ILM’s Top 77 Tracks of 2018

The highest vote getter per artist places, all others by said artist are dq'ed. Sounds easy. xps

I don't even remember the earlier Mr Twin Sister track, but "Jaipur" is really good, probably the best new-to-me track so far

Mr. Twin Sister's "Jaipur" really makes apparent the continuity with the earlier records by this band, when they were called "Swing Out Sister"

okay I’m back to hating mgmt again now, that one is fucking ghastly, order is restored unto to the world

The highest vote getter per artist places, all others by said artist are dq'ed

Yep. With the full results and "pure" placements shared after the poll is done, ideally.

I don't like that myself but see what the people think

so if I vote for ten 1975 songs, only one of those ten votes counts? tbc, I would also prefer no repeats, just trying to think through how this would affect the poll

let's save this discussion for the poll

ok

tbh if applied to this poll it would kill Geyser, which I am slightly loath to accept tbh as I prefer it to Nobody and it's here on merit

here's an idea: every year we do a best of the 80s poll simultaneous to the EOY poll so y'all can get this shit out of your system

I'm also someone who preferred the previous Mr. Twin Sister album, but I'll have to give Salt another chance. I do think that "Keep on Mixin'" is a great lead-off track (love the polyrhythmic beat), and "Jaipur" sounded nice just now in the poll playlist.

If you're voting for 10 tracks by the same artist, may I interest you in the albums poll?

if y'all are having this conversation now i'd like to suggest it should've happened in 2013 or whenever vampire weekend had like thirty tracks in the 77

from a record i liked!

I never vote for tracks that appear on albums I vote for, but that's me.

I've probably been suggesting this every year since around then lol

so that would boot out like, 15 songs, give or take? what's the #92 result look like in terms of votes and such?

there'd definitely a strategic element to this, for example "Music is Worth Living For" was not my favorite song on the AWK album but I ranked it higher b/c I knew it was more likely to place than say, "Break the Curse"

I almost never have any tracks/albums overlap, but I made a couple exceptions this year

xp
I mean I wouldn't personally do that, I was just thinking of hypotheticals. I am genuinely confused by people who see two tracks by one artist place and think "I hope [track #3] places too"

I never vote for tracks that appear on albums I vote for, but that's me.

― Your sweetie-pie-coo-coo I love ya (Alfred, Lord Sotosyn), Tuesday, January 29, 2019 1:34 PM (one minute ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

iirc, the Lex was a stickler for this, too

OK, this Talaboman track is great, I'm a sucker for things that should be boring but somehow never stop growing on me for 11 minutes (the repeated ping in this case)

cool as it is atm imo

I don't like loads of repetition of acts but I'd dislike popular tracks getting the boot more.

emil.y has it

a true testament to the 70s german scene

also, refusing to vote for tracks by an artist you've voted for in the albums poll is insanity imo

I use the lex/Alfred rule as a way to cut down my tracks ballot, but I always end up making a couple of exceptions

I have too much love to give to spend it all on under 48 or so artists

(And now I’m playing “2000 Elefanten” again. Very cool track. Will check out the album)

ya i vote for my favorite things and sometimes my favorite big things have favorite little things in them

i mean, i did tbf cut tropical fuck storm and daphne & celeste out of my tracks ballot because i'm more invested in the album as a whole, but there were some artists where i just could not avoid voting for them in both polls and to do so would have defied my year in music

would've been weird if DNA placed last yea, but not Humble

*year

If you're voting for 10 tracks by the same artist, may I interest you in the albums poll?

I'll start a poll once both rollouts are done. let's reconvene on the subject then

this mgmt song is pretty good

maybe i'll check out the album

album is solid! I always like when seemingly flash-in-the-pan acts turn out to have some longevity

I never vote for tracks that appear on albums I vote for, but that's me.
― Your sweetie-pie-coo-coo I love ya (Alfred, Lord Sotosyn), Tuesday, January 29, 2019 1:34 PM (one minute ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

iirc, the Lex was a stickler for this, too

― jaymc, Tuesday, January 29, 2019 1:37 PM (twenty-one minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

people who do this are just scrubs smh

breastcrawl otm
Most of the artists I root for these days release tons of great singles but v few albums.

If only the highest song places and the others are disqualified I don't see how it resolves vote-splitting.
If there's no consensus that's it. Placing several songs is actually a good sign.
+1 at not voting for album tracks being madness.
Every time I come back to this thread and press on "skipping...", I automatically land on Andrew WK giving me thumbs up :s

Hop Along was my #2, super happy to see it place

I think the only way to artificially reduce track possibilities is through nominations: don't give 40 nominations per user, force them to be disciplined.

It doesn't seem to be on Youtube, can I listen to it anywhere without having to sign up for a streaming service?

― Tuomas, Tuesday, 29 January 2019 Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

you can go to a nearby factory and sit near an industrial fan

― my tweet portal is whack (voodoo chili), Tuesday, 29 January 2019 Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

A++

top three for today is something like (having not heard Autechre but I can tell what kind of thing it is and it'll be a fine from me n' all):

46: Mr. Twin Sister – “Jaipur”
54: Talaboman – “Dins El Llit (Superpitcher Remix)”
60: Cardi B featuring Bad Bunny and J Balvin – “I Like It”

Worst had to be Smoko. Sounded like lj was responsible for this?

would have still made the 77 without my 6 points

I like that Hop Along song but voted for "Somewhere a Judge" instead.

I would definitely support curtailing nominations to max of 20 overall or fewer.

If an album has 5+ nominations, you could do a short poll to narrow it down to 1 or 2.

I’m opposed to this curating/curtailing of nominations. Let a thousand flowers bloom (or wither, whatever the case may be).