The Byrds: Classic Or Dud

It's a great song. I like it enough that seeing Papa M do an instrumental cover in concert was kind of thrilling tbh.
It was probably my first favorite Byrds song.

"Turn! Turn! Turn!" and "Mr. Tambourine Man" are two of the most overplayed songs ever that I don't switch off when they come on the radio. I could list 10 Byrds songs I love more, but neither one is dead for me yet.

listening to John Reilly and What's Happening?! today, hazy summer bliss

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yoSwOrytf_M

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4gD84jbVV3c

that's the jam

haha, those dancers in the "nowhere" clip are rad. almost like they're dancing to a completely different song.

i've always been a little confused by the byrds' status in the late 60s -- were they seen as kinda passe at that point? i guess they just don't show up on a lot of those big festival movies.

Crosby seemed to think so.

yeah, i guess at that point, the byrds might've been "that band David Crosby used to be in." s'pose the fact that mcguinn was the only original member left made a difference too, no matter how awesome the clarence white-era band was.

What's weird to me is how quick the transition was. They always seemed like such distinct entities to me; the original lineup, the sweetheart aberration, the revamped rockers.
But all three of those things existed in 1968. Fucked up year, to say the least.

yeah, no kidding! sort of amazing there was a byrds at the end of all of it. seems like the easiest thing to do would be for mcguinn to start a solo career, but the namebrand thing must've been too much to drop.

"(Untitled)" is a really good album, especially with the unreleased tracks on the last CD reissue. It's kind of a shame that it didn't really give them the fresh start they were hoping. They definitely had a cool sound, much more muscular on some of the rockers and twangy when needed with Clarence White on guitar and good drummer with Gene Parsons. Really in some ways it was way more of a 'band' than the original group, which used a bunch of ringers on the earlier studio stuff. I suppose the fact that McGuinn was the only one left kind of made them seem lame to some. If they would have had a single that would have really landed, it might have been really different, but that is kind of the case of the 2nd half of the Byrds career. There was a lot of music happening in 68-70 to say the least, so I could see how a band, even one with a rep like the Byrds could get lost.

"seems like the easiest thing to do would be for mcguinn to start a solo career"

From what I get reading into all of this, the Byrds were pretty much broke so they were playing live a bunch to kill off some debt. That's the thing I got from an article about Clarence White. It might have been a situation like when Led Zep first toured as the Yardbirds at the beginning...I don't know.

http://a8.sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-ash4/423727_10150578703543406_593208405_9013388_1130855863_n.jpg
1200 pages apparently! good lord.

dude

lol at volume 1 !
guess the second volume is supposed to be about the members' post byrds careers ...

I love that Michael can't keep a straight face in that photo.
Who are they kidding? Nice branch, Crosby!

i'm sure cros was like "this branch ... means something, man!"

So this is "Timeless Flight" expanded again?

yeah i think so. you'd think rogan would be so sick of the byrds by now.

i'm sure cros was like "this branch ... means something, man!"

He believed it played a part in the Kennedy assassination, iirc.

haha.
i actually haven't read timeless flight -- it's good?

Timeless Flight is very good.

Tempted to buy this, despite having bought 2 previous versions of "Timeless Flight". One of my all time favourite music books.

yeah looking forward to reading it. guess it hasn't been published in the US yet? or something?
http://www.amazon.com/Byrds-Requiem-Timeless-Johnny-Rogan/dp/0952954087/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1318659492&sr=8-2

I just went through that. Yeah if you look at amazon.co.uk you will see it.

This guy had a deeeep trove, much of it West Coast buckskin, much of it Byrds and related--all crashed with Mega Mama, but he's re-posting, with Chris Hillman and Friends at the top of this page, Untitled-era live Byrds at the bottom, Flying Burritos etc in between, and might not be long til he restores Byrds x FBB
http://bbchron.blogspot.com/

yeah i grabbed that fbb/byrds gig before it went down -- very fun stuff!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UUOpjDF86yo

Just reminded my first copy of Timeless flight was a thin paperback back in the 80s. then got the one from like 10 years ago & been wondering how necessary an update was on that.
Got the John Einarson Gene Clark book to read sometime in near future too.

did anyone read that latest version of rogan's bio?

http://24.media.tumblr.com/e7486eb541c1887e7a984467ed73b1a7/tumblr_mkov20xPFt1qa9uo9o1_500.jpg

man they're too much aren't they

you listen to them and it's too much, but you keep listening

their time has come again

did anyone read that latest version of rogan's bio?

Classic

holy shit @ the jesu joy of man's desire bridge in she don't care about time. i thought it was just half man half biscuit who pulled that stuff :D

gene is easily the best byrd but younger than yesterday is my favorite album of theirs

Roger McGuinn might be a totally doofus, but he's clearly the best Byrd.

Surprised there hasn't been a Best Byrd poll, tbh.

Roger McGuinn might be a totally doofus, but he's clearly the best Byrd.

Worst is probably Mike.

Dave is a distant second-worst.

Chris I like a lot, especially his bass lines, although I dock him a point or two for being a little sloppy now and then, as well as for his unspectacular multi-instrumentalism. But perhaps I am being too harsh.

Gene is probably the best songwriter

This is probably true or at the very least he is the most consistent (all the other major songwriters had some real stinkers to go along with their gems). That said I'd also say quality of songwriting matters a little less here since Byrds were always consistently brilliant interpreters of other people's songs.

Indeed

Well Gene Clark was a great songwriter full stop. |seems to have been a pretty flawed human being but it does seem to have fed into his songwriting.

I think that John Einarson biography of him Mr Tambourine Man was pretty good, but most of his bios have been anyway.

yeah that einarson book is excellent.

Lotta good stuff on this thread too: Byrds POX

I"m sure I said this before but the Byrds' two best albums are Younger Than Yesterday and Notorious, and those are the two albums were Chris Hillman stepped up... he is by far the most underrated Byrd.