Oh! The Fall John Peel Sessions box set! OH! you guys.

Thanks for doing this! Its inspired me to pull out the box and finally load it on to my iPod!

They're all first-listens, so my feelings, usually those of astonishment, are fully genuine, and fully fresh. Sessions 3 and 4 are eerily similar in their
barnstorming-opener-followed-by-long-3rd-track-that-actually-threatens-to-damage-your-mind way.

I was thinking to myself "He's not going to be able to contain his "Hip Priest" review to three lines"

yup.

*relistens to New Puritan with headphones off this time, thus preventing death*

Oh ye 90s compare...
LP vers:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KJSCLVtnouo
Peel vers:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L2Mx534urnw

Absolutely. And oh yes, that Peel version of Hip Priest is some inchoate primal brilliance.

Looking forward to the next session reviews, which is my favourite:

Session 5 - 26 August 1981 - produced by Dale Griffin
"Deer Park"
"Look, Know"
"Winter"
"Who Makes The Nazis?"

ask and ye shall receive

Deer Park - This time the keyboards are an oppressive layer of sheet-metal. MES is being satirical and snarky, I think. (You ask: when is he not? Well, especially so here.) The guitarist appears to have been given free license to play what he wants, as long as it's in that one chord. Bass plays the melody. Drums suddenly become more pounding in the last minute. Decent intro, I expect it to pick up now.

Look, Know - Again, the bass is prominent. So far this session hasn't been so much my thing, for some reason. "I don't give a shit what I look like" - ok, in the second verse this is picking up. Hahaha, BUM NOTE (seemingly) on bass into chorus! That's actually kicked the track into gear, like how Polonius' forgetting of his lines in Act Two Scene One of Hamlet launches the play properly. Yeah, the guitar squalls make sense now. And fuck there's a perfect li'l solo! Haha!

Winter - This has begun promisingly, like a slightly more straightforward Hip Priest. Love the buzzing noise that develops. "He looked like the victim of a pogrom!" Slyly this has become brilliant and there's another guitar solo, just a subtler one. Keyboards being deployed superbly. I've fallen in again. MES SINGS! "TAKE THIS MEDALLION!" Bass suddenly foregrounds, guitar goes off-kilter. Bass plays a FUNKY BREAKDOWN for NO REASON. God, I love this band. Bass then appears to go out of tune. Keyboard still makes surreal merry. This is approximately 5334714x better than the album version. Weird, heavy, ecstatic and slightly wrong. OH SHIT - buzzy keyboard solo in final movement just killed me. THE FALL KNOW BEAUTY. CRAP THE BASS AT THE END I DON'T EVEN

Who Makes The Nazis? - Hahahaha this is so badly-played, it's genius. It's like MES is playing the guitar himself! Maybe he is. Because there's another guitar now and it's playing the air-raid siren noise that music should make when The Fall are about to pounce on it. Need I mention the drums? "LONGHORN BREED." Now that guitar again on its own, joined after exactly the right number of bars by the drums. And then...what the fuck is happening in the right channel above my ear? What chaos? What hell?

Who Makes the Nazis with the plastic guitar is my favorite Peel track.

Next one up is my favourite Fall recording ...

Next one up is the one I'm looking forward to the most out of all of them. Am savouring the minutes before I stick it on.

I'm listening to the next session now, in anticipation.

Smile - Christ, the echo on the guitars! The slurred drums! MES lost in the vortex of musical fury arising from beneath him! You can barely distinguish the chords after a short time. Then the bass begins to explore. What I sense here is a terrifying pound, guitars as meat-cleavers. MES isn't shrieking or going catatonic, like on the album version. He's controlled, self-possessed, trying to keep it together as the roar intensifies. One-way ticket to the abyss, this one. No let-up.

Garden - Already one of the better Fall songs, here the very length indicates monstrosity. The guitar-line's been embellished with a major-chord, as if to throw me off the scent. Instead feels like some sort of Eastern incantation, like a Velvet Underground song that's found a proper drummer. No offence, Mo! Ha, I was kidding! No, I was! Honest. OK, the drum pulse during the first guitar breakdown...you can keep ya fancy NYC whackers, this is Rock Almighty, this is Lore. This is the fourth consecutive Peel Session with an elongated musical dissertation on precisely what makes music a force to be reckoned with, except there's two more after this one! Another breakdown, then a retreat. Briefly. Bass crushes home like justice. "JACOB'S LADDER - WAR ZONE!" This session is if anything even more composed than the previous ones. I say that, and "He's here! At last! He's here!" brings the panic. Then a weird snake effect. Then a broken organ. Then a Jew on a motorbike.

Hexen Definitive - Strife Knot - This is all minor-chord, all sadness. Glue pastes band to floor of recording room. Love how the chord changes for the chorus only once, stays at that chord until the energy is spent, and then returns to the initial pattern. Strange tooth-picking percussion. Guitar as church bell, tolling for the song it plays. Things go awry and the bass fades into view, distorted, like a surfacing Kraken. Song has mutated. Earth corrupts into fear. Guitar plays ballad for its own tortured strings, like plucked wire on a pig-farm. Call and response with evil of bass. Run. Run from this fucking song, but don't hide, it'll find you. After the religious contention of the previous track, this is the unbidden visitation of putrescence that we craved. And the guitar, finally, vomits at the sight of itself.

Eat Y'Self Fitter - One of my favourites, this was always the funniest and oddly one of the catchiest Fall songs. Here's to a romp! A fearsome, righteous romp! Oh god the response vocals are so quiet, hehehe! It's like MES is king and queen, and the VASSALS can cry from beneath the BATTLEMENTS. Need I add, the drums are insanely enormous. They dwarf even the guitar-line. Oh god those drums! Tribal primal horror excavation mechanism fury. The random blurts of noise accompanying "UP THE STAIRS MISTER" are a treat. Drums seem to stall, then power back in with more snare. They're all getting their cues slightly wrong and it's awesome. This is ineffable. Oh, is Mr Weird Organ trying to jump the party again? HE IS INVITED. Song impossibly becomes even more of a rave, just before the 'centimetre square' bit. Then rides roughshod over the carcass of YOUR EARS, DEAR LISTENER.

Glad you pointed out, inter alia, the slightly altered 'he's here! I saw him! I swear!' lines. I think the crucial addition is 'he's back!' For some reason this always produces a little nick extra of panic and fear.

Listening to the session version of Smile the other day as well and was struck how much the sounds seem to slide around compared to the album version. It feels stranger, loosed from structural bonds.

In case it wasn't clear, Hexen Definitive was my favourite. It's been a good run for third tracks.

Have we ever discussed which tracks beat their LP counterparts? That Youtube example above really shows how much more muscular and focused is the Peel version of "Ladybird". Not all of them are, though - the Peel version of "Hey Student" is disappointing.

even with the lyric changed to "As you masturbate to your Shawn Ryder face?"

I think there was a thread on the Peel sessions somewhere, but I'm not at my computer so I can't search.

Generally I'd say they're better, some much better - Squid Lord and Blindness to take two. I must admit I love the session Hey! Student - not least that wail at the end! tho the album version is great in its locomotive force as well.

OK, that's a week's rest.

Off you go again!

Yes, please.

no sleep for the wicked

Pat Trip Dispenser - Awesome mumbled backing vocals and off-key bassline in the chorus, and amazing post-chorus Marc Ribot-style guitar breakdown! Shit! And then it builds marvellously back into the verse. And you can hear Brix. This band is fucking on FIRE. It's as riveting as any of the openers so far. Guitar work is simply brilliant. MES rant 2/3 of way through is excellent. Oh god, this is the crazed POP MUSIC that The Fall hadn't really in all earnest made so far. I'm not exaggerating - this is WELL inside the top 10 of Peel Sessions songs I've heard so far. HAHA there's SUCH an awesome (piano?) drone over the last bit!! THIS IS FUCKING PHENOMENAL.

2x4 - Rockabilly! They play it well. Not quite the somersaulting blast of wrong-headed bizarreness that is the opener. Sometimes a repetitive bassline is transcendent for The Fall; not quite so here. Can't fault the performance. Gets better towards the end when the guitars and drums are allowed to explore a bit.

Words Of Expectation - You said it. 9 minutes long, 3rd track in the session, I'm expecting greatness. OK. A promising bass thunder. Distant radio recordings. MES phoned in from his own dingy basement. Crisp drums. Portentous, hanging, and enter MES for real. With one of the most righteous opening lines he's ever uttered. As the chattering goes on beneath. And the guitar chimes like a damaged thing and a female voice from a badly-manipulated tape rambles. Elements are gathering. It's a faintly major-key-tinged train into something horrendous, and we've only just begun. I don't need to say that it's gripping as all hell. It's also somehow completely different from all the other Peel Sessions monsters. Then, 4 minutes in, a sudden build, and the guitars become thumbtacks. Bass lurches. OMG THE KING CRIMSON LINE HAHAHAHAHA!! Don't think you've really got your Fripp on to be honest but nice image. MES has wrestled control of this song away from his bandmates, which is why I think it's not quite as good as the other long-form ones (maybe except Garden); he's the undisputed star, with his "HALIFAX...COPTER". It's not a double-helix dropping into some inferno. Until the 8-minute mark, which has thankfully just come and put the rest of the band into a spin-dryer. That's more like it. There IS something pretty hypnotic about the bassline; I'd say on balance it works nicely, although more as an MES vehicle than a Fall one. The best bit was the first half with the recorded voices.

C.R.E.E.P. - OK, if PTD was crazed pop music, this isn't even crazed. Energetic yes, but not imbued with terrifying gnostic vision. It's pretty catchy, I guess. 'Catchy' isn't ENOUGH, though! I want my Fall catchy AND fearsome! Or at least catchy and violently unorthodox. I'm griping unnecessarily; this really is quite the tune.

*listens to Pat Trip Dispenser again, because it was NEXT-LEVEL*

2x4 and CREEP better served as LP version imo, I love Pat Trip but am not as familiar with this version, such a great song. Words Of Expectation - another classic mostly-unreleased tune (Kimble CD EP from '94 or so and nowhere else I think, same version) that shows up in a lot of live recordings from the era, some of which are great (Rotterdam 83).

Speaking of which, does anyone have a high quality live gig from the 84/85 era they can share? Apparently we won't be getting one with the upcoming deluxe reissues of "The Wonderful And Frightening World" and "This Nations Saving Grace".

Cruiser's Creek - Haha, he can't pronounce 'excerpt'. Silly Mark. And then, yeah, that riff. OMG! Blast of keys/guitars when it enters the chorus is guaranteed to wake a few people up. This was never my favourite Fall at all, although it is for a surprisingly large number of people. This is a good if not game-changing performance. Guitar/keys blast aside, which just shook me up again. Oh what there's 3 and a half minutes left?! How are they gonna spend it? I think I'll grab a mini-doze, see if they feel like waking me up again. Of course they do. MES' vocals becoming more strained each time is nice. OK, I'll say it: this is something of a dirge, and not in a good way. Needs to be half as long and twice as evil. Now stop. STOP. Dammit. OK, blast me again first why dontcha.

Couldn't Get Ahead - MORE LIKE IT. This is somewhat classic. And guess what? It's half as long as Cruiser's Creek! And about...five times as evil! This is a truly stirring, blockbusting performance, harmonica buried in the noise-mash of the chorus the highlight. So good it's given its own weird solo. This chorus is the HELLMUZIK that The Fall make at their best. The tune is and always has been great. No complaints, only praise.

Spoilt Victorian Child - Promising. But it's kinda lost me. Suffers from same syndrome as Cruiser's Creek, I fear. OK, there's a nice bit now, with a suspenseful build over thundering toms and pregnant guitars. Then it goes back to the original pattern, which is boring. How the FUCK did this win the TNSG poll? I cry fix. But then I'm a menk who would've voted Paintwork so don't listen to me. Crap there's two minutes left! You should have ended! Oh it's the suspense bit again. Fall Peel Session Eight: officially the worst yet. By a long way. And that's WITH a super li'l 2nd track. END NOW PLEASE. Oh, the last 30 seconds are quite good. Why couldn't the whole song be like this?

Gut Of The Quantifier - Big drums, MES with purpose, surely this will be good. And here we go. Gah, this doesn't have much going for it except for the bassline. It's just not an inspiring performance. I've heard the second TNSG session is a vast improvement over this; it'd better be. It's too busy and clinical with its repetition. It's like a sort of mushy compromise between pop and Fall, rather than the thrilling merge we saw in Pat Trip Dispenser. I guess Couldn't Get Ahead was a fine piece that forged something pretty righteous.

Speaking of which, does anyone have a high quality live gig from the 84/85 era they can share?

yeah, but only one, WOMAD from June 85. I'll msg you, it's in flac.

and o yes Gut Of The Quantifier on proper LP version is all time top ten for me.

"Words of Expectation" my favorite thing in the box.

thirded re Gut.

L.A. - Loving the tannoy intro! YES! THIS PLAYING! Already this session is better than 8. Dual guitars with purpose and bass you can chew on. And Brix having some kind of Krautgasm. And some lovely atonal shimmer. This is propulsive AND building. When all the guitars start playing the same thing and MES starts repeating 'L' and 'A' it gets intense. Now where? I'm eager to find out. Guitars go up the scale as Brix intones! It's all taut and chaotic at once. Then MES comes back in as Brix says "This is MY happening!" and it's all confluence of excellent things. Thumbs up. Oh and there's time for another go-round! With a FADE-OUT! Ladies and gentlemen, TECHNOLOGY.

The Man Whose Head Expanded - Haha, this is a weird interpretation of the keyboard riff. And now - HEAVY! Much heavier than the original. This one always had fine lyrics and they're delivered well. Breaks down into a sort of langorous pop midsection. If this breaks back to the original motif then it'll seem a bit formulaic. Well, it does, but there's a mental tannoy "Over! Over! Over!" in the background so it's forgiven, plus the guitars are being ruinous. Oscillating synths in the background are the bomb, and the song appears to be speeding roughly to a conclusion with everything going haywire. Overall, pretty excellent.

What You Need - This one's clearly the 'gritty' one of the set. Sheets of synth punctuate an industrial thud of nagging guitar and deep drums. Then a low and fiery bassline enters. This is mesmerising and has lost me in a GOOD way. The drum becomes a pulse, then a hi-hat, as guitars chug, and it's all very psychedelic. I don't know what the alchemy is this time, and I like that fact. I think the bass is getting steadily louder but this may be a mirage. Menacing and YES THE DRUM INTRO! With the tribal chanting and the handclaps! And MES lowing beneath. Brilliant, linear slice of Fall madness.

Faust Banana - I'm a big fan of DKTR. Faustus so this ought to deliver. And a fade-IN this time! Multiplicity of voices. The chorus was always the star in this song and it's done well. Hmm, maybe this song isn't as awesome as I remember. It's no Gross Chapel or Riddler. Or maybe the recorded version, woodblocks and all, is better. (Well, it is.) But this isn't bad at all! It's more drawling, more shambling. Oh wait, it DOES have a woodblock! Haha! Nice. And it's using it to slowly drag us into the quicksand. Marvellous. This has actually become really, really good in the last two minutes. Maybe the two versions are equivalent. Maybe this one's pulling ahead! Shit, this is a good final movement. The woodblock here might be even better-deployed! Awesome.

written last night while internet was down. gut of the quantifier is much better served by LP version obv

Next Session contains the single TRACK I've most been looking forward to, namely Gross Chapel - British Grenadiers. Words can't express my love for that song, and I am crackling with anticipation. It's getting put off until I'm fully psyched.

Having spent a long time only having heard the LP version of 2x4, that session version gets me every time - the way it blows through the wall at the end and keeps on going. Kind of a water mark as well, when they really started getting some snap, crackle and pop - it really f'ing moves. 'There's a new fiend on the loose, it's a fear of the obtuse' - damn straight.

Love Words of Expectation obviously, it really lopes along, amazing bass and guitar playing. Also thoroughly recommend the live version on the re-issued Room to Live. I quite like CREEP as well, prefer it to the single possibly, a little explosive savage music box.

Persevere with Spoilt Victorian Child, jaggedy pop, with those sudden moments of dirge-like delerium, dropping out, brilliant vocals.

What You Need (especially) and Faust Banana just incredible - one sparse, taut, every varying repetition w' brilliant commandments over the top, the other deranged Mittel Europ renaissance carnival stomp - 'sparse gartens in vinter' and 'fruits exotic' indeed.

Gross Chapel... (crosses self)

Hahaha, now I'm truly psyched! Well, more or less. Yeah, I didn't quite realise where Faust Banana was going, but the end put the whole thing in context - it may WELL be better than the eventual version. Really REALLY wish there'd been a Peel Session of Riddler! but you can't have it all.

2x4 did get better towards the end, yeah. I think it got simultaneously more tuneful and more intense. Just as I was having my doubts it emerged as a super li'l pop song.

That version of "Man Whose Head Expanded" is colossal. They almost never looked back in Peel sessions but that was a great call, and as much as I love the studio version I pull up the Peel take when I want to hear it. You'll find a few other re-visitations towards the end of the box that are equally wonderful.

Couple of things - here's the Peel Sessions poll, for added commentary and reference fun.

And also - I was just bumbling around the Fall website:

In 1980 The Fall released Fiery Jack (January), Totales Turns (May),
How I Wrote Elastic Man (July), Totally Wired (September) and
Grotesque (November).

I mean I knew this, but, wow, just... wow.

I have trouble writing a sentence some days. Including today. Dreadfully hungover.

Spoilt Victorian Child is one of my fave Fall songs, pls to relisten.

Been tearing through this box for the last 4-5 days, just moved on to disc 6. Weak start to this one. Really looking forward to seeing acoleuthic continue.

via lj

Hot Aftershave Bop - Awesome little wistful riff to open! And then we plunge into the garage body of the song - a second guitar is doing lovely seagull-slide things in the background. The bass is exploratory and the mix is lush. I really, really like this already. Chord-change! He loves somebody a lot, and the melody has bent sinister. This song is like a cupped handful of mercury sloshing around in a pleasant and slightly poisonous way. MES even screams. His hands shake and we end on an almighty garage rave-up. Super.

R.O.D. - Galloping drums, whispers. Promising. Then - oh shit it's the 1980's!! That keyboard tone! Finally, The Fall have stepped out of the inexplicably ancient. But they've taken their guitarist with them. And now the keyboard betrays a garish organ tone, which is only a good thing. Song uses tension deliciously, pulls back when threatening to explode. This is beautiful. This is MUCH better than the album version. I'd say so far this is one of the 2 or 3 best sessions, actually. But then I always loved Bend Sinister. I always thought that album had the right mix, the right sound, the right songwriting ideas, even if it didn't pull off the album itself as staggeringly as some others. This drones and rocks on like a sad thing in the grips of illness. Guitar begins to sound a *bit* like The Cure. Again, this is not an unwelcome development. And now the lead guitar lapses from notes to chords and it's sweet as. All is ending gauzily, hazily, perfectly...

Gross Chapel - British Grenadiers - OK, this is the one. One of the greatest songs ever written by man. And it's started excellently, stereo panning effects fitted as standard, MES spoken intro backgrounded and menacing. Guitar enters! And it's curter, brighter somehow than the album version. A little more garage. The lead guitar is crazed with the same poetry that informed previous Peel Sessions monsters. MES is quiet. This is a song which demands that he be quiet. He can't overcome this mood his band's instruments are creating. The drums create such forward momentum. This song, while moody and slinky, is really fucking driving too. This is a slightly faster, more vicious version of the hypnotic original, but it loses barely any of that song's qualities while adding a few of its own. Guitars mirror each other, then back to the riff of riffs. Where did they come up with that riff from? I think it might be perfect. Lead guitar is trying hard not to lose it. This is not a song to lose it entirely in. It is a song about a riff and intimations therefrom. And all of a sudden it's completely enveloped me. It holds on, then gracefully retreats. Its point has been made articulately. A fever-dream heatstroke nightmare of a song. And then MES howls the final words. Out of key.

US 80s-90s - More roly-poly than the album version, more...slinky! This 10th session has a real fucking groove, a liquid constitution. The bass especially has been poured into my ears, brutally poured. Iron slag but fluid. The artificial-sounding drumbeats are a lovely touch, especially as this appears to be a comment on rap production. There's even record static in the background! The bassline, in its fluidity, has an upbeat funk. Counteracting this are the guitars, droning (and fairly liquid themselves) but harsh enough to coat everything in lysergic bile. Need I add, but this sounds huge. And MES, while he's been calm in this session, is as authoritative as he's been. Lead guitar begins to scratch and spit towards the end, as if to remind us that it can. And that it really likes it. In fact, the ending is a sort of surreal tech-vision-groove-battle. Breathtaking fucking session.

Oh thanks!

this is one of my favourite sessions too. i like the way they distilled the essence of whatever lp they had out at the time and made it better

More, please!

yeah!

Did our kid get banned again?

Can't believe I just referred to lj as "our kid", sorry everyone.

He self-banned so as to get on with some uni work, I believe.

Yeah I heard he was doing this David Blaine-ish stunt where he is like living for six months (possibly frozen in ice? possibly in a cage over the Medway? possibly just in his pants? I dunno) and during that time he's not posting to ILX. People keep baiting him by posting stuff about the Fall etc but through the power of mind alone he is managing to hold out.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/nol/shared/spl/hi/pop_ups/03/entertainment_living_with_david_blaine/img/1.jpg

Hey Louis have you heard the new Cardiacs record?

Truly, lj is like a modern day Jesus, suspended in a perspex box for our prog rock related sins.