When we were teenagers, my sister and I used to occasionally try to decide on what the greatest pop song ever written might be. The debate would always conclude with one of us asking, "Hang on, what about Captain of Her Heart?" I'm not sure that I don't still hew to that belief! The recording is touched with a rare kind of magic. I've also always suspected that it was an influence on The Blue Nile during the recording of Hats - cf. the arrangement of "The Downtown Lights".
I just quickly ran through it on my piano, and I noted that the chorus melody is closely aligned to the underlying chords. The progression isn't standard-issue circle-of-fifths stuff, but it's not exotic either - just an emotionally-satisfying sequence of (mostly major) triads.
― Vast Halo, Wednesday, 20 June 2018 19:48 (five years ago) link