does tom petty have any redeeming qualities?

Another one for the ILM FAQ.

THANK YOU. May I add that Men at Work are also better than LED ZEPPLIN and BOSTON combined. (n.1)

_______________________________
(n.1) Actually, I was kidding in this and the original post. I do like Men at Work, tho.

the original question could have been answered with a quick "no". i love the extrapolation but other threads deserve it more.

Lock thread.

Seconded

yeah let's get extrapolating on the 700 poll threads about terrorizer poll results

agreed

i do like a lot of his songs but by no means does he warrant this much discussion, positive or negative.

xp!

i love the extrapolation complaints that something isn't worth discussing, but other threads deserve it more.

It's fun to talk about Tom Petty, I think Michael Ian Black forgot to.

haha ok well ... bryan adams sounds like a canadian ... guy ... who wanted ... to get laid ...

B-b-but he fucked Princss Diana!

...or Princess Diana as she's more commonly known.

Carlene Carter album pretty good.

It's not bad. But the best song on it is one she first recorded 28 years ago, for whatever that's worth.

We talking about the same album, I Fell In Love?

that colin hay song is pretty good! it's at least as good as iron and wine and stuff like that that's big in indie circles

that colin hay song is pretty good! it's at least as good as iron and wine and stuff like that that's big in indie circles

Hey hey hey hey, easy there.

We talking about the same album, I Fell In Love?

I guess not! I'm talking about Stronger, out March 4 on Yep Roc.

Princss Diana has such great style sheets.

HAD *pow*

But hey James, this is about the Carlene Carter album you got -- from the rolling country 2006 thread (parts of which also ended up on a Cock Robin thread yesterday, coincidentally enough):

carlene carter *i fell in love* 1990 $2.99 (title track sounds familiar, so i guess maybe it was a hit? it also sounds like a nick lowe song, though he apparently didn't write it)
-- xhuxk, Saturday, March 25, 2006 11:04 PM (1 year ago) Bookmark Link

I think Carlene's "I Fell In Love" was written by Al Anderson, ex-NRBQ; at least, he and she were having a rave-up with it, when I saw 'em on Austin City Limits (so astonished I forgot to hit "Record"). He's written a lot of other good songs too.
-- don, Sunday, March 26, 2006 9:21 PM (1 year ago) Bookmark Link

actual songwriting credit is: Carlene Carter/Howie Epstein/Benmont Tench/Perry Lamek. ("The Sweetest Thing" on that album gives partical credit to Robert Ellis Orrall, who I've brought up a couple times on this thread. And more interestingly, "The Leavin' Side" gives partial credit to one Tom Gray: I wonder if that's the same guy who used to lead the Brains, of "Money Changes Everything" fame! They were Southerners, from Atlanta, right? So it wouldn't have been out of the question for him to go the country songwriting route.)
-- xhuxk, Sunday, March 26, 2006 10:44 PM (1 year ago) Bookmark Link

The Carlene Carter album I bought seems consisently kinda fun but never quite fun *enough*, at least so far. Maybe I wish her poppabilly was more rockabilly, "The Sweetest Thing" is slow, and could amost be a Lorrie Morgan hit from around that time; "Goodnight Dallas," which I like more than most of the tracks, has mariachi horns and yodels, so it's "western" I guess. I'm still waiting for at least one track though to jump out at me. --
xhuxk, Sunday, April 9, 2006 3:27 PM (1 year ago) Bookmark Link

and "lonely nights." he had his moments

OTM I haven't heard this song in probably 20 years but iirc it is played entirely in the key of win.

What's up with hating Tom Petty?

Like Christgau seems to think he's like the worst human ever.

yes. God, just have a beer and try to get head like everybody else

(I have a living room's worth of ladies, chatting and I'm a not terribly *yawn* inclined to engage in anything resembling civilized banter.)

Still, you got the word order rearrangement thing going.

i think xgau suspects petty of reactionary tendencies. which is fair enough. he needs to be understood in the context of southern rock as much as california rock.

but petty was a lot more tuned in than i think people give him credit for. the whole "new wave" thing, he wasn't new wave but he had a kind of new wave energy. he loved mtv. he hooked up with dave stewart. he was kind of a fellow traveler. and he was chiming guitars a few years before r.e.m. and the edge and so forth. he really fits into that era.

plus grace jones covered him. should count for something.

"Damn The Torpedoes" is smack full of great tunes, and "Into The Great Wide Open" isn't far behind (plus it has excellent production work by Jeff Lynne in addition).

, he wasn't new wave but he had a kind of new wave energy

Well, on those first couple albums, he sounded totally powerpop -- a lot closer to the Records or Nick Lowe or Bram Tchaicovksy than to the Eagles or Molly Hatchet or Jackson Browne. (One thing that seemed to bug Christgau early on is that, in live shows, Petty acted less new wave than on record: "Onstage, he acts like he wants to be Ted Nugent when he grows up, pulling out the cornball arena-rock moves as if they had something to do with the kind of music he makes." Which I'm guessing actually made his live shows less boring -- in the same review, Xgau says what made bands like the Byrds great "was that they just got up there and played," which may or may not be true, and sounds like a snooze either way -- but we all have our preferences, I guess.)

^^^ This. That's why Tom Petty's early stuff (e.g., "You Got Lucky") kills his later stuff (which, to me, is listless, by-the-numbers nu-classic rock).

[And I bet if you read a Creem review of his stuff around that time, they'd be more likely to mention him in relation to, say, Dwight Twilley than either California rock or Southern rock. So in 1978 he wasn't exactly new wave, but he was for sure on the borderline of it -- like Cheap Trick, or the Cars.]

The fact that he (allegedly) lip-synced his Super Bowl performance makes me love him more:

http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/ent/stories/DN-petty_0204gl.ART.State.Edition2.4531d76.html

The Cars weren't New Wave?

(xp)

The fact that he (allegedly) lip-synced his Super Bowl performance makes me love him more

it would explain the sound quality being so much better than, say, the stones.

(see, lip-syncing is very new wave.)

The Cars weren't New Wave?

In retrospect it seems like they obviously were, but in 1978 (at least in Detroit) they were pulling in too many mainstream rock REO/Styx/Frampton fans (like my older brother, who also bought Cheap Trick) to seem completely new wave. (From Xgau's 1978 Pazz & Jop essay: "most music bizzers are relieved that the Sex Pistols have vanished into infamy; they still find the Clash strident and the Ramones simplistic, declaring such bands unacceptable to the imaginary consumer who personifies their own complacency and cowardice. But because it's the nature of complacent cowards to hedge all bets--and because they want to prove they're not, you know, square--they reassert their own putative attachment to 'good' rock and roll at the same time, thus easing the sales breakthrough of 'twixt-wave-and-stream bands like the Cars and Cheap Trick. " Earlier in the essay, he counts up the number of new wave finishers in the top 30, and says the Cars and Cheap Trick [and Eno] don't count. Also says "the Cars may share a producer with Queen, but they share a&r, not to mention key musical ideas, with Television and the Dictators." Though I'm not sure what musical ideas he thinks they specifically shared with those two.)

he Cars may share a producer with Queen, but they share a&r, not to mention key musical ideas, with Television and the Dictators.

Heh - I'd have reversed these two clauses.

I think Richard Lloyd was quoted in Please Kill Me about hearing an advance tape of the first Cars album during the sessions for Adventure and he told Verlaine that it was over for Television because Elektra had found a group that souded like them but with radio-friendly songs.

The Cars = Geir Television.

Most Tom Petty fans are unaware that the original title of his smash hit 'Don't Do Me Like That' was originally 'Don't Screw Me In Scat', a bawdy tale about Petty's experiences in Tiajuana. When record execs balked, he re-recorded the song as "Don't Jew Me Like That". However MCA's chief audio engineer, Hymie Goldberg, merely dubbed over the word Jew and the song was released in the form we now know it.

Thank you.

he re-recorded the song as "Don't Jew Me Like That". However MCA's chief audio engineer, Hymie Goldberg, merely dubbed over the word Jew and the song was released in the form we now know it.

Joking, right? I've never heard this. No mention of it on the all-knowing internet, either.

this thread at first seems pretty annoying and full of silly challops but after reading it more closely i'm finding it quite entertaining.

while we're here, let's talk about long after dark.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/1/19/PettyLongAfterDark.jpg

the most overlooked tom petty record, imo. great singles -- "you got lucky," "change of heart," "straight into darkness," "we stand a chance" -- and some of my favorite petty album tracks: "finding out," "the same old you," "deliver me."

"Straight Into Darkness" is terrific.

I got up the (underrated?) Let Me Up (I've Had Enough) for a buck a couple of months ago. It's worthwhile as the back-to-basics album Petty never recorded in the seventies; call it a post-reactionary reactionary album. "Jammin' Me" has always been one of my favorite singles, inexplicably omitted from the original greatest, and there's a couple of other numbers ("Runaway Trains") where he doesn't yowl so much.

anyone heard "Waiting For Tonight," with absolutely killer harmonies by The Bangles? Wonderful song.

let me up has some nice songs. i love "runaway trains." "it'll all work out" is pretty, "think about me" is good. "ain't love strange."

xpost: yeah, that bangles song is on the petty box set (which i found for like $20 a few years ago -- six discs!). it's a good tune.

Oh, come on. He's about as mainstream as my taste goes, but he's a swell fellow, a very consistent artist and his catalog is full of unexpected surprises. "Here Comes My Girl" is a perfect example of exactly the sort of heartbreakingly perfect song that Chrissie Hynde might have written for the first Pretenders album - check it out. And for more than 25 years, he's engaged in anti-price-gouging battles with his label over high list prices and whatnot. He's made a record with his pre-Heartbreakers band thirty years later to help his old buddies out for giving him his start. Roger McGuinn said when he heard "American Girl" he assumed it was one of his old classics he'd forgotten about and was crushed to learn it wasn't his song at all, but a deliberate McGuinn tribute by Petty. A fine fellow.

Good race car driver.

tipsy mothra and alfred completely otm re: long after dark and let me up and especially re: runaway trains. jeez lord I love that song.