he really 'isn't' that interesting
― Master of Treacle, Sunday, 18 October 2015 04:24 (eight years ago) link
I'll agree that MacKaye isn't interesting enough for two chapters, honestly I'd probably cut the Fugazi one, since so much of Fugazi's strongest work is outside of the time period of the book (though I guess you could make an argument that it should be included because it represents the continued spirit of the 80s "underground")
I do think the book is better for having two bands whose most famous work is meat-and-potatoes hardcore. It gives a chance to emphasize the city-by-city scenes of kids inspired to start bands. Otherwise it'd just immediately jump to the all the bands that were outliers for being more arty or melodic or jammy.
Also it'd be weird to write a book about hardcore punk and what came out of it and not include the early 80s DC scene. Like I said upthread, a Bad Brains chapter would have accomplished the same thing, though I legitimately don't know if their recordings fit the criteria that Azerrad used as far as independent labels/distribution.
― intheblanks, Sunday, 18 October 2015 05:46 (eight years ago) link
As far as the Nirvana book, I have never read it, I'll take your word that it makes a lot of the Mudhoney chapter redundant.
― intheblanks, Sunday, 18 October 2015 05:47 (eight years ago) link
Is Jess' review of this for Freaky Trigger still around? I'd dig it up via archive.org, but that's blocked in China ...
Surprised this book's become as canonical as it has considering the defects - whole bunch of Guangzhou musicians I know have read it, and find Beat Happening p.inspirational.
― etc, Sunday, 18 October 2015 06:01 (eight years ago) link
absolutely baffles me that everyone around here loves the Huskers and hates Black Flag. I'm guessing that's related to one Greg Ginn.
Faves: MoB, Huskers, Mats, Big Black, Raymond Pettibon.
― campreverb, Sunday, 18 October 2015 13:42 (eight years ago) link
I like Black Flag especially the marquee 84 gig, but do like that whole heavy as rock grinding thing they were doing around that time and the Chuck Dukowski version of that material too.
― Stevolende, Sunday, 18 October 2015 14:01 (eight years ago) link
Shakey, you need to hear My War, jesus. At least side 2. I can leave everything bf did after that.
― banned on ixlor (Jon not Jon), Sunday, 18 October 2015 18:53 (eight years ago) link
Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.
― System, Wednesday, 21 October 2015 00:01 (eight years ago) link
Re: later Black Flag stuff, My War is def worth hearing but I like In My Head even more
― Underground Rick (albvivertine), Wednesday, 21 October 2015 00:40 (eight years ago) link
Realize this won't be a popular vote, but I saw a ton of Replacements shows in their first few years. Loved 'em more than anything else on this list by far.
― Retro novelty punk (Dan Peterson), Wednesday, 21 October 2015 16:05 (eight years ago) link
Like:Sonic YouthBeat HappeningDino JrThe ReplacementsBig BlackFugaziHusker Du
Dislike:Black Flag
Even heard enough:MudhoneyButthole SurfersMinor ThreatMission Of BurmaMinutemen
― Van Horn Street, Wednesday, 21 October 2015 16:25 (eight years ago) link
Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.
― System, Thursday, 22 October 2015 00:01 (eight years ago) link
100+ votes is pretty good turnout
― Exit, pursued by Yogi Berra (WilliamC), Thursday, 22 October 2015 00:08 (eight years ago) link
Poor calvin
― Modern French Music from Failure to Boulez (askance johnson), Thursday, 22 October 2015 03:00 (eight years ago) link
yeah i'm fine w/ beat happening, enough time has passed, but there was no way in hell i was voting beat happening. that said calvin is the hero of this book. voted fugazi as that's the one i'm by far most likely to listen to nowadays, would guess sonic youth is the one i've listened to most (over husker du) but that's mainly sheer volume of releases. except for mudhoney, beat happening, and i guess butthole surfers (all of whom i like)(like those first few butthole surfers way more than any mudhoney or beat happening, they just fell off pretty hard and became supertiresome in general for me), i love every group up there.
― balls, Friday, 23 October 2015 10:36 (eight years ago) link
I think this book would have been improved with some levity towards the end - I would possibly have made some room for Camper Van Beethoven, for example. Sonically, there's some 'spirit of punk' right there (compared to one or two groups who talked the talk but sounded not unlike everyone else)
Ian MacKaye's problem with T&G ("they were the ones who smoked cigars and ate ribs") - what's that about? It seemed like a contemporaneous interview.
― Master of Treacle, Sunday, 25 October 2015 04:39 (eight years ago) link
wasn't T&G was pretty well respected? i thought i heard they uniformly did 50/50 recording contracts with bands
― brimstead, Sunday, 25 October 2015 19:21 (eight years ago) link
maybe that's not that great, idk
― brimstead, Sunday, 25 October 2015 19:22 (eight years ago) link
i wonder if ian mackaye has ever had a conversation with paul westerberg about the proper performance state of mind
― reggie (qualmsley), Sunday, 25 October 2015 19:35 (eight years ago) link
I always took that "cigars and ribs" remark as reflecting a pretty clear culture clash between the Dischord wing of steadfast DIYism and the T&G/Albini/"pigfuck" wing. It's easy to imagine that the guy who wrote the lyrics to "Suggestion" might look askance at the part of the scene that plays host to a band called Rapeman.
― JRN, Sunday, 25 October 2015 19:36 (eight years ago) link
It's also a working class midwest mindset vs. activist/political east coast mindset.
― Josh in Chicago, Sunday, 25 October 2015 20:37 (eight years ago) link
Trying to think which of the midwest punk/indie bands of the era ever got political. Not the Effigies, Naked Raygun, Big Black, Jesus Lizard, Killdozer ...
― Josh in Chicago, Sunday, 25 October 2015 20:39 (eight years ago) link
Effigies 'We're Da Machine' is v pointedly political
― these are my pincers and if you don't like them I have udders (DJ Mencap), Sunday, 25 October 2015 21:03 (eight years ago) link
but yeah there was an avoidance of hectoring or anything that might resemble it in nearly all cases
― these are my pincers and if you don't like them I have udders (DJ Mencap), Sunday, 25 October 2015 21:04 (eight years ago) link
toxic reasons?
― Haino Corrida (NickB), Sunday, 25 October 2015 21:17 (eight years ago) link
Articles of Faith
― Just noise and screaming and no musical value at all. (Colonel Poo), Sunday, 25 October 2015 22:59 (eight years ago) link