Rolling Metal Thread 2012

I think its usually 100 and he refuses to participate. Last year he got others to join him.

hah xp

I've said this all before, but since you keep prodding I'll say it again. I think there are plenty of ways to discover new stuff, like reading this rolling thread, for example. A best of/year in review should be about the things the voting community agrees on, not everything each member likes. The ballots we all post after do a great job of that, and I don't think the poll should try.

Again, different strokes for different folks.

I think 100 is still too much, because the voting pool is small. The whole ILM community only does a top 77 with way more voters.

noted, phil. no worries.

xp

and it misses out on a LOT of good albums as a result.

I'm pretty sure I voted last year despite my reservations. Maybe not though. I definitely voted in the main poll.

Every cutoff misses great records. Just lost them all and have fun.

List not lost. Fucking phone.

once the results are in hardly anyone is interested in albums in other peoples ballots. Its far more likely an album getting its 15 mins of fame in a longer rollout will get way more checking it out than it showing up in someones ballot.

But if you're not happy with the way myself,jjj and glenn run the poll, then feel free to run it yourself without us if you think you can do better.

Dude, it's nothing against any of you! I keep telling you to have fun because people seem to like your style. It's not my thing, as I've said for years, and instead of being snarky this time I was friendly and explained my thoughts.

Again, have fun and do that thing you do. But don't take it personally when I don't participate. I was always at the fringes of centricity (or however that was phrased) anyways so my missing votes won't even matter much.

the only thing that matters is the poll. And if it can be run better and get more participants by someone else running it i'm happy to step aside.

Dude, don't be silly. I have nothing against any of you or how you choose to run a poll. I just explained why I'm not participating and wasn't even snarky about it (for a change, I freely admit). I have a different philosophy, that's all.

Good luck, have fun, and my historically fringe votes won't even be missed very much.

ag, i have no idea why i bother, but here goes:

if you want to turn people on to new records, a top-200 rollout is an awful way to do it. i don't have time to listen to samples from 150 records. i also don't have time to follow a thousand-post thread that takes days and days to finish. if you did a top 50, i could follow the whole thing and listen to many of the ones that i hadn't heard.

but you're going to do whatever you want so

it was not me who mentioned a top 200 fwiw it was ez snappin

you did 125. my point stands.

well, we could dispense with a rollout completely and just put a full list in one post just like how it happens in a magazine.

Do we have to have this argument every year?!

Apparently.

but i'll tell you what. I'll come up with a few formats then run a standard poll with them and we agree to abide with the results. That way everyone has their say. Cant say fairer than that.

ez does,jeff.

Dude, just do a top 50 or 100. 200 is WAY too much. I really appreciate the hard work you put in running the poll, but since this thing is supposed to be for the community and not something that you came up with yourself (like the 70s and 80s polls), I feel like the community does have a say in the rollout – And it seems like the community is saying that they want a smaller list.

dear j3ff i did not say i was doing a top 200. That was ez snappin.

Okay, piss off AG. You asked a question, I gave a short, succinct answer and you just kept picking and poking.

Do whatever makes you happy dude, and don't worry about pleasing me or me carping about it anymore. I'm done.

Best wishes, etc.,

What kind of EOY Metal Poll do you want this year?

And i put a no poll option for phil

Angry metal dudes! It seems AG is trying hard to accommodate here. Personally I really don't understand the complaints about longer rollouts. If you don't think they're fun or useful, just wait for the last day when the top 10 or whatever are revealed. What's the big friggin deal?

I cant please everyone and no matter what I do someone is unhappy so there's a poll to decide. Whatever ilx wants ilx will get and we need to abide with that.

Voting no poll.

please keep the discussion off this thread and do it on What kind of EOY Metal Poll do you want this year?

so this thread can run as normal thanks.

There's a new Pig Destroyer video. Does anyone like it?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d6dycCqqZS0

I dig the distinctly un-metal styling. Also, monkeys with guns - what's not to like?

I like a hundred plus poll 'cause it gets me outta my metal comfort zone to try new earth shakin' tunes...

can you say that on the other thread please. Best to keep it off this thread so you dont annoy others.

Here's this week's Lazarus Pit, not metal at all but close enough: http://www.decibelmagazine.com/featured/the-lazarus-pit-midnight-syndicates-born-of-the-night/

Is there a new Cauldron album coming out?

There is! http://open.spotify.com/album/1oDZtKLf6PMDwSuoRs9cEW

At my job I've been working on generating automatic introduction playlists for arbitrary genres of music. Here are a couple I did in the process of fiddling with the code:

Gothic Symphonic Metal: http://open.spotify.com/user/glennpmcdonald/playlist/1s6DGJAFH8vA1LHFkQnrTU
Black Metal: http://open.spotify.com/user/glennpmcdonald/playlist/7b10dwILeYCI8D5KJfUdZp

Got one for doom?

Doom: http://open.spotify.com/user/glennpmcdonald/playlist/72BfNj0kefmNpIcEtRnJcv

I generated and posted that without checking it song by song, so let me know if you spot anything egregiously inappropriate.

thanks!
A couple of borderline things maybe but nothing major

Funeral Doom: http://open.spotify.com/user/glennpmcdonald/playlist/5QMc6xIa7x3uNpA6V8xk9G

As you'll see, this has plenty of overlap with the plain "Doom" list, but that makes sense.

thanks!

Hi Glenn. If you don't mind me asking, how are you automating the content of these playlists?

And, by request, Atmospheric Black Metal: http://open.spotify.com/user/glennpmcdonald/playlist/3p6x9xQv5aR46SFULNg61x

Raoul, I work for http://the.echonest.com.

the band Weedeater that opened for Saint Vitus was one of the loudest bands i've ever seen, way louder than swans who i saw last year

Weedeater is boss. I totally need to see them live.

"the band Weedeater"

Hey roxy I think Beast in the Field has put an album out or is about to put an album out. Have you heard it yet?

its coming out in january. cd, no vinyl til march. i've only heard one track - doesnt seem like a big departure, still the same ol' world-ending doom, really good.

also i cant believe this is their 5th album. time flies.

Right on

Glenn that must be a fun job. I've never heard of echonest but it looks like i use your clients. Well, Spotify at least.

oh cool new weedeater