Rolling Past Expiry Hard Rock 2010

Message Bookmarked
Bookmark Removed
Not all messages are displayed: show all messages (1307 of them)

Just determined that Fastway's 1984 All Fired Up is split more or less evenly between songs that sound like Led Zeppelin had 14 or so years before (Side One, best examples: "Misunderstood," "Station," and much slower ooze blooze "Hurtin' Me") and songs that sound like Cinderella would four years later (Side Two, best examples: "Tell Me," "If You Could See".) Can't think offhand of anybody who's done Zep better, overall, since In Through The Out Door (which isn't exactly what I said in my review of Fastway's self-titled 1983 debut in Stairway, which still doesn't explain why I ranked it way down at #389 and then got rid of my copy after the book came out.) Anyway -- killer rhythm section including ex-Humble Pie Jerry Shirley on drums, Dave King's a great lemon squeezing squealer, and Fast Eddie Clarke's on guitar. How come nobody talks about these guys anymore? ("All Fired Up," the title track, is also an excellently speedy NWOBHM facsimile.) Popoff actually gave the debut a 10, though, and this followup just a 6, but I don't remember the first one being that much better (if it was, it's got to be one of the greatest rock albums of all time.)

xhuxk, Monday, 18 January 2010 02:42 (fourteen years ago) link

Speaking of Zepalikes, I heard Whitesnake's "Here I Go Again" over the car radio a few weeks back, and thought it totally sucked eggs. But I guess "Still Of The Night" was their great Zep rip, right? I haven't owned any of their albums for decades, though; maybe they had other ones. (Also have no recollection of whether Kingdom Come were any good.)

xhuxk, Monday, 18 January 2010 02:47 (fourteen years ago) link

Hah, Dave King's been in the Flogging Mollys for years where he does very little lemon squealing.

Kingdom Come did the bald-faced "Kashmir" rip. I still have their second record "In Your Face." It's better than the abuse they got but not by a great deal. The main thing is the singer spent so much time sounding like Robert Plant that he can't easily not sound like Percy, so it still sounds like Zep. But it has the late-Eighties hair metal overproduction so it never really sounds like Zep when you get right down to it. It's a big blocky hard rock and metal album with the usual bits of overwraughtness and howling in the gail.

Gorge, Monday, 18 January 2010 03:39 (fourteen years ago) link

Makes sense, huh?

Gorge, Monday, 18 January 2010 03:51 (fourteen years ago) link

Actually, I don't think Plant does much lemon squealing himself these days. (Though maybe I did overstate King's squeal at least...a little.)

xhuxk, Monday, 18 January 2010 04:59 (fourteen years ago) link

Thing about Whitesnake is the US audience mostly knows the band by the big production Eighties sexy video completely over the top thing. That band's utterly different from first half career Whitesnake which is Deep Purple with Glenn Hughes kicked out and Juicy Lucy guitarists all to do extended blooz rock with David Coverdale doing his almost-Percy impressions. Doesn't sound like Zep. A comfortably stodgy Brit hard rock band with lots of name value, successful in Britain, unheard of over hear until makeover. I have a live album from the Hammersmith Odeon. It's pretty much an excersize in 7 to 12 minute numbers. About five songs on it, sort of like the first live Rainbow album.

A couple years ago the old Whitesnake cranked up their career in Europe again with a couple releases as Band of Snakes. Stodgy friendly arena-ready mid-Seventies blooz rock, acceptable as live recordings if you like that stuff.

The original single version of "Here I Go Again" isn't a band at all, just famous ringers and Coverdale produced by Dan Huff before he was famous in Nashville. So Taylor Swift should probably cover it.

Gorge, Monday, 18 January 2010 16:55 (fourteen years ago) link

Gene Dante made me laugh, perhaps coincidentally. He could be that urbane guy in the new Geico
commercials who asks the rhetorical question, only he shows a stud in his tongue and wears sunglasses.

One of the songs on the page sounded straight from Seventies Brit glam, Alvin Stardust rather than
Ziggy, but decent. The horn charts in it were key. The other two had an indie minstrel cabaret thing going, but US in flavor which messes up the Euro Bowie Brian Ferry thing it seems to be aiming for.

Gorge, Monday, 18 January 2010 17:08 (fourteen years ago) link

my brother used to play this a lot when we were kids:

http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_kkCHUk87bYc/SLviIBfOy7I/AAAAAAAAJeA/13DKaDJaZxc/s400/Whitesnake+-+Live+in+the+Heart+of+the+City+(2007).jpg

scott seward, Monday, 18 January 2010 18:37 (fourteen years ago) link

not long ago i visited my brother and he gave me his original copy of this which rules and i was very happy to hear it again:

http://www.metalkingdom.net/album/img/d40/1589.jpg

scott seward, Monday, 18 January 2010 18:40 (fourteen years ago) link

just thought of it cuz its another example of pre-mtv-big-hit-80's version of longstanding band.

scott seward, Monday, 18 January 2010 18:42 (fourteen years ago) link

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/a/af/Whitesnake-liveathammersmith1.jpg/200px-Whitesnake-liveathammersmith1.jpg

This is the alb I was referring to. Functionally identical to Live..Inna Heart of the City.

Thumping extended blooz rock punctuated with gails of howling. "Been mistreated!" for the fifth or sixth time on record. Cue Stormbringer next.

Gorge, Monday, 18 January 2010 18:45 (fourteen years ago) link

That Whitesnake Live...In The Heart Of The City album was reissued in 2007 as a two-CD set. Boosted it all the way up to 15 tracks.

neither good nor bad, just a kid like you (unperson), Monday, 18 January 2010 18:47 (fourteen years ago) link

burn and stormbringer are always gonna be my favorite coverdale moments. but i STILL need a copy of come taste the band cuz i'm a tommy bolin fan and i'd probably dig it. never even heard it!

scott seward, Monday, 18 January 2010 18:59 (fourteen years ago) link

Whitesnake Live...In The Heart Of The City

Breakaway Records in Austin had an LP copy of this on sale for $1 a couple months ago. Considered buying it, too. Maybe I should have.

xhuxk, Monday, 18 January 2010 19:02 (fourteen years ago) link

Listening to it now. It's pretty good.

neither good nor bad, just a kid like you (unperson), Monday, 18 January 2010 19:04 (fourteen years ago) link

The update reissue may have the tracks from Live at Hammersmith. I remember the two seeming to come from the same set of performances. So I got out my old copy -- a Japanese deluxe CD with sash and booklet -- and mine has "Come On," "Might Just Take Your Life," "Lie Down," "Ain't No Love In the Heart of the City" , "Trouble," and "Mistreated."

It's very much the thumping blooz rock and party album. Mostly, it has Coverdale sounding most like Paul Rogers. "Ain't No Love In the Heart of the City" actually steals from a Free tune I can't quite put my finger on, "I'll be Creepin'," I think. There's even a Grand Funk-ish quality to some of -- "Might Just Take Your Life" and "Lie Down" with Coverdale doing the cool hard rock soul man vocal ala the kind of things Farner and Don Brewer were fond of. "Trouble" owns a lot of modern country rock, particularly
Jason Aldean. Who I'd bet had Whitesnake imports at some point.

"Mistreated" has Coverdale reverting to his Percy stylings.

It's hard not to smile at this stuff. Coverdale's likably oafish and the band is totally unflash, no Blackmore-isms from the guitarists, just the facts, ma'am.

Gorge, Monday, 18 January 2010 20:16 (fourteen years ago) link

New Disney atrocity in the fake heavy metal band show meme: Iron Weasel.

Couldn't get through more than thirty seconds of two-cased songs, one called Pull My Finger, which one might think would be OK in the hands of someone genuinely crass and not writing for kids TV. But that's not the case here.

You can whip these songs out in 3 minutes tops, I'd think, particularly if you have a library of digital heavy metal riffs and drum lines. Then all you needs is some fool to sing a little although some of that is probably also buyable in bits and pieces now, too.

And here we are bagging on "Here I Go Again" and old Kingdom Come. Sacre bleu.

Gorge, Tuesday, 19 January 2010 00:06 (fourteen years ago) link

One thing about David Coverdale was that he knew the value of getting good musicians in. Steve Vai, Cozy Powell, Neil Murray, Colin "Bomber" Hodgkinson (those last 2 both from a jazz fusion background), etc etc. Although I guess Bernie Marsden and Mickey Moody had to go if they ever wanted to get on MTV. Adrian Vandenberg looked like the kind of guy who'd bring his own wardrobe to the band, unlike Jon Lord.

Ork Alarm (Matt #2), Tuesday, 19 January 2010 00:55 (fourteen years ago) link

Okay, so anybody want to give me a good reason why I shouldn't get rid of my CD of L.A. sleaze-glam revival band Vains Of Jenna's 2006 Lit Up/Let Down, which has mostly been gathering dust around my abode for the past three or four years? Just tried playing it again today -- twice -- and it just really sounds generic. Guess somebody knowing that genre at all seemed refreshing in '06, but really, who cares? Do you?

Here's their myspace, if you need your memory refreshed:

http://www.myspace.com/vainsofjenna

xhuxk, Wednesday, 20 January 2010 00:58 (fourteen years ago) link

They're managed by the guy from Tuff! Other than that, not really.

Agent ov Fortune (J3ff T.), Wednesday, 20 January 2010 01:23 (fourteen years ago) link

Playing The Last Vegas (from Chicago)'s 2004 sleaze-glam Lick 'Em And Leave 'Em (on Get Hip, same label as the Gore Gore Girls) now, and it sounds way better. Rawer, more ominous, kicks more ass when it decides to. The slower grinds remind me what pre-grunge Seattle bands like Green River were doing with half-remembered Aerosmith "Seasons Of Wither" riffs in the mid '80s (and the blurry hairy CD cover photo with eyes hiding behind sunglasses suggests that may be what Last Vegas had in mind), only with more mid '80s L.A. hairspray. Last Vegas got more slicked up and half-coherent on last year's Whatever Gets You Off, which came out on Nikki Sixx's label Eleven Seven and which I overrated for a few months before they were gonna tour with Crue (still think it's not bad), but the debut sounds grimier and rocks me more when it speeds up, e.g. in "One To Go" and "Hit The Bricks." Honestly figured I'd gotten rid of it; glad I found it in a box in the closet.

xhuxk, Wednesday, 20 January 2010 01:49 (fourteen years ago) link

Also, that debut admittedly does sound recorded at the bottom of a slopbucket, which usually makes me push reject these days (and I'm not claiming you can hear the songs that well to be honest.) But it reminds me why I used to think that kind of schtick was cool, once upon a time.

xhuxk, Wednesday, 20 January 2010 02:23 (fourteen years ago) link

I just got the re-release of the Armegeddon album with Keith Relf, Bobby Caldwell etc. A lot of the same "motifs" from Captain Beyond pop up here, which leads me to believe Caldwell was the true leader of both bands. Plus, the motherfucker was a genius drummer, just amazing. I dont know which record gets the nod from me, the CB debut or this. I think he had better players around him in Armageddon, but Captain Beyond is just so weird (in a good way). This is certainly heavier, and "Silver Tightrope" is a pretty killer ballad. Curious what you guys think.

Bill Magill, Wednesday, 20 January 2010 14:19 (fourteen years ago) link

Scott's raved about that Armageddon album on many an occasion. I think it's pretty good but a bit long-winded. (I too prefer Captain Beyond.)

Race Against Rockism (Myonga Vön Bontee), Wednesday, 20 January 2010 16:55 (fourteen years ago) link

The songs on Armageddon are long, but they dont bore me for some reason.

Bill Magill, Wednesday, 20 January 2010 17:35 (fourteen years ago) link

the first side is perfect, so just play that, myonga!

scott seward, Wednesday, 20 January 2010 18:11 (fourteen years ago) link

oh and i forgot to thank you for the cdr, myonga! thanks!

scott seward, Wednesday, 20 January 2010 18:11 (fourteen years ago) link

and, bill, if you want to pay tribute to bobby, by all means, add kind words to the tribute thread:

Where Is The Love For Bobby Caldwell?? No, Not THAT Bobby Caldwell! Bobby Caldwell of Captain Beyond & Keith Relf's Armageddon & Johnny Winter And & Rick Derringer Fame!!

scott seward, Wednesday, 20 January 2010 18:13 (fourteen years ago) link

Yeah, that thread is fantastic, kind of a "This Is Your Life" vibe.

Bill Magill, Wednesday, 20 January 2010 18:43 (fourteen years ago) link

xxpost - You're welcome, Scott; and sticking to Side One of "Armageddon" is exactly what I do!

Also, can I just say (without fake modesty) that my second remark on that Bobby Caldwell thread is possibly my alltime favourite of my own postings?

Race Against Rockism (Myonga Vön Bontee), Wednesday, 20 January 2010 19:49 (fourteen years ago) link

Interesting that you dont like side 2, the last song is the most "Captain Beyondish" song on it.

I am not Bobby Caldwell.

Bill Magill, Wednesday, 20 January 2010 19:56 (fourteen years ago) link

Re xhuxk's thing in the Voice, excerpted. A bit off topic but this is my territory, the demographics of which have something to do with which he speaks:

The indie domination at the top of the album list is a harder nut to crack, but a few factors seem worth pondering. For one thing, the poll's electorate has changed—freelance dollars aren't flowing like the old days, and with dailies and weeklies chopping arts positions, newsprint dinosaurs have departed the vocation, voluntarily and involuntarily, in droves. Meanwhile, way younger bloggers and Tweeters who make even less money reviewing music have stepped in. Some vote, and plenty see eye-to-eye with Pitchfork ... But when it's mainly the old farts who seem to have minds of their own, I start to wonder.

Actually, saw this coming years ago. Krugman, with reference to the economy, calls it looking for people who aren't part of the Borg collective.

I dropped out of the Poll two or three years ago, no longer keep track. Didn't look at the list this year except for your essay which was noted elsewhere and which caught my eye.

When McD presented his statistical analyses of critic non-congruence, I was always in the bottom five, reliably the total outlier. But there were others, I don't recall them all, but I'd reckon there's been a certain amount of loss for the same reasons -- their are some who are no longer interested in what it has to say. And while it was novel to be a statistical anomaly, the thrill of it's purely transient. I don't actually need a regular statistical proof that I've not been susceptible to groupthink.

It may be partly generational and age-related. But part of it is also not wishing to be part of a large stupid club to which your contribution is less than marginal.

After 2006, the Voice scrubbed itself of all the editors I'd worked with. In the space of over half a decade I'd written, at one time or another, something for every section except astrology and sex, including a cover story.

But it simply became too hard to pitch things to a different group with which I have nothing in common. We might as well be living on different planets and while that's not the case, it is part of the larger phenomenon in which stratification and people walling themselves off in their own areas of mutual interest is now the norm, one which is actually made easy to do through digitial communication/niche community. It's just the way things are so there mut be a certain percentage of people who choose not to participate or become invisible for similar reasons, not necessarily related to the Voice, but certainly related to their experience with music journalism and pop pro-rating.

I don't feel it's a duty to make an effort to break through such things anymore. If one were ostensibly running something like P&J, one would theoretically think such a person would be more interested in doing that. But with the numbers still involved, and there's never a shortage of actual digitally-conveyed input, what's the motivation to do so?

One thing I do know from being in cyberspace full-time for a couple decades is that crowds of the like-minded appreciate themselves more when they're less diverse and if you want lots of eyeballs and comments, you pitch to that if you want the best results. Pandering, but it is the most successful formula.

Anyway, while it's stupid to think that more than a couple people who read and regularly post in this thread contribute to P&J now, it's equally stupid to think that those who post here don't listen to anything new outside of hard rock reissues oldies they've dug out of their closets, f'r instance.

Note: Since this has to do with my own private Idaho, don't cut-n-paste it into the P&J discussion.

Gorge, Saturday, 23 January 2010 19:02 (fourteen years ago) link

this is the first year i submitted a ballot since chuck left. my avant/noise/whatever column in decibel mag enabled me to hear all kinds of strange sounds that i dug a lot and i celebrated the best of them. and there were more where they came from. my column has totally reinvigorated me as far as writing about records goes. so, cuzza what i was listening to this year, i ended up in the bottom ten of voters. happy to be there! but not inordinately happy or anything. i wish more people heard the stuff i heard this year. a lot of it was very exciting.

scott seward, Saturday, 23 January 2010 19:12 (fourteen years ago) link

I wound up down at the bottom by submitting an all-Latin ballot, a few of the albums on which probably sold in the hundreds of thousands of copies. Just not in America, and not to the online critical community. Not a lot of Los Tigres del Norte fans at Pitchfork, I bet.

neither good nor bad, just a kid like you (unperson), Saturday, 23 January 2010 19:14 (fourteen years ago) link

Picked up Ten Years After's Roadwork from 2005, a double. It fell on the heels of Now which I thought was a good album sans Alvin Lee and it contains many of the songs from it performed live. They benefit from being played a lot by the time this was put out. Joe Gooch can do all Alvin Lee's parts, so the half of the thing that's classic live TYA is spotless. I'd say "I Can't Keep from Crying Sometimes" which was 14 minutes on the TYA's live one on Epic in the early 70's is still 14 minutes but is souped up by the addition of a medley that goes from the Yardbirds to Deep Purple before sequeing back into the slow jazz blues. "I'm Going Home" is crunching in all the right ways, plus "Hear Me Calling" is included.

Not quite was Foghat Live II was but in the same ballpark. Lots of yobbish soccer cheering from the crowd, so if it's not added on, there's some decent pub fighting audience for 'em in the UK still.

I recall Now, the studio album which came out the same year getting some good notice here. I still have it and crack it out now and then. It was way better than most of Alvin Lee's late stuff with TYA before they laid it to rest.

The Tubes' Mondo Birthmark was studio quality recording -- Wally Heider in SF -- before the debut album. It is, they say, all the stuff producer Al Kooper made a face at with the exceptions of earlier versions of "White Punks on Dope," "Mondo Bondage" and a couple from "Young & Rich". Now it doesn't
seem so outrageous but a spoken word thing about butt fucking set to a Capt. Beefheart disjoint must have seemed so, along with a song about Vietnam vets called "Empy Shoes." Waybill sings his shoes are empty because his legs have been blown off and his baby's left him. Could be ripe for a remake. Send it to Nashville right away.

Nice version of "Telstar" and the first version of "White Punks On Dope" rules just about as much as later versions with the slight diff of having the middle choruses singing "We're white dopes on junk/mom & day live in Hollywood/Hang myself when I get enough rope" rather than the straight title.

Lots of nifty pics and liner notes. This particularly reminds me of how some bands of people who were unreconstructed hippies gravitated to hard rock and elaborate arrangements -- some of this is arranged like the overture from Tommy, only fractured. Coincidentally, I was listening to the Pink Fairies' NeverNeverLand last night and there are similar roots, only the Tubes came from middle class Phoeniz, Arizona and were bigger snobs about being superlative on their instruments, Prairie Prince being one of the original members.

Gorge, Sunday, 24 January 2010 03:07 (fourteen years ago) link

And that was release sometime last year on Fuel. I do recommend it if you're a Tubes fan, at least as far as the live album. Not so much if you like their "Talk to Ya Later" stuff.

Gorge, Sunday, 24 January 2010 03:08 (fourteen years ago) link

So what happened with Wolfmother's Cosmic Egg. In the store yesterday, I noticed a surplus of copies being a bit of evidence of it the band laying a big one.

From four years ago, boiled down from the large enthusiasm from the press:

...The Austin-American Statesman, claims "These Australians play blistering, Afro-rockin' hard rock in the AC/DC tradition" and another, from Associated Press, compares them to the Jimi Hendrix Experience and Cream.

From the UK News of the World, a gig gets one star and the caption line: Dead Zep

The Aussie rockers have changed their line-up in recent years.

Frontman Andrew Stockdale is the only original member left, having sacked his two bandmates between their debut album and laughably-titled new record Cosmic Egg.

It's had little effect on their search for an original idea. That is, if they're even bothering to look.

Why waste time and effort on creativity, when it's much easier to photocopy the riffs, lyrical themes, haircuts, jewellery, trousers and chest hair of Led Zeppelin and their ilk instead?

As this rapturously received gig proves, as long as greasy men still live with their mothers and denim jackets are seen as a viable style choice, there'll always be a market for derivative Guitar Hero knock-offs such as Woman and Vagabond.

Depressing beyond belief.

Fickle, fickle, fickle.

Gorge, Sunday, 24 January 2010 19:11 (fourteen years ago) link

These were coverage of a gig in Manchester and this notice is more favorable:

... This uncertain demeanour seems completely at odds with Wolfmother’s music. To the uninitiated, Wolfmother are about as subtle as a brick in the face. This is not a criticism; the noughties will most definitely not be remembered as a fruitful period for the guitar solo. Instead, this century has been defined by bands that would rather choke on their skinny jeans than ever dream of turning their amplifiers up to eleven. Wolfmother have defiantly stood against this trend. They have succeeded by playing riff-heavy, hard-rocking songs which grab you by the neck and rattle your boots. By virtue of their willful idiosyncrasy, Wolfmother have become unbelievably popular in the UK. How many other bands that released their debut album in 2005 are still packing out venues of this size? Not many is the answer. By embracing a supposedly moribund genre of music, Wolfmother have struck gold. So with all this success, why does Stockdale seem so tense? It’s probably due to the fact that tonight we are watching one of the first shows undertaken by Wolfmother v2.0.

Following the acrimonious departures of founding members Chris Ross and Myles Heskett last year, Stockdale is now the band’s sole surviving original member. Added to the generally unfavourable reviews that greeted Wolfmother’s most recent album, Cosmic Egg, the reason for Stockdale’s apparent nerves become clear: there's a lot riding on this tour. The Academy crowd obviously don’t care for such petty band politics, remaining buoyant throughout the show, roaring their approval for every song the band play. The band's new members don't seem to share Stockdale’s nerves, delivering a flawless, if mildly clinical performance

Musically, Wolfmother are hardly original. Their influences are not so much predictable as achingly obvious; just name any band that once headlined the old Donington Monsters of Rock festival. Wolfmother are no pastiche however, bringing their own 21st century twist to some well-worn riffs. The hard rock genre may be easy to mock, but it’s a damn hard thing to do well. Wolfmother have the talent not only to do it well, but to thrill their audience at the same time. If they manage to continue playing gigs of this scale, Stockdale will have nothing to worry about.

Gorge, Sunday, 24 January 2010 19:15 (fourteen years ago) link

The same thing could be said of blues or country acts.

Why waste time and effort on creativity, when it's much easier to photocopy the riffs, lyrical themes, haircuts, jewellery, trousers and hats of Muddy Waters and his ilk instead?

Why waste time and effort on creativity, when it's much easier to photocopy the riffs, lyrical themes, haircuts, jewellery, trousers and hats of Hank Williams and his ilk instead?

The second Wolfmother album is decent. But I liked the debut.

neither good nor bad, just a kid like you (unperson), Sunday, 24 January 2010 19:16 (fourteen years ago) link

The Runaways movie, early reviews. Hollywood Reporter gives it a good review. Salt Lake
pub emits a few haw-worthy although obvious putdowns in a review that's grudgingly positive. You haveta read the whole thing to get the idea he enjoyed it, working under the idea that anything retro or semi-historical is unworhty in some way because teenagers will not like it for multiple sins associated with being quaint.

http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/hr/film-reviews/the-runaways-film-review-1004061594.story

http://www.saltlakemagazine.com/Blogs/Sundancing/January-2010/Sundance-Film-Review-The-Runaways/

The built-in audience would be: Pervy oldish men who like watching 16-year-olds kick out the jams in their undies. You know, the creepy guy who stares at you a little too long in line for the Port-A-Potties at Coachella. The dudes in the airport 20-years-too-old for that designer T trying to lure bright young things into the Fox Sports bar for a Midori sour. The Generation Which Refuses to Grow Old who collectively careen towards middle age Tweeting and Facebooking their way back to adolescence.

Whereas teens, you know, the ones who buy movie tickets and T-shirts and jewelry from Claire's – can't be bothered with your nostalgia. They don't care. Give 'em sparkly vampires and a gimlet-eyed country-pop star who spits saccharine sweet nothings about boys who go for the cheerleader instead and they'll come charging.

Playing music in a garage? Staying in crappy hotels? Calling from a payphone? Cramming in a sweaty station wagon? Feathering your hair? DIY shirts? Thrift store shopping?

Very quaint mom and dad. But sounds like so much work.

Even as Fanning turns in the most honest portrayal of a teen by a teen since Jennifer Jason Leigh's Stacy in Fast Times and Stewart's Jett, if for a moment, erases the bile of Bella from the viewer conscious collective — the young ones will stay away from The Runaways for the same reason they look at you funny when you blast The Clash while cleaning the house on a Sunday morning.

Gorge, Tuesday, 26 January 2010 20:11 (fourteen years ago) link

The Wrestler suffered from the same -- calling from payphones, staying in crappy places, being in a sweaty van, feathered hair, thrift store shopping.

Gorge, Tuesday, 26 January 2010 20:12 (fourteen years ago) link

More reviews, pinched off WSJ, one of the oddest places to find any interest in such a thing:

[i]“Coming-of-age movies are Sundance’s stock in trade, but few announce themselves as boldly, and broadly, as “The Runaways,” whose first shot is a splotch of menstrual blood hitting the pavement. Said splotch emanates from Cherie Currie (Dakota Fanning), a suburban California teenager with a burgeoning David Bowie obsession and a surly sensuality just beginning to bloom….But in spite of that opening drop, the movie’s evocation of the Runaways’ rise and fall is short on the juices that make for great, trashy, disreputable rock. [Director Floria Sigismondi] crams Fanning into Currie’s famous corset, and stages a passionate kiss between Currie and Jett before compressing their romantic relationship into a single softcore montage, but the movie is too tasteful and glossy to thoroughly embody the Runaways’ quasi-pedophiliac appeal.” [Sam Adams, IFC.com]

“When it gets away from the stage, however, and from the iconography of strutting she-devil-in-lingerie empowerment, The Runaways is just a watchable, rather so-so rock biopic, with the thinly imagined characters and desultory, one-thing-after-another episodic slackness of a TV movie. Granted, there’s a special challenge in bringing this story to life: The Runaways were really just little girls who fed themselves into a giant, buzz-saw machine of image and marketing, all ruled over, of course, by Fowley, the gonzo manager-producer from hell. So they’re really passive vessels in their own story. But The Runaways turns them passive in a different way: They’re made so likable and innocent and quaintly brash that they don’t fully have egos, erotic or otherwise.” [Owen Gleiberman, EW]

“‘The Runaways’ bursts with energy, youth, excess, female empowerment, sex, drugs and rock ‘n’ roll. It’s an instant hit worldwide with its cast of young stars, but is it any good? Surprisingly, yes. It just must be met on its own terms… Maybe the film falls into the category of Guilty Pleasures. The dark ugliness on display — the amazing drug abuse and pre-AIDS hedonism — looks probably too exciting. While the film makes it clear its personalities suffered tremendously for their addictions, it all looks so glam.” [Kirk Honeycutt, Hollywood Reporter]

“The movie’s all about the descent into booze and drugs of lead singer Cherie Curry, played as well as she can (given the awful script) by Dakota Fanning as a frail child who’d rather be singing Peggy Lee and Don MacLean. Short on character (Michael Shannon is amusingly ludicrous as the band’s abusive but image-savvy manager) and long on attitude, The Runaways plays like the sloppily entertaining stretched-out music video it is.” [Ella Taylor, NPR]

“All-girl teenage band ‘The Runaways,’ once regarded as a prefab joke but now lionized as trailblazers, are the subject of Floria Sigismondi’s first feature. Despite the helmer’s multidisciplinary background, this proves a conventionally enjoyable making-and-breaking-of-the-band saga… Though sometimes her usual neurotic tics distract, “Twilight’s” Stewart is a good fit for the tough but good-natured Jett, who carried on as frontwoman after Currie left, then launched a far more successful solo career. In line with many previous roles, Fanning emphasizes Currie’s vulnerability — making her a sexy nice-girl victim — though the bratty, dangerously needy character seen in old clips, discussed by bandmates in “Edgeplay,” and even glimpsed in Currie’s own book, seems more interesting.” [Dennis Harvey, Variety]

Gorge, Wednesday, 27 January 2010 18:32 (fourteen years ago) link

It's my book the Runaways records still don't sell much. I thought the first one was great when I
bought it in 1978 but it was never set to go far. A little less than half of it is fairly clumsy and one of favorite parts of it is "Dead End Justice" which has limited appeal if you don't like a bare parable about bad girls breaking out of juvie and one of 'em going down on the jailbreak. "Cherry Bomb," "American Nights," "You Drive Me Wild" and "Is It Day or Night" are the other good ones. They work off good riffs and they're so underproduced with big guitar they have a brutality that wasn't on a lot of hard rock records that year, boys vs. girls being irrelevant.

However, the subsequent records were mediocre to turdly except for the live album recorded after they broke up and never released in this country. Done in Japan, where they -- like Cheap Trick -- were
drawing big screaming audiences of children (but everyone did, I think, UFO I was big in Japan), it was substantially stepped on back in the studio. So it sounds really good, the cover is now great dirty old man stuff (it wasn't in -- what '80?) and it fills out to a record of their best material. One can like it as much, maybe more, than the debut.

So why would someone at NPR like anything about The Runaways movie? Any assertions that such a person would like the music or even the Runaways have to be frank lies because the records were never popular and certainly not with the class that pays attention to things like NPR.

And to say the movie bursts with 'female empowerment,' ala the Hollywood Reporter is unusual. The Runaways did not do empowerment on their first album, they did raw rock 'n' roll and their pictures didn't look so hot, even though they were supposed to. And Cherie Curie's biography was not empowering. I had a copy, reviewed it for the newspaper. It was a horror story -- mostly -- with no happy ending and it would have needed, and probably received, something of a face lift for a movie.

I think empowerment came along around the time Joan Jett hit all over the world with "I Love Rock 'n' Roll."

Anyway you slice it, this bit on YouTube from Japan is not empowering. It is a spectacle and the more one watches it the more embarrassing and sweat-inducing it becomes. It was thought to be a good Kim Folwey idea at the time. There certainly had to have been a better way to do things, somewhere much better than Fanny but not quite like this.

http://www.youtube.com/results?search_type=&search_query=Cherie+Currie+Runaways+Cherry+Bomb

Gorge, Wednesday, 27 January 2010 18:54 (fourteen years ago) link

they will be immortal if only for cherry bomb alone. as far as npr goes, 70's nostalgia always goes far there. or anywhere. i doubt this movie will be anywhere near as good as the immortal Foxes.

scott seward, Wednesday, 27 January 2010 19:06 (fourteen years ago) link

come to think of it, the Foxes soundtrack probably beats most things too. moroder and angel! and bob seger and , um, janis ian! and boston! and donna summer!

scott seward, Wednesday, 27 January 2010 19:10 (fourteen years ago) link

glossy to thoroughly embody the Runaways’ quasi-pedophiliac appeal

Their small audience, what there was of it from being in Circus and Crawdaddy, was not obviously afflicted with pedophilia. I'd bet that Dave Marsh's style would have been to tell you the Runaways were for pedophiles, though.

I think pedophiles had their own special mags and the Runaways weren't in them?

I was actually interested in seeing the movie but I may now have to tell everyone I didn't and go in a pulled-down hat and black macintosh.

As for Foxes, yeah Skot, the same thing occured to me. The Runaways without the music and Scott Baio as someone the problem of being to young-looking to get any action.

Gorge, Wednesday, 27 January 2010 19:12 (fourteen years ago) link

I've always assumed the Runaways' audience was mostly teenagers, more or less the same age as the Runaways. (Lita Ford born '59; Joan Jett born '60, just like me. Though to be honest my main exposure to them at the time was probably watching the forgotten late '70s TV celebrity fake-sports/obstacle-course competition Almost Anything Goes. I swear I saw them on there once, though when I was hunting around the Internet for evidence of their appearance a couple weeks ago, I found nothing. Could barely find anything about the show itself, actually.)

Did "Cherry Bomb" actually get any rock radio play at the time? Sure don't remember hearing it in Detroit; I'd figure it would have been considered way too punk rock in 1976. Debut album only reached #194 in Billboard; '77 followup, Queens Of Noise, only got to #172.

xhuxk, Wednesday, 27 January 2010 19:48 (fourteen years ago) link

The Joan Jett wikipedia page says 9-22-58, a month or so after mine. (Madonna anticipates me by 10 days; Michael Jackson trails me by three.) Anyway, I do remember hearing Cherry Bomb on the radio then, but it didn't get heavy play. I guess that would have been WPLJ or more likely WNEW. Saw them as a late teen, in their post-Cherie days, wedged between Suicide & the Ramones. I probably knew about them more from their press than their radio play. Hmm, now I wonder who was in that Joan-led version of the band.

Thus Sang Freud, Wednesday, 27 January 2010 21:03 (fourteen years ago) link

Hmmm.. I didn't check Wiki; Joel Whitburn has 9-22-60 in Philadelphia. But maybe she's older than she used to be!

xhuxk, Wednesday, 27 January 2010 21:06 (fourteen years ago) link

Did "Cherry Bomb" actually get any rock radio play at the time?

I think Cherry Bomb might have actually had more play a few years later when JJ re-recorded it for Glorious Results of... album.

Late period Runaways was probably Joan Jett, Sandy West, Lita Ford and rotating bass players, either Vickie Blue or Laurie McAllister, not that it mattered much.

There was an old poster that hung in one of the record stores in Pasadena, maybe from the Roxy, advertising a bill of the Runaways and Van Halen. Probably dated from around '78.

Gorge, Wednesday, 27 January 2010 22:32 (fourteen years ago) link


You must be logged in to post. Please either login here, or if you are not registered, you may register here.