurk. x

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m8-_aJ1BiFE

xp all that's fine, I'm mostly thinking of this

he didn't fail tho! all season he was constantly winning without even trying. he even went back in time and stopped Laura from ever dying in the first place.

Which if you look at the ending and you're thinking "wow Dale wins again, just like in Vegas with the Mitchum bros, yep, literally no difference" you are ignoring entirely the emotional tenor of the finale, which is that of a nightmare.

^ wins OTM

Laura feels like she's a victim in some ways, unable to accept her solitude because Dale comes to force her to realign with her past trauma

I'd hardly call her life in Odessa "solitude." she has a dead body in her living room and has people after her either for that or something else. the universal trauma of Laura Palmer reverberated through Carrie Page's life, too.

not calling her life solitude, just saying she can't pursue true solitude

sorry if badly worded

and also i basically agree with what you said as well, that it reverberated through Carrie

Laura is stronger than Cooper though. The stubborn, insistent intrusion of fwwm into the return allows me to take comfort in that film's ending, which seems to stand outside of time (at least, it doesn't fit into the timeline of dale's visits to the red room in original series + tptr). Again, the whole end of this feels like a repetition of "don't take the ring", which was ultimately an insignificant failed intervention that Laura shrugged off as she dealt with her trauma her way. I think dale's more gravely trapped than she is by the end, precisely because her pain and sorrow can't be contained or undone.

https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/originals/b0/46/27/b04627a4b216f91d9cb7e9cf1eb77b7e.jpg

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CHEVGFae09s

https://i.redd.it/5i3doc4hjikz.jpg

From Reddit. The label on Janey-E's trousers says 'Paige'.

i cannot stop thinking about this show. nothing of value to add, just wanted to say that.

With you there :) Thought I'd see what the stars of TP thought of the finale, but not sure that's a good idea. Fenn, for instance:

Amen https://t.co/GOGfkAsSpk

— sherilynfenn (@sherilynfenn1) September 8, 2017

(never thought of her to be so into christ as she is)

yeah she's been like that for a while. and she's been supportive of the show as a whole and is pushing for a season 4; she an Lynch are friends, i believe. She certainly didn't go off her rocker like Julee Cruise did on FB for a day (she seems to be spending her time now backpedaling that, not very well because I don't think she understands how FB works).

I guess one side effect of keeping the story secret from everybody including the cast is that you have to deal with their reactions/disappointment/etc. Nobody knew what they were actually signing on for, and of course who knows how many scenes were filmed but not included. It is a heck of a lot to take on faith for an actor. I mean, nothing's ever guaranteed and all sorts of things happen in the editing room, but if you have a whole script at least have a general sense of what to expect.

This is true and understandable, but it may be advisable for the cast to maybe sit with it for a little while before making a public statement about their disappointment. Just sayin'.

That's not really fenn's way

This is true and understandable, but it may be advisable for the cast to maybe sit with it for a little while before making a public statement about their disappointment. Just sayin'.

Doh pocket post

There was an interview with fenn a week or so ago where she was enthusing about the material she'd been given, talked about doing the dance & said she couldn't talk about the finale in a way that intimated that she thought she would be in it (she also said she hadn't been watching, though). Of course we all want to believe scenes were filmed & cut because of the possibility we might see them one day! Anyway yeah she & lynch are I believe pretty close friends despite her complaining about mistakes made with the character to anyone who'll listen for the last 27 years, I doubt that'll change due to sherilyn being sherilyn on twitter

Dale wins again, just like in Vegas with the Mitchum bros, yep, literally no difference

hah did i say this? it seems like you are in a one sided argument

im just gonna dip out of this thread again. wins you have this weird bullying thing going on.

im out peace

xpost It's likely she's also still pissed about being paid scale.

I wonder who all the other teapots in the Fireman's house are/were

🙄

I gotta say, I understand being upset about unequal pay but also scale is still pretty fucking good. Actors are vastly overpaid.

Battery/capacitor things != Jeffries-like teapots imo

tbf being paid scale when you've had a reasonably active career to appear in a few scenes that most viewers will dismiss must be maddening. The prestige of this project will redound to Lynch and a few of the principles and hopefully (deservedly) Dana Ashbrook and not many others I assume, since it's such a niche thing. Amy Shiels will probably get work out of it. I don't think there's anything wrong with Fenn's response.

xp to Simon that may be true but it must be hard to reckon with that far into a career

also, you know, actors

yeah I don't think her response is unfair or unsurprising

Battery/capacitor things != Jeffries-like teapots imo

could be, idk I haven't rewatched and only noticed it briefly

I wonder if she'd be reacting differently if it weren't for a sizeable number of viewers vocally complaining about Audrey in particular

The stereotypical twin peaks fan is really fucking annoying

Not like ~us~ of course

Something something neutral milk hotel

hahaha

We're Audrey mega fans deeply disappointed in the wake of FWWM? I guess a lot of TP mega fans were deeply disappointed so it's hard to sort out, but you'd think they'd learn to cope by now!

Donna mega fans def were! There were two of them in the row in front of me when FWWM came out

Good comparison in that case because in both instances it was a strong use of the character, maybe the best, but people have a very fixed idea of how it ought to be portrayed

by the same actress?

I'm still haunted by seeing FWWM in a theater back in early April, followed by this kid who was probably in college asking his friend after the movie: "So I understand <points A, B, C> but would these other things make sense if I'd seen the tv show?"

I was really impressed how much of the plot he got and had guessed things about the show

in one of the instances, yes xp

I would totally have watched more of Audrey, but if you stitch together her scenes over those episodes you'd have a spooky standalone nightmare. I think her scenes are key to the whole thing, so it's not like she's not an important part.

otm!