POLL Will Tear Us Apart – ILM Artist Poll #86 - JOY DIVISION – New Order solo or other groups Poll (aka the Electronic poll) – a NEW ORDER (#37) supplement poll --- Results Thread

(For those who have lost theirs)

I would have expected "Disorder" to fall behind "Transmission" and "Atmosphere," but hey, what do I know? Interesting results. Thanks Bee!

Top to bottom...

Transmission
Atmosphere
The Kill
Exercise One
Ice Age
Disorder
Atrocity Exhibition
Colony (Peel Session)
Sound of Music (Peel Session)
Twenty Four Hours (Peel Session)

Out of Control (Chemical Brothers)
Getting Away With It (Electronic)
What Do You Want From Me? (Monaco)
Get The Message (Electronic)
Wheels Over Indian Trails (Stanton Miranda)
Tighten Up (Electronic)
The Patience of a Saint (Electronic)
Forbidden City (Electronic)
Tasty Fish (The Other Two)
Selfish (The Other Two)

Movement
Still
Substance (Joy Division)
The Complete BBC Recordings
Power, Corruption & Lies
Substance (New Order)
Unknown Pleasures

My ballot. I included a Sumner production; I could've included Hooky's production of "Elephant Stone" too, I suppose.

1. Transmission
2. Decades
3. Isolation
4. Shadowplay
5. Heart and Soul
6. Love Will Tears Us Apart
7. Atmosphere
8. She’s Lost Control
9. Disorder
10. Atrocity Exhibition

1. Electronic – Get the Message
2. Quando Quango – Love Tempo
3. Electronic – Getting Away with It
4. Monaco – What Do You Want From Me
5. The Other Two – Selfish
6. Electronic – Forbidden City

My ballot

Joy Division Tracks

Disorder
Love Will Tear Us Apart
Transmission
Atmosphere
Digital
She's Lost Control
Twenty Four Hours
Dead Souls
Shadowplay
Interzone

Solo or other tracks

All Electronic except where noted:

Getting Away With It
Idiot Country
Disappointed
Tighten Up
Reality
Feel Every Beat
Forbidden City
Tasty Fish (The Other Two)
Selfish (The Other Two)
Get the Message

Albums

Substance 1987
Technique
Unknown Pleasures
Low-Life
Brotherhood
Electronic
Power, Corruption & Lies
Closer
Republic

Love that Twenty Four Hours placed so high. I used to listen to the live version from the 'Still' cassette over and over:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kQl5tpEEHM0

I never would have predicted "Disorder" at #1. Cool result though!

My ballot:

Part 1 (JD):

Love Will Tear Us Apart
New Dawn Fades
Shadowplay
Twenty Four Hours
Transmission
Day of the Lords
Disorder
Sound of Music
A Means To An End
Warsaw

Part 2 (songs):
Monaco, What do You Want From Me
Electronic, Getting Away With It
The Other Two, Selfish
Electronic, Get the Message
Electronic, Idiot Country
Electronic, Gangster
808 State feat. Bernard Sumner, Spanish Heart
Electronic, Tighten Up
Electronic, Some Distant Memory
Electronic, Reality

Part 3 (albums):
Joy Division, Unknown Pleasures
New Order, Technique
Joy Division, Substance
New Order, Power Corruption and Lies
Electronic, Electronic
Joy Division, Complete BBC Recordings
New Order, Substance

Unless I've missed something, "Failures", "Komakino", "From Safety To Where", and "As You Said" were the only JD tracks that didn't receive votes (not including pre-1978 Warsaw era demo recordings that were never released on Factory).

Ballot. Next time The Other Two would definitely make it in before the two Twisted Tenderness tracks.

Joy Division tracks:
Transmission
Disorder
Atmosphere
Love Will Tear Us Apart
Decades
Twenty Four Hours
Dead Souls
Isolation
Insight
Passover

Solo or other group - these are all by Electronic:
Some Distant Memory
Get the Message
Reality
Tighten Up
Try All You Want
Getting Away With It
The Patience of a Saint
Idiot Country
Twisted Tenderness
Vivid

Albums
New Order - Technique
New Order - Substance 1987
Joy Division - Substance
New Order - Brotherhood
New Order - Power, Corruption and Lies
Electronic - Electronic
New Order - Low-life

my ballot

Twenty Four Hours
The Only Mistake
Decades
Insight
Atmosphere
Something Must Break
Novelty
The Eternal
Transmission
A Means to an End

My ballot

Part One (Joy Division, ranked):

Day of the Lords
New Dawn Fades
Disorder
Shadowplay
Atmosphere
Interzone
She's Lost Control
Wilderness
Digital
A Means To An End

Part Three (albums, ranked):

Unknown Pleasures
Closer
Movement
Power, Corruption & Lies
Substance (Joy Division)
Substance (New Order)

My ballot

Twenty Four Hours
Transmission
Heart & Soul
Shadowplay
Love Will Tear Us Apart
Passover
Decades
Disorder
She's Lost Control
Atmosphere

Joy Division:
Transmission
Ceremony
Atmosphere
Insight
Decades
Love Will Tear Us Apart
Isolation
Disorder
Shadowplay
Incubation

Solo etc. (ALL ELECTRONIC)
Some Distant Memory
Idiot Country
Soviet
Gangster
Tighten Up
Disappointed
Patience of a Saint
Get the Message
Getting Away With It
Feel Every Beat

Wow, great JD results. My ballot:

New Dawn Fades
Twenty-Four Hours
Shadowplay
Candidate
Insight
Disorder
Novelty
Atrocity Exhibition
Day of the Lords
Transmission

I thought "New Dawn Fades" was a fan favourite. I'm a little surprised I was the only #1 vote.

It's definitely one of my favorites.

My whole Top 10 made the Top 10, so great results!

1. Transmission
2. Atmosphere
3. New Dawn Fades
4. Shadowplay
5. She's Lost Control
6. Love Will Tear Us Apart
7. Dead Souls
8. Twenty Four Hours
9. Decades
10. Disorder

Thanks for the poll Bee OK!

JD tracks

1 Disorder Preston 1980
2 She’s lost control Evidently Chickentown/BBC vers
3 Ceremony (Still v)
4 New Dawn Fades (UP vers)
Shadowplay
Isolation
Love will tear
ice age
dead souls
atmosphere

ALBUMS

U Pleasures
Preston 1980
Still
Closer
Les Bains

JD

The eternal
Atmosphere
Decades
Love will tear us apart
Transmission
She's lost control
Isolation
Shadowplay
New Dawn fades
24 hours

OTHER

Electonic - Getting away with it
Disappointed
Get the message
Some distant memory
Idiot country two
Imitation of life
Patience of a saint
Monaco - What do you want from me

ALBUMS

Technique
Electonic
Closer
Power corruption & lies
Low life

1. Love Will Tear Us Apart
2. Shadowplay
3. Ceremony
4. Transmission
5. She's Lost Control
6. Days of the Lords
7. Dead Souls
8. I Remember Nothing
9. Heart and Soul
10. Decades

thanks to those who kept the Spotify up to date!

Spotify (ILM Joy Division) https://open.spotify.com/user/beeok/playlist/5jWdl7QBLtDJvmhCzw77l2

Albums Full Results

16 Albums
16 Ballots

1 Power, Corruption & Lies 596 Points 15 Votes
2 Unknown Pleasures 526 Points 12 Votes 5 #1
3 Technique 504 Points 11 Votes 5 #1
4 Closer 473 Points 11 Votes 1 #1
5 Substance 1987 - New Order 471 Points 11 Votes 3 #1
6 Low-Life 423 Points 11 Votes
7 Substance - Joy Division 405 Points 10 Votes
8 Electronic 322 Points 8 Votes 1 #1
9 Brotherhood 232 Points 6 Votes
10 Movement 163 Points 4 Votes 1 #1
11 Still 120 Points 3 Votes
12 Republic 071 Points 2 Votes
13 Singles (2013) 046 Points 1 Votes
14 The Complete BBC Recordings 040 Points 1 Votes
15 Waiting For The Sirens' Call 036 Points 1 Votes
16 1981-Factus 8-1982 035 Points 1 Votes

New Order Solo or other Groups Full Results

33 Songs
18 Ballots

1 Getting Away With It - Electronic 753 Points 17 Votes 5 Number Ones
2 Get the Message - Electronic 652 Points 16 Votes 2 Number Ones
3 What Do You Want From Me? - Monaco 395 Points 10 Votes 1 Number One
4 Disappointed - Electronic 366 Points 9 Votes 1 Number One
5 Some Distant Memory - Electronic 352 Points 8 Votes 3 Number Ones
6 Tighten Up - Electronic 346 Points 9 Votes 1 Number One
7 The Patience of a Saint - Electronic 326 Points 9 Votes
8 Gangster - Electronic 275 Points 7 Votes
9 Reality - Electronic 273 Points 7 Votes
10 Idiot Country - Electronic 248 Points 6 Votes (1 vote for "Idiot Country Two" (AKA ultimatum mix))
11 Selfish - The Other Two 182 Points 5 Votes
12 Forbidden City - Electronic 172 Points 5 Votes
13 Try All You Want - Electronic 164 Points 4 Votes 1 Number One
14 For You - Electronic 116 Points 3 Votes
15 Tasty Fish - The Other Two 105 Points 3 Votes
16 Spanish Heart - 808 State 104 Points 3 Votes
17 Feel Every Beat - Electronic 101 Points 3 Votes
18 Dark Angel - Electronic 84 Points 2 Votes 1 Number One
19 Out of Control - The Chemical Brothers 83 Points 2 Votes 1 Number One
20 Don't Know What Love Was - Hot Chip, Bernard Sumner & Hot City 81 Points 2 Votes
21 Soviet - Electronic 75 Points 2 Votes
22 Vivid - Electronic 68 Points 2 Votes
23 Twisted Tenderness - Electronic 67 Points 2 Votes
24 Shoot Speed/Kill Light - Primal Scream (Bernard Sumner (guitar 2000)) 50 Points 1 Vote 1 Number One
25 This Time I'm Not Wrong - Sub Sub feat: Bernard Sumner (vocals, guitar, 1997) 50 Points 1 Vote 1 Number One
26 Love Tempo - Quando Quango 46 Points 1 Vote
27 The Real Thing* - Gwen Stefani 43 Points 1 Vote
28 Elephant Stone (12" version) – The Stone Roses 40 Points 1 Vote
29 Wheels Over Indian Trails - Stanton Miranda 38 Points 1 Vote
30 Imitation of Life - Electronic 36 Points 1 Vote
31 Until the End of Time - Electronic 36 Points 1 Vote
32 Looking From a Hilltop (Megamix) - Section 25 34 Points 1 Vote
33 Freefall - Electronic 33 Points 1 Vote

Joy Division Full Results

26 Ballots
38 Songs

1 Disorder 848 Points 21 Votes 6 Number Ones
2 Transmission 825 Points 19 Votes 5 Number Ones
3 Atmosphere 811 Points 20 Votes 1 Number One
4 Shadowplay 787 Points 20 Votes 1 Number One
5 Twenty Four Hours 661 Points 17 Votes 3 Number Ones
6 Love Will Tear Us Apart 640 Points 16 Votes 3 Number Ones
7 She Lost Control 620 Points 16 Votes 2 Number Ones
8 New Dawn Fades 506 Points 13 Votes 1 Number One
9 Dead Souls 444 Points 12 Votes 1 Number One
10 Decades 425 Points 11 Votes 1 Number One
11 Heart and Soul 351 Points 9 Votes
12 Isolation 323 Points 9 Votes
13 Ceremony 258 Points 6 Votes
14 Digital 252 Points 7 Votes
15 The Eternal 238 Points 6 Votes 1 Number One
16 Day of the Lords 233 Points 6 Votes 1 Number One
17 Atrocity Exhibition 216 Points 6 Votes
18 A Means To An End 197 Points 6 Votes
19 Insight 151 Points 4 Votes
20 These Days 143 Points 4 Votes
21 Passover 135 Points 4 Votes
22 Warsaw 111 Points 3 Votes
23 Something Must Break 104 Points 3 Votes
24 ice age 72 Points 2 Votes
25 Novelty 70 Points 2 Votes
26 Interzone 68 Points 2 Votes
27 Sound of Music 67 Points 2 Votes
28 The Only Mistake 46 Points 1 Vote
29 The Kill 43 Points 1 Vote
30 Candidate 40 Points 1 Vote
31 Exercise One 40 Points 1 Vote
32 autosuggestion 38 Points 1 Vote
33 No Love Lost 35 Points 1 Vote
34 Colony (Peel Session) 34 Points 1 Vote
35 I Remember Nothing 34 Points 1 Vote
36 Wilderness 34 Points 1 Vote
37 leaders of men 33 Points 1 Vote
38 Incubation 32 Points 1 Vote

Thanks for running the poll, Bee! This was a fun poll -- I wasn't sure what to expect from such an odd mishmash of mini-polls but the results turned out better than I expected.

I don't think Bee OK has posted since this poll, sad face.

I watched Control last night and made me think of this poll.