hall of fame, next vote...

Agree about Beltran. I would expect Helton to make it in before Rolen does

My Beltran post above should read "*unless* people seriously think that ..."

I think both Helton and Rolen will make it this year. They're rapidly trending upward (both received less than 20% of the vote in their first year), the "controversial" players (Schilling, Bonds, Clemens) aren't clogging up the ballot anymore, and the class of incoming first-timers is fairly weak.

I agree about Beltran's stats, but I do think it will hurt him--in a weird way, losing the Mets job might hurt him more than what caused it. Just guessing; we'll see.

I think ppl will see the astros as more “between the lines” than steroid era and that the vitriol is LA/NYY pissiness about losing their respective series #costalbias

At this point with everything, you got so many people NOT in because of this or that who actually gets elected is kind of a who cares. It was just like 'some' media people trying to put asterisks on asterisks on Judge getting the home run record, it really does not much matter anymore.

Answering my own question above (courtesy Posnanski): who are the 16 voters on the Veteran's Committee this year?

Hall of Fame Players: Chipper Jones, Greg Maddux, Jack Morris, Lee Smith, Ryne Sandberg, Frank Thomas, Alan Trammell

Executives: Paul Beeston, Theo Epstein, Arte Moreno, Kim Ng, Dave St. Peter, Kenny Williams

Media Members/Historians: Steve Hirdt, LaVelle Neal, Susan Slusser

https://blogs.fangraphs.com/in-naming-the-era-committee-members-the-hall-again-cant-avoid-the-specter-of-cronyism/

I wish Trammell had cronyed Lou Whitaker back onto the ballot.

Didn't realize this is tonight. Fred McGriff's sitting by the phone right now.

Kind of nervous they’re gonna install fuckhead mcgee

Posnanski puts him at 59%.

and this might seem funny coming from a blue jays fan; but i never thought of Mcgriff as a HoF'er...i won't be annoyed if he gets in or anything, but don't really feel he belongs either.

I know what you mean, and I'd vote for Delgado ahead of him, but I think he'll be a fine addition. I was trying to think of a comparable HOF'er, and I think Tony Perez is a good fit: consistent power hitter without eye-popping seasons, respected by other players, popular with fans. McGriff was better, and he was definitely better than Harold Baines. (Not the ideal way to approach this, I know.) From '88 to his great strike-season in Atlanta, he was maybe one of the best half-dozen hitters in the game. He dropped off slightly after that, while everything around him exploded. In '96, he hit 28 HR and knocked in 107; Brady Anderson hit 50 HR that year. in 2001, at the age of 37, he hit 31 HR and knocked in 102; that was the year Luis Gonzalez--Luis Gonzalez--hit 57 HR. (I know I shouldn't be using RBI...just shorthand for his consistency.) I'm sure he was tempted to join the party. He didn't, he just kept putting up the same solid season year after year.

Said it before but mcgriff being as far as we know a “clean” dude, maybe that tips him a bit more into the HOF discussion. I don’t necessarily think HOF caliber guys who maybe/probably/definitely juiced should be kept outta the hall (though I’m not shedding any tears either tbh) but it’s good to contextualize freddy’s numbers a bit in light of all that. Bonus points for the nickname.

How did he even get that name?!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McGruff_the_Crime_Dog

Ya that was a dumb question. Had a night and still not at my best just yet.

Unanimous for Fred!

(Fuckhead McGee and everyone else passed over.)

Mattingly - 8/16
McGee - 7/16
Murphy - 6/16

Everyone else fewer than 4 votes.

Did not expect unanimous at all!! Guess he goes in as a brave?

happy for him

Braves probably make the most sense, but wouldn't be surprised if he's one of those hatless guys.

Keeping with the idea of how consistent he was:

A.L. - 10 seasons, .284/.384/.506, 132 OPS+, 28.4 WAR
N.L. - 10 seasons, .284/.370/.512, 137 OPS+, 24.3 WAR

Almost twice as many bWAR with the Jays as with the Braves, but he won a WS in Atlanta, and played in two there, so if he does pick a team, probably them.

Shd go in in the emanski hat not joking

Being Canadian, had to look that up!

http//www.youtube.com/watch?v=2T-TYMPQSbE

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2T-TYMPQSbE

What did Willie McGee do? I don't recall any controversy as a player or a coach about the dude other that Howard Cosell making fun of how he looked as a cheap shot.

lol i too was offended by the use of willie's surname in such a manner

i think yous owe him an apology

I watched the announcement online, and they didn't even have him set up for a phone call--not fair.

Very important:

Never forget that Fred McGriff makes an appearance in Home Alone pic.twitter.com/SsJLBU9Bef

— Three Year Letterman (@3YearLetterman) December 5, 2022

McGriff's entry gets my full endorse ment.

Brady Anderson hit 50 HR that year. in 2001, at the age of 37, he hit 31 HR and knocked in 102; that was the year Luis Gonzalez--Luis Gonzalez--hit 57 HR.

have we on ilb accused brady anderson of juicing?

or merely of having the most insane outlying season of all time?

I am, to be honest, definitely insinuating that those two totals were assisted by PEDs. Why would they stop? I can see where those seasons were such eyebrow-raising outliers (as opposed, to say, all the Greg Vaughns and Jim Edmonds who were power hitters already, and jumping from 30 HR a year to 40-45), they thought "Well, I got away with this this year, maybe better not press my luck"). But it's a good question and a fair point.

New popular theory ALSO involves the ball being juiced in that time frame

Right. I think there were non-juicing guys who benefitted from that (and two expansions, and maybe all the new parks being built, although I don't know if they helped on balance), and other guys who threw PEDs into the mix, and then there are Anderson's '96 season and Gonzalez's '99 season where you just have say wait a minute--really? 50 HR for a guy who never hit more than 24? 57 for a guy whose career-high is 31?

Of the two of them, Anderson using then stopping would be the harder one to explain. By '99, I recall that suspicion was mounting quickly about inflated HR totals; I could see Gonzalez feeling a spotlight on him. But I don't think the subject was even being discussed in '96.

could have just had an off year. you still gotta hit it.

Story of his career: Fred already bumped off mlb.com's front page by all of today's news.

We've got a Tom Emanski shout-out from Fred McGriff in his Hall of Fame press conference: "This ain’t my Tom Emanski hat. It’s a whole lot better."

— Emma Baccellieri (@emmabaccellieri) December 6, 2022

I know it played almost no role in why he got in, but McGriff was really durable. From his first full season with the Jays in '88 to his age-37 season in 2001, he never played fewer than 144 games or had fewer than 586 PA. Except for the two strike seasons, that is, where he played 113/114 games in '94 and 144/144 in '95. For those 14 seasons in total, he played 97.5% of his team's games.

McGriff was sort of a Willie Stargell type, minus the 40 HR seasons (he'd have had one of those, and 500+ for his career, if there was no strike) and the MVP award. I also always enjoyed his swing, that windmill thing he did was shockingly effective. And this isn't some Jack Morris revisionist history, but at his peak ('88-'94, every year in the top 4 in HR) he was a very intimidating hitter.

Not sure when the voting started, but they've got 64 votes in so far.

Leaderboard: http://www.bbhoftracker.com/2022/11/2023-bbhof-tracker-summary-and-leaderboard/

Spreadsheet: https://onedrive.live.com/view.aspx?resid=F2E5D8FC5199DFAF!47464&ithint=file%2cxlsx&authkey=!AOiVOHV1SzKLAR0

Always hard to glean much from early voting, but Andruw Jones (68%) doing much better than I expected.

Vizquel getting fast-tracked to irrelevance in these discussions

Sheffield made zero gains last year but this year he’s picked up a decent number of votes. It’s not a Larry Walker type surge tho.

Helton and Rolen both around the same number of votes but if I had to bet money on one making I’d put it on Rolen. Wagner continuing to make strides.

Mark Buehrle looking like the type of guy who will linger on these ballots forever.

jeez, mark buehrle was incredibly durable for his era. did he ever miss time on the DL? except for his partial debut season and his final season, he pitched 200+ innings every single year. in his final season, 2015, he pitched 198.2 innings, which, you know, let's just round up to 200 there.

https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/30372428/why-everybody-vote-andy-pettitte-hall-fame

(xpost) John Gibbons tried his damnedest to get Buehrle those 200 innings in 2015; gave up five hits and eight runs in 0.2 innings against the Rays his final start. (All eight unearned...don't remember how that happened.) Cost us homefield advantage in the playoffs, and that did end up mattering.

Also: he was starting on one day's rest!

yeooooooowch. kind of a crappy way to toss your last regular season game, too!

Interesting to compare Andruw Jones and Torii Hunter. Not that they're much alike, but a) both have a ton of Gold Gloves (10 consecutive for Jones, 9 consecutive for Hunter) and the same OPS+ for their careers (111 for Jones, 110 for Hunter). Hunter was still playing well in his late 30s, Jones decline and early exit started at 30/31. Jones is ahead in bWAR (62.7 to 50.7); in voting, he leads Hunter 68.6% to 0.0% at the moment.

Weird thing is how Hunter hasn’t lost any votes so technically still on track for +5%