Magic: The Gathering C/D

boros reckoner

like blockers that deal their extra damage to the attacking player? i don't think that exists

I guess reckoner doesn't do that

for example, you have a 3/3 with "blocker's trample" and you block a 1/1, you kill the 1/1 and deal the remaining 2 damage to your opponent

reckoner doesn't do that

why would you need that

yeah that doesn't exist on a card yet to my knowledge

I don't personally need it, just interested to know if such a card exists because I think it would be a neat idea

it would be difficult to template clearly and wouldn't be a very relevant ability (if it's going to trigger then your opponent is making a suicide attack anyway), so i doubt they'll do it unless they have a good reason

you are not attacking into bigger creatures often enough for it to be relevant that often

(xp)

oh i guess they could be attacking a 4/1 into a 3/3 with the ability and take 2, but that seems pretty narrow for how confusing the ability would be

it might work in something like

9/3 defender
all creatures your opponent controls must attack each turn if possible

yeah, I'd imagine it would either be a deterrent to attacks or perhaps you would attack into it if you had a bunch of creatures on the board

the cost on a 9/3 defender would be horrible

also it would encourage horrible board stalls, which is something design seems to be actively moving away from

ya it would have to be like 5 or 6 for that card to be fair

Ghosts of 1994
Creature - Spirit Wall

Defender, Cumulative Upkeep 5

Whenever combat damage is dealt by ~ it deals that much damage to target player

9/3

for each snow coevered land your opponent taps, prevent 1 damage

i'm still blown away that they actually thought it was a good idea to make a set with cumulative upkeep in it in the year 2006.

and yeah i know it was for the mechanical tie-in to ice age and i guess hibernation's end was a cool card but still

on the other hand if they actually did make a new snow block without all the early-magic bad design baggage of ice age attached i would probably love it to death

yeah ice age flavor is great

I think that despite NWO, they could easily slide back into the absurd mechanics of the past

soulbond seemed like a somewhat intentional attempt at a modern version of the banding concept

that's exactly what it was, although it is somewhat more comprehensible

I just think of soulbond like the two creatures are in love

wolfir silverheart has definitely stirred the emotions of many a furry

I actually thought Coldsnap was a really well-made set and I loved how they did Cumulative Upkeep that often tied into what the card did. Limited definitely had its issues (especially Ice Age "block" draft which was awful) but the set itself was very cool!

Also I was looking through some stuff last week and found a bunch of Unglued/Unhinged cards and I'm actually quite impressed by how funny some of them are. Kinda funny how Maro basically admits now that most silver-bordered cards are things that he tried to slot into regular sets at some point.

Though really I'd say that Future Sight sort of bridges the gap between the Un-sets and regular Magic

yeah i love coldsnap and the old ice age sets flavor-wise and nostalgia-wise but they just don't play that well. i'm hoping they try a redo on that concept sometime in the near future, much like how innistrad was vaguely like homelands.

if it had 300 cards and not 150 it would have been a really cool Limited format

(pun totally intended, by the way)

i have to think that norse mythology is on their shortlist of real-world things to mine for future blocks, which is somewhere snow could fit in okay

i wish dark depths wasnt banned in everything, thats in my top ten cards of all time

i was thinking that a norse-inspired set has to be on their shortlist of new planes to visit - also maybe an interesting way to revist the quest mechanic

a new fallen empires bloc could work

I guess onslaught already close enough?

I'm looking over the Cumulative Upkeep cards now and nearly all of them either power up over time or give you "change" when they die. I really loved the design of the Sphinx. I'm kind of surprised looking back at how many subtle references there were to old Ice Age era cards, and how many truly out there designs there were (the Wurm you could play from your library, or the Knight that could only be played from the graveyard). Ripple was a really cool mechanic. Recover I never really got.

the black recover spell is pretty busted in pauper

speaking of which, we should get some info on the fall set this week. i went to their panel at pax last year and it was kind of cool though in retrospect it's funny that restoration angel got the least enthusiastic response of any of the cards they previewed there. gonna try to make it again this year, though waiting in line for an hour for the chance to see like 5 preview cards that will be on the internet in minutes feels kind of dumb.

i hope we go to this place it seems pretty rad http://magiccards.info/extra/plane/planechase-2012-edition/trail-of-the-mage-rings.html

the planechase cards are all pretty cool looking though i've never actually played with them

planechase is pretty cool, it reminds me of that old e-league thing "Chaos Magic" which was one of the most fun things ever

i like planechase despite having never played it (although i won the baleful strix set as a door prize at a release event so i do own some of them) because i really like land cards

I'm gonna be at PAX this weekend too, cider - if you see an Indian dude in a shirt that says Overclocked Remix, say hi! (We're doing a panel for that website on Sunday.) I went last year but ended up getting in line for the Wizards panel too late, so this year gonna make it a priority. Though like you said, it barely matters whether you go to the panel or not, the spoilers get posted online basically mid-panel.

And as far as Coldsnap goes, I thought the design was decent but it was a very "careful what you wish for" moment for me. I'd previously thought a small set designed to be triple-drafted would be awesome, but the strategies in that set were so boringly linear. Feel like I should have predicted that.

oh cool you're an OCR person? i was part of that community way back in high school like 9-10 years ago but i've mostly drifted away from it now. i only have a saturday pass though so i can only do so much stuff, last year i didn't even have time to play any mtg events, just the panel.

i've never drafted coldsnap but the ripple cards seem like they could be pretty degenerate in draft

Yep! I do a bunch of various stuff for the site, cool that you've heard of it. Yeah PAX has way too many things going on, it's crazy. The only mtg I've played there was teaching my non-mtg friends using the 30-card beginner decks they give away.

you'd really need 5 before they got real crazy but yeah I always had the dream of getting like 5-6 Surging Dementias and basically winning the game on turn 2

getting 5+ of a common in a 3x small set draft seems within the realm of possibility though. ari lax drafted 8 ethereal armors at one of the RTR limited GPs, and that's in a large set.