Rolling Metal Thread 2009

tho I did chuckle a bit at the wtc/weed pic

I posted the Photoshop thing on MSN... http://bit.ly/7eCys2

I really do like Reinventing the Steel as an album best out of their whole catalog. Each disc before that had a bunch of solid songs, but that one really works for me as a cohesive unit.

Where did you see the pic first, Phil? I found that one on VLV. Wouldn't be surprised if it was 1st done there as there is a habit of that kinda thing on that forum. No doubt it's been posted on every metal/music board by now.

I grabbed it here, just now.

oh hahaha. I thought you had posted it earlier today.

Objectively I should thing that Dimebag/WTC picture is horribly offensive, but I gotta say its pretty cool. As is the man's grave: outstanding.

RIP to a guy who i truly think was fucking great.

substitute "think" for "thing"

I've browsed through the thread, but any recommendations this year for a metal dilettante who likes stuff like Gojira's The Way Of All Flesh (technical/progressive death metal, I guess)? I see the Mothra and Ulcerate being compared to Gojira. Any others?

If you like Gojira, you'll really enjoy France's Hacride. Their last two albums are superb.

Thanks - I will check them out.

i would heartily recommend the ulcerate album. to me, it shares elements with (bits of) blut aus nord, deathspell omega, gorguts and even, in the klangy, chimey interludes, early sonic youth. it SEETHES, furiously trying to suffocate or strangulate itself, then tolls. i think it's great.

(i am from nz and love heaps of music that's come from there, but i never woulda thought it likely a band from nz would produce a great dm album. i think this one is.)

sounds like something lj would love then

i reckon he should give it a go, yes. and other people too.

i wasnt impressed when i heard it but i do have pretty much zero tolerance for death metal

it is not gonna win anyone over who doesn't like death metal. the vocals are standard low bark, lyrics whatever. it's all about the writhing, claustrophobic instrumental density juxtaposed with the perfectly judged space and pace of the squamous slow breathers

(er. yeah, 'breather' as 'interval, interlude'; i shoulda just said that)

i have that record. i respect it tho it's a little tech-y for me to listen to for long stretches.

Song title of the day, from the new Arsis record: "Half Past Corpse O'Clock"

"arsis uh huh uhuh huh uhuh"
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_IiAFcfNAJmA/SqkOCljhPLI/AAAAAAAAA14/wyvsXZBLiHk/s320/bandb.jpg

Ulcerate is definitely working for me on a first listen. And I generally lean heavily towards early 90s DM.

hey writers/reviewers of ilx you might like this
http://www.teufelstomb.com/reviews/withoutmercy-withoutmercy/

djmartian should read the middle bit especially :)

That was shit

If this dude has been writing about metal for 15 years how has he not noticed that like 80% of press releases are exactly like that one

Dude shouldn't talk about his girlfriend like that in a review. That's no way to maintain a relationship.

Here's a link to part three of my trawl through the Decibel Top 100 list... http://bit.ly/787X19

sound advice

I must say that i am enjoying the hell out of unperson's daily dissection of the Decibel list.

That review posted above is painful, not to mention atrociously written.

And Phil, you really should hear Ludicra...they're good!

They are, but I was a bit disappointed by the new song. Another Weakling throwback was not what I was expecting from these guys (and girls), hopefully the album will have more John Cobbett rifftasticness than this preview.

Listening to three songs from the Charred Walls of the Damned disc - Ripper Owens on vocals, Jason Suecof on guitar, James DiGiorgio on bass and Richard Christy (it's his band) on drums. Power metal, flamboyant and unashamed. Not my thing, but whatever.

xpost - I'm not sure which track Ludicra posted but I've had the new album for many months and it's fantastic. There is one song that is a bit more in the Weakling/WITTR vein so I'm assuming that's the one that you heard? Trust me, there's Cobbett all over this thing. And there's more big news ahead :)

is the Ludicra track called "A Larger Silence"? The one posted on Brooklynvegan?

Nate's right, the new album is very strong.

is the Ludicra track called "A Larger Silence"?

That's the one I heard, yup. It's fine, just not the next-level thing I was hoping for. I just did a big USBM piece (in Dutch) saying Ludicra is *the* band to keep an eye on, so they gotta come through big time, ya know ;)

Trust me, there's Cobbett all over this thing. And there's more big news ahead :)

Sweet! So what is it, Scalzi joining the fold, or what?

No, it's US tour-related.

(and Canada)

Day Four of my journey through the Decibel best-of-the-decade list may be the most argumentative one yet... http://bit.ly/4YGMhw

i still think panopticon is every bit as great as Oceanic, Phil. Lots of ilmers agree too.

I on the other hand perhaps predictably co-sign w/Phil 100% on Panopticon

I actually like it more than oceanic but would be hard-pressed to argue why. they're very similar but panopticon felt like a refinement of the sound, maybe?

could just be a matter of context. with oceanic, I was a bit disappointed at the time with how they scaled the heaviness way down from celestial. wasn't expecting much from panopticon but was pleasantly surprised.

they're pretty much on a par, but maria's vocals on 'the weight' give oceanic the edge.

mind you, my affection for isis has diminished severely of late. the last two albums were shockingly dull.

phil are you gonna do your own decade-end list on yr site? would be much more interesting to me than reading abt what is metal and what is not metal.

the new isis album is a lot better than Absence Of Truth

yeah, I agree. hated absence of truth but the new one is pretty good.

i didnt hate i just didnt think it was as good as what preceded it.

Oceanic and Wavering Radiant are my two favorite Isis discs. I also like the Oceanic remixes set quite a bit. But my favorite thing about Isis remains my memory of seeing them on tour with Botch in (I think) 2000 (might have been 1999); they were much more experimental than they've ever been on record, or on any of their live discs. At one point, the song they were playing melted down to a theremin/didgeridoo improv duet.

I'm not sure yet if I'm gonna do a full decade-end list, but I am gonna do something later this month.

Amon Amarth's exclusion from the list I'll give you (I had Twilight of the Thunder God in my top 10), but Megadeth and Judas Priest? Megadeth had one album this decade that came even close to being great (Endgame), and Judas Priest had two incredibly uneven records, neither of which I would have included. I can think of much more shocking omissions.

Dude, if they can find room for Fugazi, they can find room for Nostradamus, which might be uneven but has at least one full disc's worth of killer stuff. I still listen to it. Not weekly by any means, but frequently.