The Hissing of Summer Lawns: a poll

I think Joni's influence is more cosmic bop -- Monk and obv. Mingus -- but Dan is pretty plainly influenced by big band and bop, the 33.3 about them breaks down a lot of their chord stuff - there aren't a lot of pop songs doing stuff like the title track from Aja or the breakdown in "I Got the News," or any of their tremendous horn arrangments

― Now I Am Become Dracula (underrated aerosmith bootlegs I have owned), Saturday, May 31, 2014 7:32 PM Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

Totally, or the chord progression at the beginning of "Deacon Blues" -- it could be the intro to a hard bop tune. Not to mention that the verses sit on 13th chords, or that the chorus sounds like a bossa nova jazz progression. I mean how often do they play a chord that doesn't at least have a 7th in it, let alone a 9th, 11th, 13th, etc.

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

I mean how often do they play a chord that doesn't at least have a 7th in it, let alone a 9th, 11th, 13th, etc.

my dad plays jazz piano and has straight up told me "always play the 7 or the maj7." straight chords just do not exist for him

Some old jazzers call straight maj/min chords "cowboy chords."

Title track, for so perfectly a lazy, faintly sinister summer's day in 70s LA, but The Jungle Line is obviously incredible too.

And I fell in love with Shades of Scarlet after the ILX Joni poll. The lyrics!

not a fan of this artist, but played this yeasterday and wd have to go w/ The Boho Dance.

Heatwaves on the runway
As the wheels set down
He takes his baggage off the carousel
He takes a taxi into town
Yellow schools of taxi fishes
Jonah in a ticking whale
Caught up at the light in the fishnet windows
Of Bloomingdale's
Watching those high fashion girls
Skinny black models with raven curls
Beauty parlor blondes with credit card eyes
Looking for the chic and the fancy to buy

He opens up his suitcase
In the continental suite
And people thirty stories down
Colored currents in the street
A helicopter lands on the Pan Am roof
Like a dragonfly on a tomb
And business men in button downs
Press into conference rooms
Battalions of paper-minded males
Talking commodities and sales
While at home their paper wives and paper kids
Paper the walls to keep their gut reactions hid

i could've easily voted for any of the first six songs, they're all of them As. probably then i would've voted for sorrow. but i voted for harry. such captivating imagery. amazing.

took me foreverrr to get into this record, in comparison both court and spark and hejira seem open and intelligible, less clustered and walled away. but now i love it, its vibe is so specific, all these deep, ever-shifting character studies, the song structured as dimensionally as the lyrics. this was between "scarlett" and "boho," and i went with "boho" almost arbitrarily

like a priest with a pornographic watch
looking and longing on the sly

it always annoyed me that Bjork covered that song because she seems like pretty much the opposite of its narrator

There can hardly be a better lyric than:

His eyes hold Edith's
His left hand holds his right
What does that hand desire
That he grips it so tight?

A: a wank

synth tone on "shadows and light" so evil

the band sounds like typewriters....disco, maybe?

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

That's interesting...

the big poll arrives

From what I've heard, in France they...

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/c/c8/Charles_Marville%2C_Urinoir_en_fonte_%C3%A0_2_stalles_avec_%C3%A9cran%2C_Chauss%C3%A9e_de_la_Muette%2C_ca._1865.jpg/352px-Charles_Marville%2C_Urinoir_en_fonte_%C3%A0_2_stalles_avec_%C3%A9cran%2C_Chauss%C3%A9e_de_la_Muette%2C_ca._1865.jpg

urine real trouble for that one.

god this album is such a masterpiece

i have been like living and breathing these songs day and night for months

i love everything here very much but especially that run from "edith" through "boho dance", it is just astonishing

Jungle Line is incredible. Totally out there. What I especially like about Joni is she manages to be 'jazz' without shoving in a load of skronking brass or even that much traditional jazz instrumentation, but it's still jazz in spirit.

kind of been wanting to do a thread of Jungle Line vs Bowie's African Night Flight but not really sure how it would work, or even if there are other songs that could be wedged into a similar category.

well joni's "dreamland" would fit!

but yea jungle line, even if i prefer other tunes on the album, is so out there, such a forward-thinking piece of music, always felt like bjork really took that tune to heart and internalized it

oh i didn't know she'd done a version. yeah it's one of those tracks from the past that you could define a whole career by in that respect. we've got a thread for that somewhere, haven't we?

oh sorry i didn't mean she did a version! just that as soon as i heard it for the first time i thought "bjork must have listened to this a thousand times"

and she mentioned it in an interview recently

Pitchfork: Hejira is one the most feminist albums ever.

B: Right? The lyrics! And The Hissing of Summer Lawns as well. I love “The Jungle Line”, it sounds like something somebody would make now, it’s crazy. Maybe it’s because it’s not my generation, but when I hear the folk stuff that she did before that, I hear it as a lot of people and not just her. It’s a zeitgeist.

xp yeah it's that slippy vocal style that only just syncopates over the beat, which btw is totally irregular. can't work out what time signature it's in

bjork did sing "the boho dance" on the herbie hancock joni tribute several years ago

oh wait it was a different tribute album, not the herbie one

the one with Prince doing "A Case of You."

jungle line is in 4/4

What sort of doll's house would have a replica of HOSL in it?

Oddly fitting, in a way.

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/MINIATURE-ALBUM-VINYL-LP-1-12-Dolls-House-JONI-MITCHELL-Hissing-of-Summer-/301592222223?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_3&hash=item46384c1a0f

i think this is actually my favorite joni record

she covers her eyes in the x-rated scenes

every song is so perfectly constructed. like the last minute or so of "shades of scarlett conquering" my god

i think this is actually my favorite joni record

― flamenco drop (BradNelson), Saturday, March 31, 2018 9

you're darn right!

I'm pretty sure Hejira is ur fav Joni record...

Edith is correct as poll-winner, surprised to see seven votes for The Jungle Line, removing that song would make the album better in my challenging opinion

this or court and spark is my favorite Joni record

I love how playful that Moog line is, though.

niels, i agree with you, i can't listen to the jungle line, but the rest of the album is totally classic. i would've voted for "in france," just for the joyousness of the "do you wanna dance" refrain

Reading back over the earlier parts of the thread and it's interesting to see the speculation that Steely Dan inspired Joni to turn to jazz.

I feel like Hissing is the culmination of the approach she started cultivating with For The Roses (and the two records feel very related to me) - if anything a lot of the vocal cadences and song structures of For The Roses feel even more jazz-laced to me, but she doesn't yet have the band to support her direction so it's mostly just built around these ruminative piano pieces or complex guitar phrases. Incidentally FTR was released the same month as Can't Buy A Thrill.

Whereas on Hissing that same approach really flowers with these arrangements that are drenched in ambiguity and wondering. Edith, Shades, the title track and Harry's House in particular are such remarkably beautiful and passionate tracks given they're ultimately third person character sketches in which judgment is either suspended or heavily convoluted.

I think she was certainly aware of Steely Dan and they may well have had some influence, but to say that she was this folkie who heard Steely Dan and went jazz-pop seems like a bit of an ill-informed stretch and may in fact be the opposite of how things worked.

She made For the Roses with Tom Scott among other session players before the first Steely Dan record came out, and while that and the second album may have played a role in pushing her in more of a jazz-pop direction on Court and Spark, that record came out before the Dan went more explicitly jazz-inflected on Pretzel Logic, and its direction was likely simply a consequence of bringing on Scott's band, the LA Express, which had released their debut album within the prior year, and which included Larry Carlton (who not too long after played on Katy Lied and The Royal Scam), and Joe Sample (who subsequently joined him on Aja and Gaucho, the last of which finally roped in Scott himself).

That same band also played on Miles of Aisles and the Hissing of Summer Lawns (which did rope in Victor Feldman from Dan-land, but featured Chuck Findley before he played on The Royal Scam, et al) and absent a reason to challenge her statement, Mingus approached Joni rather than vice versa, presumably after noting her work with Jaco and other Weather Reporters on Hejira (a year before Aja came out) and Don Juan's Reckless Daughter.

re: "oh but hejira is your actual favorite joni record" sure, ok, yes, hejira's accomplishments can't be overstated, it's probably her most comprehensive lyrical achievement, it sounds like no other record, a complete world of its own made up less of chordal progressions than desert shimmers. hissing resembles several records but that's ok imo bc it's the most distant and almost... orchestrated version of all the fusiony jazz-pop records it shares superficial qualities with (the motifs in "shades of scarlett conquering" and especially the "darkness!" choral vocal in the title track feel so symphonic to me), a storyteller observing her characters with an eye that isn't detached or unsympathetic but still doesn't interfere emotionally with what's already happening, allowing the scene to develop almost of its own accord. i hear the word "honesty" associated with joni's work a lot and i think this is really the form of honesty she deals in, a kind of pop flannery o'connor, characters so completely realized that their feelings power them toward their fates. also idk, as soon as i hear the drums in "in france they kiss on main street" i'm completely mesmerized, what a fucking record

tl;dr even though hejira is her most realized record-as-soundworld the in-betweenness of hissing is what draws me to it

This is my favorite too. “Oh well, just another hard time band with negro affectations” = such a great line that you could never get away with now, although I don’t *think* she meant anything problematic by it (if anything she’s calling out the white dudes)