CLASSIC ROCK TRACKS POLL: THE RESULTS

I was at a club tonight and got behind the drums and sat in on a jam session for a bit and...for the first time in my life, "FREE BIRD!" was yelled at me while I was onstage playing music.

this poll is cursed, man.

a+

this thread/poll rules. party on, everyone, and a huge thank you to some dude and gr8080

because of this thread i just totally killed at REO Speedwagon & 38 Special on Rockband <3

Good morning, folks. It's time to recreate what has yet to be created, whatever the hell that means.

http://i.imgur.com/lwXVoRU.jpg

60. The Doobie Brothers – What A Fool Believes
991 points, 15 votes

So many great keyboard sounds. So many great beard sounds.

This is the one time in the poll where I will join in on the "is this classic rock enough?" handwringing. In my mind Michael McDonald-era Doobies is less CR than pre-MM Doobies, and even then "Takin' It To The Streets" is the most classic rock MM single, this feels like much more of a crossover pop hit, don't think I've heard it on rock radio in a long time.

Agreed

This song's rhythm was as often imitated as totos dink dink dink piano

Robbie Dupree 'hot rod hearts' etc

Yesterday we left off with Fleetwood Mac, and this morning we started with the Doobie Brothers. I guess this means we've got a Doobie Mac sandwich here...reminds me of the time I got pulled over by the cops and had to hide a joint in my McDonald's burger.

http://i.imgur.com/M2OqgE3.jpg

59. Fleetwood Mac – Dreams
993 points, 15 votes

lol

This song's rhythm was as often imitated as totos dink dink dink piano

― before you die you see the rink (Jon Lewis), Wednesday, July 30, 2014 7:41 AM (11 minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

Robbie Dupree's "Steal Away," Pablo Cruise's "Love Will Find a Way," the Spinners' version of "Working My Way Back to You"...

speaking of dreams, is everyone still in bed today or what

c'mon ppl it's HUMP DAY

How's the traffic looking on the 67/167?

Two in a row for me + evil woman yesterday makes it 3/50. Still enough space for all of them!

So far this thing belongs to Stevie Nicks

The traffic heading into Nazareth is heavy this morning, hopefully you won't be feeling half past dead when you pull in.

http://i.imgur.com/6WAU6hz.jpg

58. The Band – The Weight
1002 points, 14 votes

A Band hater wore me down over the years and now I look at their shtick as no better than that of Eages...can't hear the music for the overall ickiness (of RR mainly)

What on earth?

totally gonna start referring to the Eagles as Eages though.

Eagles! C'mon, there's a well known subset of people who find them pretentious and phony baloney with all the Civil War get ups, etc. But now every hipster asshole in the world looks like them ca. 68.

riffin' and beboppin' over a typo is pretty inventive stuff, though, how's life. Algonquin Round Table-level, well-done

Xposts alfred otm I meant steal away not hot rod hearts.

That photo is infinity times better than the actual song

Some dude and gr8080 in fine form this morning.

I thought the weight would at least be in the top 50. I had it at 6.

A Band hater wore me down over the years

http://lunaticfaith.files.wordpress.com/2011/11/b-combatting_cult.jpg

I had The Weight at Number 3. Who are these Band haters and what happened to their souls?

Or lack thereof

I think they are people who saw the Last Waltz and assumed that, since everyone in that movie looks like awful phonies or complete wastes, all the members of the band were like that all of the time instead of the reality, which is that the complete wastes could really play well and dreadful phony Robertson was never as important a part of the group as he portrayed himself to be.

It takes a Grade-A stick in the mud to resist the charms of Levon Helm

that's what his girlfriends said

"Fool" was on my ballot, quite high, till pretty late. I cut it, not for not being CR, but for not being as CR as the two Doobies cuts I had in there. I'm sure I've heard it on these stations, but would concede that a station trying to fight down a reputation as being 'soft' might purge it. Fantastic song and recording though, never gets old.

"The Weight" is great too, though I have heard it a few too many times, especially in the last decade or so, since that one cell phone commercial where the dude is driving across the country and birds, trees, whatever are gracefully aligning in cell phone bar patterns to this tune. Feel like its profile has gone up considerably, and while a solid song, it can't quite bear the, uh, burden. It also feels weirdly long for 4:34. Needs a bridge or something to mix up the verse-chorus thing.

Ugh The Weight is such a good song. I had it pretty low in my ballot and it was one of my voter's remorse placements.

The verses are all great though, and switching up the singers varies it enough for me.

I figure I'll probably 'get' the Band some day?

Do you have to deal with solo Robbie Robertson in the US?

Didn't vote for it, but should have. The harmonizing "an -- annn -- annnnndddd" in the chorus is a wonderful thing.

Love "The Weight," and I never noticed that it didn't have a bridge before, mainly because it never sounded to me like it needed one. The vocal interplay/grappling is plenty thrilling enough. Levon's "yyeah!" simultaneous with his fill after Danko's verse is one of the great moments in sound.

I had this weird dream the other day where The Band recreated the What You Want video with Helm = Ad Rock, Danko = Diamond, Manuel = MCA. Garth was spinning the records and when it was all said and done, Robbie Robertson stood under a tree, playing guitar with a loop of the main riff repeating while the credits scrolled MUSIC BY ROBBIE ROBERTSON. LYRICS BY ROBBIE ROBERTSON. PRODUCED BY ROBBIE ROBERTSON. DIRECTED BY ROBBIE ROBERTSON.

It kinda worked with those Civil War outfits.

Do you have to deal with solo Robbie Robertson in the US?

― EveningStar (Sund4r), Wednesday, July 30, 2014 9:40 AM (1 minute ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

Haven't heard any on the radio since his awful first solo record came out, but in 1987 it was irritatingly inescapable.

Yeah, I think the media picked up on his s/t 1987 album because Lanois was a hot producer at the time and U2 was involved with a couple tracks. Otherwise, it was about the most UN-1987 thing one could imagine.

and Peter Gabriel!

My local station played "Somewhere Down the Crazy River" about half an hour ago. Shit is still inescapable here.

Love The Weight but voted for Up On Cripple Creek instead.

The Weight is a great song, but The Staple Singers have the definitive version imo.

the weight is a great song, but i cannot recall ever hearing it on crr

(regional differences rear their head itp etc etc)

the weight is a great song, but i cannot recall ever hearing it on crr

― resulting post (rogermexico.), Wednesday, July 30, 2014 2:06 PM (11 minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

I believe you but I find that astounding!