THE 10TH ANNUAL ILM METAL POLL:2017 RESULTS THREAD

Don't linger on the cover art for their previous release at work.

This is pretty good at shutting out mental noise.

I wanted to like the Pallbearer album, but then the Elder album came out and just completely swamped it.

yeah the Pallbearer kind of went to mush in the end

I think I wanted the clean vocals to be more operatic on my first listen to the first two tracks. Definitely deserves more time. xp re Lingua Ignota

Her other album from last year seems to lean more towards classical singing. It's beautiful too.

https://linguaignota.bandcamp.com/album/let-the-evil-of-his-own-lips-cover-him

8 Botanist - Collective: The Shape of He to Come 490 Points, 13 Votes, ONE #1
https://i.imgur.com/x3RQFSr.jpg

“The Shape of He to Come” is the first of the “Collective” series, which means that it diverges from the model of Botanist studio albums as the result of me, Otrebor, doing everything, and instead recording more like a full band with distributed responsibilities. “The Shape” stands as a testimonial to the work, time, and effort that six of us put into rehearsing, touring, and composing from the years 2013-2016.

The origins of “The Shape of He to Come” came from my desire to give all the members of Botanist live the opportunity to contribute to a studio record; to give them a greater feeling of inclusion in Botanist -- and also to see what they were capable of and what my options would be for further inclusion in numbered Botanist albums.

The resulting album turned out wonderfully. I took some pre-existing drum tracks that I recorded in 2010 and gave them to D. Neal and R. Chiang with instructions to do what they wanted. Initially, the album was meant to be a 3-song EP, with the three songs being divided amongst Neal and Chiang as to who would take the “lead” and who would write complementary parts.

That proved to be trickier than I had thought. A... more
credits
released September 1, 2017

“The Shape of He to Come” was recorded in various home studios in Northern and Southern California from the years 2010-2016, and mixed and mastered by Jack Shirley @ The Atomic Garden, East Palo Alto, CA, in December, 2016.

http://www.angrymetalguy.com/botanist-collective-shape-come-review/

https://www.sputnikmusic.com/review/74755/Botanist-Collective-The-Shape-of-He-to-Come/

I found it quite irritating to be honest – couldn't make it past the second track. I ought to give it another go.

i had no idea botanist released anything last year!

can't believe I forgot this one when I was making predictions. love this dude's stuff.

Probably the metal album I listened to most last year.

Another of my votes! Felt like a good move for Botanist - letting the other musicians loose in the studio was a necessary next step. And while it's all good, The Reconciliation Of Nature And Man is the one - a titanic achievement that gets distinctly (and awesomely) Jute-Gyte-esque at the end. Who wants to hear microtonal hammered dulcimer?

YOUTUBE LINK TO ALBUM

Bandcamp: https://verdant-realm-botanist.bandcamp.com/album/collective-the-shape-of-he-to-come

Man, the title track is even better than I remember it

7 Krallice - Go Be Forgotten 500 Points, 13 Votes ONE #1
https://i.imgur.com/BNGXRLn.jpg

https://open.spotify.com/album/0WIrigf44VZRcTkzS872iF?si=Wpmwf_W6SDqBeA_SQtzoLw

https://krallice.bandcamp.com/album/go-be-forgotten

https://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/krallice-loum-go-be-forgotten/
http://www.nocleansinging.com/2017/11/21/krallice-go-be-forgotten/

It wasn't forgotten after all

The stuff.

Krallice can do no wrong, and I love that they do more frequent, more focused releases now.

As far as Botanist goes, the clean vocals have this slightly off-key, Ameri-hymnal-like quality to them that I can never stand, whether in this context or elsewhere. The dulcimer is promising but too little is made of it – it mostly just shadows the guitar.

6 Myrkur - Mareridt 509 Points, 14 Votes
https://i.imgur.com/1rzoWLl.jpg

https://open.spotify.com/album/3ewAlccDDYFoybQaMnkTvW?si=1g_T5EjDRFyhbSkqx1qUBw

https://myrkur.bandcamp.com/album/mareridt-deluxe-version

Mareridt (translation: Nightmare) is the highly anticipated sophomore full-length from renowned Danish composer and multi-instrumentalist MYRKUR. Recorded between Copenhagen and Seattle with producer Randall Dunn (Marissa Nadler, Earth, Sunn O))), Boris, Wolves In The Throne Room), Mareridt is a rich juxtaposition of the dark and the light; the moon and the mother earth; the witch and the saint. MYRKUR explores deeper into the mysterious and the feminine with 11 tracks that further progress her visionary blend of metal with gorgeous, stirring melodies, dark folk passages, choral arrangements and superb, horrific beauty. Further taking MYRKUR to new artistic heights are lyrics in multiple languages, an unforgettable collaboration with Chelsea Wolfe and an array of special instrumentation including violin, mandola, folk drums, nyckelharpa (an ancient Swedish key harp), and Kulning (an ancient Scandinavian herding call). Mareridt is a profound manifestation of nightmares that demonstrates MYRKUR as one of the truly exceptional artists of our time.
credits
released September 15, 2017

2017 Relapse Records

http://www.angrymetalguy.com/myrkur-mareridt-review/

https://www.pastemagazine.com/articles/2017/09/myrkur-mareridt-review.html

xp There is no guitar for it to shadow though... Anyway it's a beautiful album that I keep going back to, no insult to Mr. Botanist himself but collabrating with other people was a very good idea.

Obviously pleased to see Krallice so high, and I love a lot of GBF, but it feels incomplete to me, there's only three fully fleshed out tracks and one of them is a cover of a previous Mick Barr project. For that reason I prefer Loum.

wait whaaaaaaat

oh it's the fake one

fairly or not, I honestly never really tuned into this one after reading her jerky remarks, though I understand she apologized and whatnot

NICE FAKE K3RR now what's the real #6 :P ILM isn't throwing 1 votes to an out-and-proud Islamophobe, no matter how good her music is!

*16

*14 haha

Yeah, pomenitul, what you're calling "guitar" probably IS the (amplified and distorted) hammered dulcimer.

Never really got into Myrkur. I always just feel like there's not enough musical meat there.

although her voice is pretty and there are some nice tunes.

(I really like Ameri-hymnal folk singing, tbf.)

Myrkur does not know how to write songs. I went back to her 1st album and it has a nice vibe but there's something that REALLY feels incomplete. From what I heard this is something that has not been solved with her latest. And that's ignoring her milkshake duck moment.

I mean, I voted for Nokturnal Mortum and they probably have worse opinions than her, but that's coz I'm special :P Not questioning her right to be there, I just think it's a fake lol

Last sentence was incomplete. There's a lot less to no clean singing on the earlier Botanist releases. Try VI if you haven't heard it, maybe? 2xp Yeah, I think that's it.

flora rules

^yes

I dont do puns or fakes

except for the time i posted this instead of the real album

https://youtu.be/3PakAiTZWAs

noooo

fine, fine, let's actually listen to this

What is this Nightwish/Within Temptation shit?

Yeah, that's not a guitar and I'm a dunce. I'll check out Botanist's earlier stuff as penance.

Re: Myrkur, I preferred her debut.

Myrkur's debut had 2 or 3 good songs on it at least. Let's see how this fares in comparison

a profound manifestation of nightmares

Talk about inflation of metal jargon. Runhild Gammelsæter this ain't.

LBI, what's yr beef with Nightwish

oh god

it's on

No beef, I just think it's terrible fairy muzak.

Shitewish amirite

btw the myrkur album is good.

Once was a fine metal gateway record when I was but a wee lad.

Anyway, I will try to give this one an earnest shot soon.