ILM Top 77 Tracks of 2018 Poll Afterparty: Ballots, Recrimination, Statistics and Damned Lies

^go back to lurking! (lol)

Ok!

Full results: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1HzfsaI__ThO3bvcUt4lYYTPBmNFDFteyVSzYgNlVvwE/edit?usp=sharing
Voter stats: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Qead3e_uylrHxeAMI1pzfuVUqu-F6USOzpN8TJv9hlM/edit?usp=sharing
Artist results: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/11H0HCDx5tfKMNrlZyDyh1UHb7jtJwjYkgAyNKtfksBE/edit?usp=sharing

Ballots as requested:

frogbs

Datarock - Feathers and Wax
Daphne & Celeste - Alarms
Orbital - P.H.U.K.
Janelle Monáe - Americans
Andrew W.K. - Music Is Worth Living For
Underworld and Iggy Pop - Bells & Circles
Andrew W.K. - I Don't Know Anything
Autechre - violvoic
Andrew W.K. - Total Freedom
Daphne & Celeste - Song To A Succulent
Janelle Monáe - Make Me Feel

nashwan

Ssion, Ariel Pink - At Least The Sky Is Blue
Chaka Khan - Like Sugar
Fischerspooner, Caroline Polachek - Togetherness
Neon Indian - Heaven's Basement (Theme From 86'd)
En Vogue - Electric Cafe
Childish Gambino - Feels Like Summer
Daphne & Celeste - Alarms
Mr Twin Sister - Echo Arms
DJ Koze with Roisin Murphy – Illumination
Nabihah Iqbal - Zone 1 To 6000

Fever Ray - Wanna Sip (Olof Dreijer Remix)
Simian Mobile Disco, Deep Throat Choir - Defender
Jon Hassell – dreaming
El Perro Del Mar - Fight For Life
Kamasi Washington - Fists of Fury
Hannah Peel - Kiss Me First
Róisín Murphy - Plaything
Tornado Wallace, Sui Zhen - Today (Move D Remix)
Mappa Mundi - Trance Fusion (Hunee Edit)
Kelela - Waitin' (Kaytranada Remix)
Kimbra & DAWN - Version of Me
Fabiana Palladino - Shimmer
Nile Rodgers & Chic - State Of Mine (It's About Time)
Gwenno – Tir Ha Mor
Snoop Dogg, Fred Hammond - Call Him

oh and this was my ballot:

The Beths - River Run: Lvl 1
Meg Baird and Mary Lattimore - Fair Annie
Domenique Dumont - Le Soleil Dans Le Monde
Nite Jewel - On Your Own
Fabiana Palladino - Shimmer
Keyakizaka46 - Moumorihekaerouka?
Ariana Grande - No Tears Left To Cry

Roisin Murphy - The Rumble
Mother of Mars - Hera in the Valley
Perfume - Mugenmirai
YAMANTAKA // SONIC TITAN - Out of Time
Ravyn Lenae - The Night Song
Lizzo - Boys
Dustin Wong / Takako Minekawa / Good Willsmith - The Garden of Earthly Flanger
Juliana Hatfield - Physical
Otha - One of the Girls
Tess Roby - Borders
Midori Takada and Lafawndah - Le Renard Bleu
Planningtorock - Much to Touch
Barbara Morgenstern - Triggerpunkt
Keith Fullerton Whitman - Albatross (Blend)
Peggy Gou - It Makes You Forget (Itgehane)
Kali Uchis - Your Teeth In My Neck
Hyolyn - See Sea
Lana Del Rey - Venice Bitch

obv you should check out all the ones in bold

tt asked earlier as well (I only say on her behalf as she's asleep) :)

Voters topping the charts

Most lonely: saer :(
Top blood sausage m8: toby
The fuxxoriest fuxxor: Indexed
The infinite antifuxxors: imago, breastcrawl, MarkoP, Dinsdale, kruezer2, tangenttangent, daavid, Odysseus, peepee, saer
Hivemind queen: Murgatroid

tangenttangent

Trust Fund - Abundant
U.S. Girls - M.A.H
Snape - Waiting for Death
SOPHIE - Faceshopping
Tropical Fuck Storm - Chameleon Paint
Black Dresses - Thoughts and Prayers
Hop Along - Not Abel
Mitski - A Pearl
Young Dreams - My Brain On Love
Hen Ogledd - Problem Child
Vennart - Immortal Soldiers
Superchunk - Erasure
YAMANTAKA // SONIC TITAN - Out of Time
Suede - Life Is Golden
Kero Kero Bonito - Only Acting
mewithoutyou - Winter Solstice
Bill Wurtz - Mount St Helens Is Going To Blow Up
Die Wilde Jagd - 2000 Elefanten
Jeff Rosenstock - Yr Throat
Joanna Wang - The Motorized Scooter Edo
Optiganally Yours - How Do You Feel?
EASYFUN - Be Your USA
Teleman - Submarine Life
Dashboard Confessional - Catch You
Clarence Clarity - W€ CHANG£

wau Gambino got 8 votes and still didn't place

LOL at me being the only voter for my number 1 choice ("Promises").

seandalai can you post mine for me pls

xp I know the feeling

that's especially odd though, since Tim and jaymc tied for most votes in the top 77

The funny thing is that I had equal highest representation of my votes in the top 77 (15/25), and of everything I voted for "Promises" was probably the biggest actual chart performer?

xpost

johnny crunch

lil baby & gunna - drip too hard
Drake - Nice For What
The Internet - Come Over
Cardi B ft. 21 Savage - Bartier Cardi
Drake – In My Feelings
Drake - God's Plan
Lana Del Rey - Venice Bitch
Saweetie - ICY GRL
Childish Gambino - This Is America
Nicki Minaj ft. Ariana Grande - bed
halsey - without me
Ariana Grande - No Tears Left To Cry
Calvin Harris ft. Dua Lipa - One Kiss
Camila Cabello - Never Be the Same
lil baby & drake - yes indeed
Kanye West - Ghost Town
Playboi Carti ft. Red Coldhearted - Middle of the Summer
flipp dinero - leave me alone
Post Malone ft. 21 Savage – rockstar
kanye west - no mistakes
Sheck Wes - Mo Bamba
Panic! At the Disco - High Hopes

My list

The Beths - Little Death
Hop Along - How Simple
Rae Morris - Dancing With Character
Lana Del Rey - Venice Bitch
Mitski - Nobody
St. Vincent - Fast Slow Disco
Robyn - Because It's in the Music
Let's Eat Grandma - Donnie Darko
Charli XCX - Girls Night Out
Musya Totibadze - Останусь с тобой
Kali Uchis ft. Bootsy Collins & Tyler The Creator - After The Storm
Jessie Ware - Overtime
Fabiana Palladino - Shimmer
The 1975 – Love it if we made it
Hatchie - Sure
Ravyn Lenae - Sticky
Kasper Marrot - Keflavik
The Radio Dept. - Going Down Swinging
Krystal Klear - Neutron Dance
Lindstrøm ft. Ronika - Didn't Know Better
Raveena - Honey
Ariana Grande - No Tears Left To Cry
Le SuperHomard - Paper Girl
Lucy Dacus - Night Shift
Rina Sawayama - Cherry

Monotony my top neighbour. I think that's six years in a row now.

My weighted ballot. *'s placed.

Okkervil River - Famous Tracheotomies
Janelle Monae - Americans
*The 1975 - TooTimeTooTimeTooTime
John Prine - Boundless Love
Neko Case - Winnie
Carly Rae Jepsen - Party of One
Buffalo Tom - Roman Cars
*Toni Braxton - Long as I Live
*Hatchie - Sure
Titus Andronicus - Real Talk
St. Vincent - Fast Slow Disco
Superchunk - Reagan Youth
Downtown Boys - Fotos Y Recuerdos
Wussy - Aliens in Our Midst
Young Dreams - My Brain on Love
Jann Arden - All the Little Things
Laura Veirs - Lightning Rod
Christine Fellows - Cocoon
Camp Cope - The Opener
Marsha Ambrosius - Old times

Can’t copy and paste from my phone but that’s quite a long list of songs that get 1 first place and no other votes, my own number one included

"Rubber Bullies" getting 6 votes has me very optimistic about the TFS album placement

my mixed ballot, bold placed

Superchunk - Black Thread
Sheck Wes - Mo Bamba
mr twin sister – jaipur
Sada Baby & Drego - Bloxk Party
Hop Along - Prior Things
Peggy Gou - It Makes You Forget (Itgehane)
Valee ft. Jeremih - Womp Womp
Kali Uchis - Your Teeth In My Neck
Natalie Prass - Hot For The Mountain
Gunna ft. Lil Baby & Young Thug - Oh Okay
H.C. McEntire - Red Silo

Khalid ft. 6lack & Ty Dolla $ign – OTW
Amen Dunes - Believe
Arctic Monkeys - Four Out Of Five
The Breeders – Dawn: Making an Effort
Rae Morris - Dancing With Character
Hoodboi ft. Tkay Maidza - Glide
Rae Sremmurd ft. Young Thug – Offshore
Beach House - Black Car
Neko Case - Bad Luck
Hailu Mergia - Lala Belu
Future - When I Think About It
Robyn - Send To Robyn Immediately
Screaming Females - I'll Make You Sorry
Westerman - Confirmation

I didn't nominate tracks but nevertheless ended up being the sole voter for these two. Many thanks to whoever nominated Bas Jan in particular. Hadn't even heard of them before the noms playlist!

Bas Jan - Walton on the Naze
Tirzah - Devotion

weighted (did not place, sole voter)

Marsha Ambrosius - Old Times
Kurt Vile - Bassackwards
H.E.R. ft. Bryson Tiller - Could've Been
Kash Doll - For Everybody
Kacey Musgraves - Slow Burn
Toni Braxton - Long As I Live
Phoebe Bridgers - Motion Sickness
Gerardo Ortíz - Egoísta
Khalid, 6lack & Ty Dolla $ign - OTW
Simmy ft. Sun-El Musician - Ubala
Lana Del Rey - Mariners Apartment Complex
Empress Of - When I'm With Him
Jacquees - You
Raymix - Oye Mujer
Sophie - Faceshopping
Mariah Carey - With You
Kim Petras - Heart To Break
Derez De'Shon - Fed Up
Ariana Grande - Breathin
Troye Sivan - Bloom
Taylor Swift - Delicate
Lil Baby - Cash
Trippie Redd - Topanga
Guayaba - Bye Bich (Dark Meat Remix)
MNEK - Tongue

great poll as always! i haven't gotten to the top ~20 or so yet but i can hold off for a little bit since as usual it looks to be the most boring part of the poll, at least based on the ones i know (yes i know some of the ones i voted for made it up there). whytf do ppl enjoy that particular mitski song. props to the pollrunners, voters and moka for the terrific graphics!!

last thoughts for now: both ariana grande songs that placed in the top 10 deserve to have been 78'd and are only impressive as seamlessly assembled, hyperefficient industry products. (yes i know i voted for a different ariana song that could also be described similarly.) i am starting to get sick of the 1975, the 'poptimist ;)' band for rockists, but alas one of my few heterosexual male friends has recently notified me that he really loves the new album (unsure if he'd heard any of the previous ones) so i guess i'll have to listen to it in full since i can't afford to lose any of those these days. i like "boo'd up" okay (not as much as "trip") but am sometimes perplexed by how little justification ppl seem to give for why they supposedly love it so much. surprised in a good way at how many ppl in the rundown enjoyed "long as i live" despite never having heard it before -- do turn on a grown-folks r&b station sometime! "before i do" not placing last year was a fucking disaster.

both ariana grande songs that placed in the top 10 deserve to have been 78'd and are only impressive as seamlessly assembled, hyperefficient industry products.

Everyone’s entitled to their opinion, but you voted for that Kim Petras track, so... GTFO

Deafheaven - Honeycomb
The Nels Cline 4 - Imperfect 10
Mitski – Nobody
The Beths - You Wouldn't Like Me
Andrew W.K. - Music Is Worth Living For
Amy Brandon/Julian Bertino - Intermountainous
Nick Omiccioli - the field well
awakebutstillinbed - fathers
Nick Omiccioli/newEar Contemporary Chamber Ensemble - Haunted Seas
Alice in Chains - The One You Know
Sons of Kemet - My Queen is Harriet Tubman
Ghost - Rats
YAMANTAKA // SONIC TITAN - Out of Time
Mary Halvorson - Storm Cloud
Childish Gambino - This Is America
Andrew W.K. - Total Freedom
The Beths - Future Me Hates Me
YAMANTAKA // SONIC TITAN - Yandere
Deafheaven - Worthless Animal
Mitski - Geyser
Panic! At the Disco - High Hopes
Jack Tickner – Let’s Go
Julia Holter - I Shall Love 2
Greta Van Fleet - When the Curtain Falls
Ella Mai – Boo'd Up

seamlessly assembled, hyperefficient industry products

Leaving aside any general objection to this kind of description one might have, it seems to me that one can no longer (if one ever could) say from a production/creation standpoint that this description applies to "No More Tears Left To Cry" or "Thank U, Next" more readily than it does to much else studio-created "pop" in the broad sense - e.g. including, say, Wizkid.

What perhaps marks out Ariana, and these two singles in particular, is not anything about them as products in isolation but rather the systems of meaning into which they are received - their ready memefication (people posting instagram picks of themselves on profile in greyscale with a burst of rainbow light; the immediate sloganisation of "thank u, next"), largely made possible by ariana's status as the people's diva and locating her in a relationship of both similarity with and divergence from beyonce (sweaters with pink "surfboard" slogans; "I woke up like this"). You might describe the way they enter the new media slipstream as "seamless" and "hyperefficient" but there's nothing interchangeable with other pop products about those qualities.

It seems to me that if one was going to criticise them ("thank u, next" in particular) it would be to argue that much of their appeal is premised on these contextual effects, without which they're (it would be argued) weaksauce not hotsauce.

But since one does not have to divorce the songs from those effects, I ranked "thank u, next" pretty high up my list.

It’s also just a lazy description — you can literally hear the “seams” in “NTLTC,” that’s partly why it’s so compelling and unusual.

(It repeatedly employs an abruptly/harshly clipped vocal hook!)

kind of amazing that any "industry product" description of ariana's work, ESPECIALLY thank u next and no more tears to cry ignores the terrorist attack that intersected with her life only a year and a half before. both those songs are easily read and recognizable as deeply human responses. pop can be commercial and honest and it's silly to refuse to acknowledge that.

yeah I def reacted to "no tears..." specifically with that context in the front of my mind

and the association is still there

Tirzah – “Holding On” - wasn't sure how i was gonna dig it when they started playing 3 blind mice on a default synth setting but this one really comes together nice! i really like how clear her voice comes thru, it's a low key wonderful voice. if other songs are similar i could for sure see myself getting into this (in a way i didn't with e.g. nite jewel b/c i only liked one song)

― they're not booing you, sir, they're shouting "Boo'd Up" (Will M.)

This was one of my favorite songs of the year and one of my favorite albums of the decade. If I were a musician this would be the kind of album I’d love to create. It sounds like two good friends having fun with a 4-track and most of the time that’s the sort of vibe I look for in music.

Tim and jaymc tied for most votes in the top 77

― rob, Thursday, January 31, 2019 7:55 PM (three hours ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

Hivemind, baby! Unweighted ballot (bold did not place):

The 1975 - Love It If We Made It
Ariana Grande - No Tears Left to Cry
Bruno Mars ft. Cardi B - Finesse
Christine and the Queens - Doesn’t Matter
DJ Koze - Pick Up
Empress Of - When I'm with Him
Haley Heynderickx - The Bug Collector
Hoodboi ft. Tkay Maidza - Glide
Hop Along - Somewhere a Judge
Iceage ft. Sky Ferreira - Pain Killer
Jessie Ware - Overtime
Kacey Musgraves - High Horse
Kacey Musgraves - Slow Burn
Laura Jean - Girls on the TV
Lizzo - Boys
Meshell Ndegeocello - Sensitivity
Natalie Prass - Short Court Style
Rae Morris - Do It
Raevyn Lave - Sticky
Robyn - Honey
Roisin Murphy - Plaything
Rolling Blackouts Coastal Fever - Mainland
Soccer Mommy - Your Dog
Sun-El Musician ft. Mlindo the Vocalist - Bamthathile
Tove Styrke - Say My Name

Just noticed that Phoebe Bridgers' "Motion Sickness" finished #94. I love it, but it came out in 2017, no?

i like the tirzah largely bc it reminded me (4 obv rzns) of mica levi's feeling romantic feeling tropical feeling ill tape, which is my favorite thing ever

do i need to post my ballot or will the overlords do this for me

Thursdays too forks got up early
and posted results in the blueblack cold,
then with jittery hands that ached
from perhaps an office job, who knows, made
ilxor hearts blaze. Everybody thanked Moka.

I’d wake and hear the votes splintering, breaking.
When the receptions were warm, he’d taunt us with fake-outs,
and slowly I would compose and then delete posts,
fearing the chronic angers of ilm.

Speaking indifferently to him,
who had driven out Childish Gambino
and 78’d my #1 vote as well.
What did I know, what did I know
of music’s austere and lonely prejudices?

respect!

kind of amazing that any "industry product" description of ariana's work, ESPECIALLY thank u next and no more tears to cry ignores the terrorist attack that intersected with her life only a year and a half before. both those songs are easily read and recognizable as deeply human responses. pop can be commercial and honest and it's silly to refuse to acknowledge that.

i was going to post a glib suggestion that everyone stop 'overreacting' to my 'obviously' unserious quip but thank you for reminding me of this. y'all, i'm really sorry i went there. in retrospect i'm a bit ashamed i did. i hope i'll do better.

lol at "The Middle" only getting 36 points. One of the most ubiquitous songs around for at least part of 2018.

A lot of my votes came in at 78-150.

You know the drilo:

Kacey Musgraves – High Horse
Tropical Fuck Storm - You Let My Tyres Down
Thalia & Natti Natasha - No Me Acuerdo
MGMT - One Thing Left to Try
Yves Tumor - Noid
Pardison Fontaine ft. Cardi B - Backin' It Up
The Breeders – Dawn: Making an Effort
Cavern of Anti-Matter - Phase Modulation Shuffle
Ariana Grande – Breathin'
Idris Ackamoor & the Pyramids - Land of Ra
Parquet Courts - Almost Had to Start a Fight/In and Out of Patience
Pusha T - The Story Of Adidon
Meshell Ndegeocello - Waterfalls
Royal Trux - Every Day Swan
Becky G and Natti Natasha - Sin Pijama
Greeicy - Mas Fuerte
Cardi B ft. Kehlani - Ring
Ariana Grande – God Is a Woman
The Armed - Luxury Themes
Ozuna - Unica
Cardi B ft. Bad Bunny & J Balvin - I Like It
Tropical Fuck Storm – Rubber Bullies
Gang Gang Dance - Lotus
Grimes ft. HANA - We Appreciate Power
Kagney Necessary - Bombshell is Atomic

Thursdays too forks got up early
and posted results in the blueblack cold,
then with jittery hands that ached
from perhaps an office job, who knows, made
ilxor hearts blaze. Everybody thanked Moka.

I’d wake and hear the votes splintering, breaking.
When the receptions were warm, he’d taunt us with fake-outs,
and slowly I would compose and then delete posts,
fearing the chronic angers of ilm.

Speaking indifferently to him,
who had driven out Childish Gambino
and 78’d my #1 vote as well.
What did I know, what did I know
of music’s austere and lonely prejudices?

― budo jeru

This is awesome

Thank you for posting my ballot, seandalai!

More poetry from Black Dresses fans in the next rollout, please. Great work!

Seandalai, would it be possible to send both my tracks and albums ballot to the email address I provided with the ballots? (I forgot to save the weighted lists.) Thanks!

mine, weighted

Talaboman - Dins El Llit (Superpitcher Remix)
Simmy ft. Sun-EL Musician - Ubala
Nazar ft. Shannen SP - Airstrike
Autechre - all end
Donato Dozzy - Cleo
Burna Boy - On the Low
Kasper Marrot - Keflavik
LSDXOXO – Freakquency
Daniel Avery – Quick Eternity (Four Tet Remix)
Amen Dunes - Miki Dora
Peach - Silky
Octo Octa - Beam Me Up (To the Goddess Mix)
OCB – Aquaquest Pt.2 (The Anticlimax)
700 Bliss – Cosmic Slop
Omar-S - Games That We Play
Tessela - Glisten
Nego do Borel - Me Solta
ANNA – Hidden Beauties (Original Mix)
Eris Drew - Hold Me (T4T Embrace Mix)
Jon Hopkins – Singularity (ANNA Remix)
Loidis – In the Place I Sit
Fabiana Palladino - Shimmer
Lone - Pulsar
Bruce – What
Bicep – Opal (Four Tet Remix)

First time hearing Black Dresses and they’re great. Where do you usually discuss them in here? Is there an esoteric thread I’m missing?

We haven't started a time-travel thread (i.e. weird/alt shit) this year yet but there's a dedicated BD thread basically: OUT OF FLUX WITH THE UNIVERSE: the canada trans electropop scene

new album in 4 days!

Uhhh any link to the stats yet? I didn't save my ballot locally. If not I'll just post my ballot here after the albums results I guess. One thing I do recall is that probably more than half my tracks list placed, which is an ILM first for me.

Oh never mind found the link!

Full results: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1HzfsaI__ThO3bvcUt4lYYTPBmNFDFteyVSzYgNlVvwE/edit?usp=sharing
Voter stats: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Qead3e_uylrHxeAMI1pzfuVUqu-F6USOzpN8TJv9hlM/edit?usp=sharing
Artist results: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/11H0HCDx5tfKMNrlZyDyh1UHb7jtJwjYkgAyNKtfksBE/edit?usp=sharing

― seandalai, Friday, 1 February 2019 01:33 (five hours ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink