Aerosmith Fite: Toys in the Attic or Rocks

I searched high and low and didn't see this in the archives, even as a pre-poll OPO thread.

rocks

Rocks is the greatest album in rock history.

We haven’t done this (to death?)
Rocks

I thought maybe we did but I couldn't find it. Can you?

Rocks

Rocks

Yup, here is it is : Aerosmith's New Album is called Honkin' On Bobo

Death to false threads.

Sorry, sorry, you’re so sorry

The answer is you should have both on 8 track in your Camaro.

I think I'm leaning toward Toys! Admittedly, it was one of my favourite albums when I was 12 and i never heard all of Rocks until adulthood. I really do think the original "Walk This Way" might be the best thing they ever did, though.

Rocks

I think I'm leaning toward /Toys/! Admittedly, it was one of my favourite albums when I was 12 and i never heard all of /Rocks/ until adulthood. I really do think the original "Walk This Way" might be the best thing they ever did, though.

I think I'm leaning toward /Toys/! Admittedly, it was one of my favourite albums when I was 12 and i never heard all of /Rocks/ until adulthood. I really do think the original "Walk This Way" might be the best thing they ever did, though.

I never got into the non-singles on Toys... Rocks is just one of those albums of non-stop rock action that just breezes/bulldozes by in a brilliant violent flash...

Rocks

in defense of the non-singles on toys: "no more no more" is one of the best aerosmith songs

Love that one, even if the performance on record sounds a little belabored? Missing some of that rocks juice or something

The highs on Toys are higher, but yeah, there’s no competition when you set the two LPs side by side.

Not sure if Tyler’s voice is adequate though

I remember really liking the title track from Toys.

yeah the title track does rip

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

I never got into the non-singles on /Toys/... /Rocks/ is just one of those albums of non-stop rock action that just breezes/bulldozes by in a brilliant violent flash...

in defense of the non-singles on toys: "no more no more" is one of the best aerosmith songs

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

Wow

Yeah I mean I voted rocks obviously but damn

Toys has all the classics ? But rocks rocks

It's a blowout!

The results on my Facebook page were much closer.

Toys is great but has more "middling" songs I think.

but lord, that title track just whallops out of the gate

"No More, No More" is indeed great

"Rats in the Cellar" is balls out from Rocks, almost feels like a precursor to hair metal (not the mid-80s glossed over kind, but the early 80s, more raw kind)

“Blood stained the keys of my daddy’s baby grand /
Ain’t seen the day light since I’m started this band”