Bob Dylan: The Bootleg Series

wish there was a solo piano demo of man in me on the new bootleg series. love dylan's piano playing.

I just discovered "All the Tired Horses" on Self-Portrait – I can only imagine how that must've been received at the time of its release.

I think Greil Marcus' response has gone down in history.

I could barely get through the first page of it.

kinda interesting to hear Kooper's version of "Went To See The Gypsy" in light of these other versions
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_EGnIgNkbwA
seems like everyone had pretty different ideas of how this song should go!

isn't "went to see the gypsy" supposed to be about Elvis? or am I making that up?

that's how I hear it

that's the theory -- makes sense to me, vegas, big hotel, etc. greil marcus says in the new liners that he doesn't hear it, but grein of salt there.

Even if it isn't about Elvis, it is about Elvis.

ha! yeah... like "The Hole He Said He'd Dig For Me" by Jerry Lee. Can't not be about Elvis.

On Another Self Portrait... I've read far too many reviews expressing the need to re-evaluate the original album based on the material included in Bootleg #10. Idiots; then and now.

the first time i heard self-portrait was in my local record store and the guy working was playing it...i asked him "this dylan bootleg is awesome, where did you get it?" and he said "this is self-portrait"

i dunno, i'm pretty into self portrait, but i have no idea what I would've thought of it when it came out.

i mean, i can see how someone in 1970 would think it was the most out of touch record bob dylan could possibly put out. which in some ways was the point, and in some ways is why it's actually a good record.

the Pitchfork review was excellent fwiw

this era in general has the feeling of bob dylan being free of the weight of being Bob Dylan

this era in general has the feeling of bob dylan being free of the weight of being Bob Dylan

how is what you said a contradiction? He started being himself by being free of the weight of Bob Dylanness.

I meant the same thing I think, free of being Bob Dylan: Voice of a Generation

the Pitchfork review was excellent fwiw

― first I think it's time I kick a little verse! (Alfred, Lord Sotosyn), Friday, August 30, 2013 5:17 PM (Yesterday) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

Ah yes, the customary "it's not all hip-hop mixtapes and metal" Pfork review of an archival release by an irreproachable sacred cow; a review that fails to quote a single Bob Dylan lyric in a review of a fucking Bob Dylan record. Yes, indeed, Bra-VO.

Sorry if it seems like I'm picking on you, Alfred. I do disagree - quite vehemently - with your review of Blue Jasmine from that other thread, but I posted the above before I saw your name on the original post, so, coincidence. In this case, it's the Richardson review that made me wanna barf, not your praising of it. It's out of my system now, carry on, I was never here, etc

Got the 2cd today, so great

Bob's "oh my goodness" during Days of 49 is one of my new fav Bob moments

Yes, but technically that's not Bob saying that. It's the rambling sign.

Ah yes, the customary "it's not all hip-hop mixtapes and metal" Pfork review of an archival release by an irreproachable sacred cow; a review that fails to quote a single Bob Dylan lyric in a review of a fucking Bob Dylan record. Yes, indeed, Bra-VO.

erm I'm glad it doesn't quote Dylan lyrics! The review creates a context, which is, "We non-boomers are not as full of shit as our parents. What's your excuse?"

Another great Days of 49 moment.... "thoseweredaysof49"

"Ah yes, the customary "it's not all hip-hop mixtapes and metal" Pfork review of an archival release by an irreproachable sacred cow"

pfork is all hip hop tapes and metal? those are usually the buried 4th-5th reviews on the "newest albums" page

there is a metal review like every day

that is a lot

the singing on both self portrait and bootleg series versions of "days of 49" is atrocious

No way dogg

This is so good

a review that fails to quote a single Bob Dylan lyric in a review of a fucking Bob Dylan record. Yes, indeed, Bra-VO.

There aren't too many "Bob Dylan lyrics" to quote from SP.

So far the ultimate Dylan Sunday morning album

"New Morning (Van Morrison Remix)"

the singing on both self portrait and bootleg series versions of "days of 49" is atrocious

You remind me of New York Jake, the butcher's boy, spoiling for a fight.

i mean he hits bum notes all over the place. not his usual wavering "i am the Volk" tone but just fucking bum notes. kind of massacres the song like that aunt of yours who is tone deaf. the outtake on the new set is better than the one on the original LP but it's still, and i quote, "atrocious."

this is from a guy who thinks dylan can really sing. i mean REALLY sing. some of the stuff he writes for himself is challenging to sing and he pulls it off. you must leave now take what you need you think will last. that's a hard line to sing, go ahead try it. but his singing on days of 49 and some other stuff is just so bad. i think something was happening to his voice. he says he laid off cigarettes so maybe that's it. starting smoking, stopping smoking can fuck your vocal cords up for a while.

listening to this, i'm struck by how much dylan was really sticking to a basement tapes approach, just taking it outside the basement. (talking about the actual basement tapes sessions, not the official LP). trying out covers to stimulate creativity, writing "genre" songs, trying out different voices... he doesn't seem like he's having quite as much fun, but he's in a big studio in nyc or nashville, not someone's house, I guess.
anyway, really enjoying this set -- i definitely want more of these thoughtfully compiled overviews of specific eras from the bootleg series.
oh and hey, speaking of "thoughtfully compiled overviews," this site is where it's at: http://thousandhighways.blogspot.com/

i bought this. they had exactly one copy at the FYE atore. as i noted elsewhere, when i was paying for mine one of the FYE dudes was on the phone with someone who wanted to know if they had any John Philip Sousa. Americana day. and it was labor day at that.

i have listened in the store but i would have to take it home and really listen to have anything to say. sounds cool. i like Self Portrait anyway so i figured i'd dig it. i still haven't read the GM essay.

I DLed the 2cd version and am getting pretty sucked in with each listen. Tyler otm that this is like the rest of the basement tapes, the part that was all Ian and Sylvia covers and shit.

Now I really want the god damn Isle of Wight part!!! That version is 21 bucks at emusic. Which would be almost my whole emusic credits for this month. Grr I bet I'm gonna do it.

yeah i saw you could DL the mp3s of the isle of wight stuff, but it is expensive on amazon too. lamesville. i will probably break down and get it. amazing that they make playing in front of 100,000+ people sound like they're playing in an upstate NY living room.

No digital option for the remastered original album, it seems...

irritating. let me pay you a reasonable amount of money for these things, record company!

Jon - check your facebook mail.

Ruh roh!

Amazon MP3 Store has the 2-CD tracks plus Isle of Wight, 53 tracks in all, for $27.98, last time I checked. I might get that.

Remastering's not gonna help the original Self-Portrait, unless they mix down a bunch of strings etc., and even then some of the vocals are way too bland, and deliberately so, according to Chronicles. He wanted to deflate great expectations, exploitations, etc.

Dude just wanted Weberman to stop digging through his garbage.

I downloaded the 2 CD version of this from eMusic. I think this is one of my favorite Dylan periods. He was (is?) a great interpreter of traditional songs. World Gone Wrong was another big discovery for me recently. This sounds great too. It reminds me that my copy of New Morning sounds like crap. I have the pre-remaster version though. Does the reissue sound as good as this? It would be worth buying it again if it does.

better - re-mastering plus studio sound, but 'natural'

i really need to illegally download the isle of wight show *cough cough is anyone holding cough cough*

i bought the 2cd like a good citizen but this is just fuck you territory by the label IMO

while you're waiting just watch this

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gWfiAK0EKSo

why don't you guys just download this stuff illegally like everybody else? bob dylan doesn't need your money (much less sony).