I have had it up to here waiting for the Beatles catalogue to be remastered

There are even UK pressings of it from later in the '70s.

The Past Masters compilations pretty much obliterated the need for those type of compilations.

I like how tidy The Beatles discography has become - sticking with the UK albums and using the Past Masters to gather up the extras.

If only the Stones had control of their '60s stuff, they could have done the same.

Weird, didn't know that about Hey Jude. Makes sense, since it was mostly singles compiled on an LP for the first time.

xp

also, not sure penny lane and SFF would have fit on the album without cutting something else.

Yeah, the only way that they'd fit onto the album is if the tracklisting was wildly reshuffled to the point where it wouldn't even be the same album.

The stereo mixes of "Rain," "Lady Madonna," and "Revolution" were all done for Hey Jude and I think those are the ones still in use. ("Paperback Writer" had been mixed in stereo for A Collection of Beatles Oldies.)

The tidiest package is the Beatles mono box, which has fantastic Japanese origami versions of the LPS, down to mini reproductions of the Emitex sleeves. The stereo box seemed provisional, since this stuff was likely to get remastered/remixed eventually.

A Collection of Beatles Oldies has one of the best covers. So does Hey Jude for that matter. Not to mention the cover for the white album that was scrapped but used for some compilation in some other country. I love the non standard album art.

" The tidiest package is the Beatles mono box"

well aside from the fact that it doesn't include Abbey Road or Let it Be.

I don't rate the stereo mixes of 'Lady Madonna' and 'Paperback Writer' very highly.

well aside from the fact that it doesn't include Abbey Road or Let it Be.

Those are best on LP, IMO.

fair enough. I am thinking of getting rid of my stereo CD box since I only listen to digital rips of these when I am not at home, at which time I actually just listen to older LPs from the blue box.

i wonder how many other boxes they can spin out of the catalogue this way? White Album next year for a cert.

Given how much work it took to put the Sgt. Pepper's thing together, I'd guess it would take longer to work on a box set for The Beatles, so unless this is currently being worked on right now, I'd say there was no chance.

Get Back/Let It Be box probably more likely.

also less interesting to me. would just be nice to get a better sounding release of the Kinfaun demos. don't know if that will ever happen.

are those the same as the Esher demos? i dunno, i can see them releasing those ...

Yeah, they're the same thing.

It would be hilarious if they announced a 7CD box for The Beatles and two of the CD's are just sessions for 'Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da'

is there an Esher/Kinfauns CD/Box that is considered definitive? i recall pre-2009 that the Purple Chick mob did the definitive 'remaster' bootlegs for example and peopel went nuts. all the Esher stuff i've heard is dreadful quality.

There are seven tracks of it on Anthology 3 and, in fact, that whole first disc is all White Album stuff (incl. "Hey Jude").

not sure. I have some version of it I downloaded from somewhere and it's ok. not dreadful, not superlative. I'm kind of increasingly surprised at how high a quality most of the leaked beatles bootlegs have been.

like the whole unsurpassed masters series (and the other one that was concurrent and overlapped with it)...those are perfectly listenable.

i like the way the Esher demos sound. it would suck to have them fix the phasing and messiness, it would suck the life out of them. but w/e i will buy a proper release

Bring life to them, more like. There's plenty of shit bands making deliberately lo-fi music for a cupboard full of hipsters in Oregon. The Beatles are a hi-fidelity band, thank fuck.

Ehhhh I mean they're home demos, right? The Beatles already went the route of turning them into hi-fi music by, y'know, making the White Album and Abbey Road. Trying to take the demos and morph them into a facsimile of studio product really might not get anywhere, and at worst might result in a "Real Love" kind of recording where it lacks the life of the demo and the oomph and richness that an actual reunited Beatles might plausibly have come up with.

the esher demos sound great, i said from the cupboard

Nobody is saying "turn the home demos into studio recordings", just to clean them up - reduce the tape hiss and correct any damage that may have happened to the recordings over the years. Beatles fans have come to expect a certain standard of product, and it'd also be a little silly to put out an official version of something that has been widely bootlegged unless there was some incentive for buying it.

'Real Love' sounds great, IMO. I genuinely believe they did their very best with what they had to work with - else it wouldn't have been released. I trust Paul McCartney, George Harrison, Ringo Starr and Jeff Lynne's judgement on those recordings.

the esher stuff included on anthology 3 sound good, right?

Yeah, I always thought the Esher stuff sounded fine, and in fact had to double-check the liner notes on Anthology 3 to make sure these were in fact "home" demos.

Hooof, well, we'll have to agree to disagree about "Real Love"! I liked it when it came out but I don't return to it much, and the Lynne gloss (which I do love on other records) kind of swamps it for me. Also makes it probably the tinniest thing ever put out under the Beatles name.

For me, it feels like what it is - an unfinished song that got a bunch of overdubbing to make it feel more "Beatlesy," boosting the ratings for the documentary and sales for the album. I'm sure George only agreed because he needed the money, as with the rest of the Anthology project. In the long term it hasn't really added anything meaningful to the Beatles catalogue and it would have been fine if it had never been done IMHO.

(Actually, is there a thread specifically about FAAB and RL? Feels like there would be...)

The Escher stuff on Anthology 3 was obviously cleaned up for release, as you'd expect.

I like "Real Love" a lot but agree it's basically an unnecessary coda to their discography

I recently listened to the two '94 songs again, and they really haven't aged well at all, solely due to Lynne's production, or rather, that fucking gated snare he inexplicably needs to use on absolutely everything.

COMING SOON: "Free As A Bird" & "Real Love"...NAKED

i don't *hate* the 94 songs, but yeah they are very inessential.

The anthology version of "real love" us awful. The demo version is lovely.

"Real Love" is a good enough song that it overcomes the production imo. I agree that the Lynne tics are an unnecessary gloss that get in the way.

I like "Real Love" a lot but agree it's basically an unnecessary coda to their discography

― Οὖτις, Friday, April 14, 2017 3:49 PM (eighteen minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

This is basically my stance on it - it didn't need to be done, but I'm glad it exists. I also think 'Real Love' happens to be a great song, which I rank as being up there with any post-'70 Lennon song. 'Free As a Bird' isn't anywhere near as good.

I hate the way the Esher demos sound on Anthology. All of the delicious double-tracked phasing on the vocals and guitar is gone. they sound empty

also a lot of the background chatter and laughing is gone - that's so essential to the vibe of those demos! i love listening to that bootleg because it's like spending a beautiful stoned spring afternoon w the Beatles.

is it? i thought all that stuff was kept in, just that they just a direct rip from George's 4-track masters.

at any rate, sign me up for remastering the Esher stuff. the Anthology 3 stuff sounded insanely good compared to the boots

yeah i just listened to Junk and Piggies, there's no phasing and none of the background chatter

Thank fuck.

aw, it's great though! i love hearing John come in early on one of his vocal takes on 'Dear Prudence' and then go "oops! hehe"

but yeah, I already have these versions. clean em up, go ahead. I really hope they don't pass over a White Album reissue - I think I'll write a letter to EMI this afternoon.

there's def actual songs/demos from that period that didn't make it onto Anthology (Heather, Sour Milk Sea, Child of Nature, The Inner Light, Circles, etc.)

Not Guilty

is on Anthology

you are right lol i had to double check the tracklist. its been years, maybe a decade, since i listened to Anth 3.