Are you cool with forks making Spotify playlists out of every rolling thread without permission?

" the guy stroking his chin in faux-magnanimity at the collective works of Rick Witter, going "hmmm, how can I meet the artist half way in what he was trying to achieve here"

lol about 90% of ILM there.

Yeah while adults who continue to believe the myths of their teenage cliquedom are a sad lot, so are those who don't recognize hackery and hamfistedness.

Yeah of course I prefer the latter group personally and yeah they're the salt of the earth but fuck there's a lot of crap out there, admit it. Do you folks never go to local shows? Cause that's 99% of music. Most of the bands are just ineptly cribbing acts they view as authentic. Go to a folk open mic and tell me their lyrics are aesthetically on par with Yeats because it's all relative. Help it percolate to the top. Then call me a hater when it hits my radar.

"You see this from the fawning praise laid at the feet of transparently limited young bands under the guise of Supporting New Music, like where's the incentive for these bands to actually get good? Where's the balance for the legions of better bands missing out on coverage as a result?"

yeah, why don't we throw a cymbal at them so they can become the next charlie parker. seriously, nobody is motivated to be better by being attacked.

"the guy stroking his chin in faux-magnanimity at the clusterfuck of his incompetent coworker, going "hmmm, how can I meet the artist half way in what he was trying to achieve here"

Its all about grey areas - like so much work fails or suceeds to a certain extent so I usually want to read people who engage with something at that level. You know that happens when a writer you think you know will come up with something that surprises you, even after I've spent time reading you and think I know how you roll. More into the shape of the argument.

Requires getting stuck into something, evidence you're muddling through as much as the rest of us. Otherwise I get bored and stop reading. I know I've clicked on it and, for the record, I am now sorry I did.

Rushomancy - so I take it from your post that you've never heard a song in which proving haters wrong is acknowledged as a specific motivation?

matt dc as jk simmons in whiplash to an ingenue site moderator

"that's not my threadlock! you fucking worthless piece of horseshit, lock at my fucking tempo" *hurls html bug at young miles teller*

since i can't respond on ilx mail, thanks to jared for the work on the spotify script.. that's rad!

fitting that my horribly-forksed 'joke' killed this thread for over a day

that and there is literally nothing to discuss re: this topic

true

only 20 days til the poll closes!

We can do it, I know we can.

I say we keep it going until David Bowie RIP disappears.

New display name, yo!

ILM Inc should just non-exclusively license lists compiled on the board to different services, any curatorial fees are split between whoever hunts through the service for the right versions of songs and server maintenance fees

I'm assuming listmakers on Spotify or any other service make about the price of a cup of coffee per list, though

brb sending forks half a coffee via postal mail, pouring the other half directly into the server

https://sketchbloom.files.wordpress.com/2010/02/coffeebutton.jpg

curatorial fees are split

that sort of talk will get you called a lowlife

it's important to remind ourselves that posters with garbage opinions don't actually have to make a meaningful difference in how we enjoy music

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

at last

v. excited

Should have had this end on Super Tuesday

Works for me

this thread is kind of like hunter thompson's "high-water mark—that place where the wave finally broke and rolled back." except with urine and a subway seat

this thread is amazing, i love this thread

tbh i'm not cool with you loving this thread without permission

fair

lol i had forgotten about this thread, simpler times

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

😎

Forks gets the nomination.

http://remarkableleader.files.wordpress.com/2015/07/sally-field-oscar.jpg

Not cool with system collating and distributing these results on ilx

thread vmic

turnout extremely high - way to get out the vote!

https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/236x/5c/ff/89/5cff89b028729c46f0c8a1d8ba7590fe.jpg

high-5 other 27!

Actually one of the 28 was me as a joke vote. I'm cool with it too forks.

Ilx to straight-edge fussbudget: get stuffed.

ILX establishment cannot contain forks, he's a maverick

I only voted not because like most I assumed it was a joke thread at first

yeah I voted "not" on accident because I didn't understand the question

But what if everyone who voted 'Yes' also voted so because they thought it was a joke and they thought 'Not' would be the obvious answer? We need a re-poll.

Seriously. And we need to let it run longer this time so we have time to properly consider all sides of the issue and the potential ramifications of forks doing things without our permission. Let's set the new poll to end three years from today, and I'll start putting together a committee so that we can get formal hearings underway as soon as possible. This is not a joke, people. This is our lives.

Trump next.

wow 181 ppl regularly contributing to rolling threads... ilm is in rude health

As I patrol all of those threads, I can say that number seems just about right as an aggregate!

maybe a LITTLE heavy... say about 150 total. And DJ Martian counts as eight.