Indie kids hate emo kids, right?

this is the parallel universe jay-z vs. nas throwdown thread.

who here can name at least 5 punk rock bands and 3 heavy metal.
and if you can i will believe most of you know what your talking about!

P.S. the unseen rule!

What happened to this thread being about emo? And I don't really see U2 as being emo. I can see some resemblence in a lot of songs, but for the most part I don't see them as fitting. They do sound like Sunny Day Real Estate though, who are pretty much the definition of emo.

THIS IS STUPID, JUST ENJOY WHAT YOU ENJOY< MUSIC IS MUSIC. WHAEVER.

IF YOU HAVE NO LOVE IN YOUR HEART, EVEN THE MUSIC OF THE SPHERES WILL SOUND LIKE THE BOILING CAULDRONS OF HELL--RUMI

alright listen mister you can go saying music is music and whatever but guess what it is not! there will always be some type of hate and the cartoon Celebrity Death Match will always make of it! So unless you going to argue dont even bother to talk!
the unseen rule!

5 Punk Rock Bands:

The Art Attacks
The Child Molestors
The Undertones
The Saints
The Urinals

3 Heavy Metal Bands:
Napalm Death
Old Lady Drivers
Pat Boone

5 Punk Rock Bands
Avril Lavigne
NOFX
Good Charlotte
Fefe Dobson
The Atari's

3 Heavy Metal Bands
Thrice
The Used
Story of the Year

5 Punk Rock Bands
Captain Beefheart
Mekons
UFO or Die
Violent Ramp
Forcefield

3 Heavy Metal Bands
Yngwie Malmsteen
Ruins
The Fucking Champs

5 Punk Rock Bands

Moss Icon
Cap'n Jazz
Antioch Arrow
Jimmy Eats World
U2

3 Heavy Metal Bands

Rites of Spring
Embrace
Hated

Ok, so you win so far, funny stuff. I am just baiting the kids in hopes that they will keep posting because this thread is somehow entertaining to me. Which makes me sad. Until I read the thread again.

5 Punk Rock Bands

Merle Haggard
Interpol
Devin the Dude
Van Halen
Balloon Guy

5 Heavy Metal Bands
Afghan Whigs
US Maple
Geto Boys

(this was pointless, I just want to keep bumping this fantasically entertaining thread, which I read for the first time today)

alright here is your list.

5 punk rock bands
the unseen
The virus
The sex pistols
U.S. Bombs
The Adicts

and 3 heavy metal band
Metallica
Black Sabbath
Ac Dc

Robert, do you shop at hot topic?

Is Hot Topic emo?

It's whatever they want to sell to you.

If it sold whatever I'd want to buy from them then I'd check it out.

As it is I managed to never enter the store once in my adolescence though I am aware of why some (indie kids?) are so derisive of it.

black flag
heroin
buzzcocks
minor threat
bad brains

sleep
vincebus eruptum
emperor

Well i have been i hot topic once. but i didnt buy anything. being in there scares me because some kids are a little freaky. they look like a huge mass a black hair and make up. i dont dress that way.

i dont think there is an "emo" store it is just what they sell, most stores sell a variety.

Robert, how old are you?

i m 13

SO SHUT THE FUCK UP

Oh, don't listen to him. Continue on, I enjoy your insights.

There is no emo store. And if there were no emo would go there. The true emo stores are salvation army and thrift stores. Hot Topic are for punks. Its alrigh but not for emos. And yeah Robert, this is your first year in JR HIGH. You know more then the usual 7th grader, but you dont know much. You dont even know why you hate emo. The best answer ive got from you was "its just stupid." So enjoy what you enjoy, but dont slam emo when you only know the basics of it.

and by the way chrishamrin, please, please, please tell me you were joking on your top 5/3 list.

Dillon, how old are you?

Dan Selzer, how are you old?

I just turned 29! If you want to send me a birthday gift, you can via my amazon wish list.

Dan Selzer, happy birthday, I would buy you a gift, but I am poor. Instead I will buy many of your fine CD offerings at a later date when I am no longer poor. Also, completely off topic, but do you send stuff out to college radio? (I think so) I tried to email someone about this once, but the email didn't work. (I want to spread the love of music!)

and by the way chrishamrin, please, please, please tell me you were joking on your top 5/3 list.

I am no longer capable of humor since the accident...

There is no emo store. And if there were no emo would go there.

Wish I did, but I don't really undersand you kids these days and your music which all sounds like noise to me and your strange ways of dressing and patterns of speech. Do kids really call people, "emos"? I mean, I really hope so.

yes, we do college radio mailings, I let my partner Todd handle such things. send me your details (what college, are you the MD? who is the MD, etc) and I'll forward it to Todd.

btw, my older sister was a Wire fan, so when they had their mid to late 80s media blitz, I remember it well, I remember her taping an episode of a talk show hosted or guest-hosted by Suzanne Summers! Seeing her smile and say "and now, Wire!" was just great. This clip is also on the Wire 154 bootleg DVD.

Emo, punk, indie, rock, country, what ever it's all good to someone out there...I dont know why people get so carried away about something stupid like this. Anyways, nice to see a few good bands being listed on here.

alright i think we are getting off subject.mainly at least, this is about emo. Dillon is 15 so stop asking ages please. (he sits next to me in class) thats how i know. i was looking at a site and it said that emo was punk played louder faster and with emotional lyrics. what a load of crap the emotional part is right though. emo will never be as fast or loud as punk.

-Robert
The Unseen Rule!

Robert, have you ever heard MOHINDER?

No, who are they enlighten me.

Dillon you have some bad taste in music. i dont understand why people like "emo". its just bad punk rock.(emo will never be better than punk) so get over it Dillon you will never get any where in the world with that music. who wants to hire a emo kid to work at a store thing. our school wouldnt even hire you. to get any where in the world you going to have to listen to something better, like punk or heavy metal. and ever notice there is like no emo girls. man youll never get a date. trust me.

i was looking at a site and it said that emo was punk played louder faster and with emotional lyrics. what a load of crap the emotional part is right though. emo will never be as fast or loud as punk.

That was from Roberts post. Listen, playing music louder and faster isnt a contest. It just is. What you dont realize is that most emo isnt even close to the sappy acoustic guitars that mtv tells the world emo is. If you call Rites of Spring or Fugazi or even as modern as Dead Poetic sappy and slow, theyd slit their wrists. If you go to their concert, they are just everywhere. Screaming into the mics, destroying their own equipment, just everywhere. Have you ever heard of Warped Tour? They just thrash out their vocal chords to the point you cant understand what they say. Obviously punk does the same, but emo is a sub-genre of punk. Whether you want to admit it or not.

emo is not a sub genre of punk. it is in a league of its own like marilyn mansen.

these bands consisted mostly of people who played in hardcore punk bands, got burned out its limited forms, and moved to a guitar-oriented, midtempo rock-based sound with emotional punk vocals
-fourfa.com

"As for emo today, as most other sub-genres, it has spawned many(sometimes extremely opposite and/or contradicting) hybrids that all stake claim to the label, rendering it somewhat useless. Here are some examples: there's political, scream-and-flail-on-the-floor, emo like Frail, Swing Kids, Impetus Inter, and a slew of San Diego based bands; there's the really slow, discordant, artsy emo like Cap'n Jazz, Joan d'Arc, Evergreen, etc.; then we have the more popular melody/pop-oriented bands like Texas is the Reason, Sensefield, Mineral, Promise Ring, Split Lip (now Chamberlain), etc.; and last but not least we have the slow, stop-and-go, melody-thrash alternating groups like Amber Inn, Still Life, and others I can't think of right now."
-www.faqs.org/faqs/cultures/straight-edge-faq/section-64.html

The short and simple answer is that Emo is Hardcore Punk music with sensitive and emotional lyrics.
-altmusic.about.com/library/weekly/aabyb_emo.htm

Have I proved myself yet?

No you have not proven yourself. this is just trash. emo is just emotional, stupid, and they are posers.

have i made my self clear eunich boy!

Wouldn't anyone purporting to be a punk after like... say 1982... be a poseur?

Here are links to classic "emo" bands that melt the faces of 95% of "punk" out there:

http://www.epitonic.com/artists/drivelikejehu.html
http://www.epitonic.com/artists/mohinder.html
http://www.epitonic.com/artists/antiocharrow.html
http://www.epitonic.com/artists/speedking.html

Also, you can listen at those links.

Indie is just a place for fat kids who want ot be emo to fit in, and they hat all the emos becasue they are smaller.... Anyway, punk is not dead and it will never die becasue Punk is more than just a type of music, it's an state of mind , and a way of life .... But there are millions of true punk bands still out there, they are just underground, so no ... Like Nazi Punks ..... if there music died do you think there would be no more nazi skinheads/ punks ? I am not sure if that is what you like trying to say (that punk is dead, becasue the music is dead ::which it's not::) but whatever .

And just to point out somtihng there are some great emo bands out there, like Alkaline Trio, which many be the only good emo band, but there are atleast three good emo bands out of the millions

All the emo band that were good created they own type of music ((screamo)) becasue they did not want to be called a emo band .... becasue well must of it is just a way for boys who like rock to make a pop band that they want to pass as rock band

SO those emo bands that sound like hardcore bands are called screamo bands ..... they would never want to be called emo bands, what person with a working mind want to be a emo band ?

Kenny, how old are you?

15

You know a lot about music for someone so young!

Hey lol It's like the only tihng I actually study

What are your favorite current punk bands? classic punk bands?

Current Punk Bands: NoFX, Bad Religion, Anti-Flag, Against All Authority, The Distillers, The Unseen, No Authority, Authority Zero, Social Distortion, Decendents, A Global Threat, Subhumans, Death by Stereo Error , Tiger Army, Guttermouth, Transplants . and a whole bunch of underground and local bands ::Knockout Monkeys::

Classic Punk Bands: Minor Threat, Operation Ivy, MDC, THe Clash, The Virus, Fear, Circle Jerks , The Misfits , Black Flag , Dead Kennedys , Crass, The Exploited , and the rest of them