Star Wars 8 shit talk

https://i.imgur.com/oLNSkND.gif

lol nm i'm bad at this

God, you are such a moron.

He doesn't "learn that slavery is bad." He learns that beneath the bright, shiny surface of a planet of unimaginable largesse and beauty -- the kind that he's never seen before, given that this takes place literally days after previous movie, and for which he's tempted to lump the whole fight and stick around -- lies a corruption supported by war profiteering and abuse.

This shit is all there, on the screen and in dialogue. Hell, there are people in this thread complaining that it's too on-the-nose. And yet you somehow (somehow!) failed to get it.

xxp

this seems like a worthwhile diversion

He should have known slavery is bad tho. Jedi Master Lincoln outlawed it.

Finn was raised by stormtroopers. I'd imagine he doesn't know much about the galaxy in general.

Yea he makes sense as someone who is in touch with the galaxy, a few weeks ago he didn't have a name and had spent 20+ years wearing the same uniform

*not in touch

Like, if people don't like the movie, fine, don't like it. But to not like it just because you're incapable of understanding what's happening in it is your fault, not the movie's.

Side question - what SW comics if any are worth reading

cognition-shaming itt rn

Side question - what SW comics if any are worth reading

Doctor Aphra is good, too -- she's like a mostly-amoral space Indiana Jones. She was introduced in the prior Vader series and got her own title this year.

Thanks!

http://www.nme.com/news/film/star-wars-the-last-jedi-porgs-origin-debut-puffins-2182100

is there a "backstroke of the west" version yet? he asks anxiosly

the porgs were no less dumb than any other cutesy creature that has been embedded in this series from more or less the beginning. They barely registered with the exception of the incredibly bad looking cooked one.

i cannot compute not loving Poe

he is an angel from heaven

― Squeaky Fromage (VegemiteGrrl),

i like poe, probably because i love oscar isaac

I don't know how the cat in ILD didn't wanna jump his bones at all times

Oscar Isaac is good, but they're not really giving him a whole lot of interesting stuff to do.

I do like the idea of having an incredibly charismatic rebel leader making really bad decisions ultimately leading to many many deaths.

star wars ix: a most violent year

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DRmasQaVQAAaoSq.jpg

bwahahaha

Christ

I love that audiences are so hair-trigger with freaking out that ten seconds of silence warrants an entire FYI message to be taped on the door

like would these people have been watching The Day After and screaming at the TV during the prolonged nuclear explosion scene "OMG THE SOUND"

That is sad

could also be just overreaction by the theatre. nobody in my IMAX opening night showing lost their minds

also maybe a joke, in reference to that one theater where the sound was off from the very start and the audience almost tore the place down

found something with zoom & enhance:
https://i.imgur.com/Ypy8d2Q.png

lol

Hahaha

I almost want to make it my life's goal to get that line in one of the movies somehow.

ROFLZ

star wars ix: a most violent year

GIVE CLAP ME CLAP NAR CLAP SHADDAA

Still a little scared, because, JJ Abrams? the JJ stands for Jar Jar

lots of posts critiquing the "suicide run" that Holdo went on as a major flaw.

I understand to a degree the points being made, but in a universe that's often been arbitrary and contradictory, feels a little weird that *this* is a dealbreaker for some people (and not some of the really egregious shit in the OG trilogy)!

But I'll take people arguing about that any day over the assholes saying that "social justice warriors are ruining Star Wars". :/

Just been reading Nova Express by Burroughs, this line of dialogue (from a section on 'biologic film') seemed prescient -

"We seen this five times already and not standing still for another twilight of your tired Gods."

Emo Kylo Ren has been killing it: https://twitter.com/KyloR3n

the backlash is officially annoying now. this forbes clickbait shit popped up on my phone this morning: https://www.forbes.com/sites/scottmendelson/2017/12/21/as-the-last-jedi-tops-600m-worldwide-can-star-wars-recover/#5162e84e146e

This was okay. And who knows, perhaps if Rian Johnson gets free reins his trilogy could be genuinely good. Most of the stuff that annoyed me had to do with The Force Awakens. The First Order is still a giant miss, nonsensical, filled with nothing characters, and Kylo Ren's personal darkness completely overwhelms whatever that sorry bunch of idiots is trying to do. The way they apparently had a whole bunch of backup plans to execute right after the destruction of Starkiller base made me think of the Doctor Who Master Trilogy, where in Castrovalva it becomes completely stupid how many backup plans there is.

My little brother said afterwards that the scene with Luke staring down the whole mechanized army was the first moment in the whole series where he felt as if the Jedi were so mythologically superhuman badass as they're always made out to be. And it's undercut in a great way, but still, it's awe-inspiring in a way they haven't always been. He is right about that.

This is really good, and says much better what I was trying to say upthread about Finn's story arc: https://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2017/12/the-last-jedis-biggest-storytelling-innovation/548609/

When Finn wakes up in The Last Jedi, he’s similarly only interested in Rey (who has left to find Luke Skywalker), and quickly decides to abandon the Resistance fleet because of their desperate situation. He’s caught mid-escape attempt by Rose, a below-decks engineer on a Resistance freighter, who has none of his dubiousness over their shared cause. Her sister, a gunner, heroically dies in the film’s opening sequence; Rose doesn’t want her sacrifice to have been in vain. Quickly enough, she and Finn are drafted into a risky mission to combat the First Order’s tracking of Resistance ships.

Rose is a wonderfully sneaky character, in that she’s set up as a plucky sidekick but almost immediately becomes a crucial teacher, and equal partner, for Finn. Her certitude about the Resistance is not tied up in a noble idea of heroism, but in her understanding of what they’re trying to overthrow. She was born on a mining colony, she tells Finn, that was stripped of resources by the First Order and then blitzed for weapons testing. When the two journey to a casino city draped in finery named Canto Bight, Rose rolls her eyes at Finn’s delight, pointing out that it’s a haven for arms dealers that runs on slave labor.

During their travels, Finn and Rose meet DJ (Benicio Del Toro), a thief who happily sells his skills to the highest bidder and tells Finn there’s no moral absolutism in the galaxy. “It’s all a machine, partner,” he warns. “Live free, don’t join.” At the start of The Last Jedi, Finn might have believed that: He’s still a runaway from the First Order trying to get as far away from the action as possible. By the end, he’s committed to taking them down, slaying his evil former master, Captain Phasma (Gwendoline Christie), in a charged showdown on a First Order ship. “You were always scum,” she scoffs. “Rebel scum,” he replies proudly, embracing an identity he’d once tried to escape.

i thought "you must have a million questions" "where's Rey?" and then a quick cut to the next scene, was some kind of genius.

left: I’m just a porg boy nobody loves me

Right: HE’S JUST A PORG BOY FROM A PORG FAMILY SPARE HIM HIS LIFE FROM THIS MONSTROSITY pic.twitter.com/SSfV0QvUk3

— merry brittsmas 🎄❄️ (@supbruss) December 21, 2017

lots of posts critiquing the "suicide run" that Holdo went on as a major flaw.

This just seems like the kind of thing that SF pros can easily come up with some after-the-fact explanation of why it works in this case and not in every dreadnought-vs-hyperdrive-equipped-ship scenario. I feel like this scene and the salt-skiiing skimmers with their red plumes both offered that primal "HOLY SHIT AWESOME" which is one of the things I come to Star Wars for. And then you make up whatever explanation you have to make up in order to facilitate that feeling.

The only thing that annoyed me about that scene was that she waited so long to do it. She just stood and waited while the transporters got shot down.

made up explanation: the transporters have to be a certain distance away or the polar-ray dynasphere effect of actuating the hyperdrive matrix will scramble their navigational circuits